Medical Apartheid: From Israel/Palestine to Canada

Independent Jewish Voice Canada has applauded Human Rights Watch and B’Tselem for declaring Israel an apartheid state in its treatment of Palestinians. However, neither organization included medical apartheid in its charges. Though their statements were widely reported worldwide, the Canadian Broadcast Corporation (CBC) refuses to publish any information critical of Israel.

Canada has a long history of humanitarian hypocrisy with regard to racial and ethnic discrimination. During World War II, “none is too many” referred to European Jewish refugees fleeing from Nazi Germany who were refused admission and sent back to Germany. Yet on April 15, 2021, Israel Independence Day, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau stated “For over 70 years, Canada and Israel have been close friends, steadfast allies, and partners in many international organizations. Our personal ties and common values unite us, including our commitment to freedom, democracy, and the rule of law.“ Leaders of all Canada’s political parties unequivocally support Israel: Canada was the only country on the UN Human Rights Council to vote against a ceasefire in Israel’s illegal, disproportionate attack on Gaza in 2008/09; former Liberal Party leader and renowned ethicist Michael Ignatieff stated that he did not lose sleep over Israel’s massacre of a Canadian family fleeing Israeli bombardment and went on to defend the use of torture in international law if it prevented a greater evil; Canada has extensive weapons/surveillance and security agreements with Israel.

*On Feb 16 2021, Democracy Now reported that Israel has halted the shipment of 2,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccine to the Gaza Strip, where they were due for medical workers. The besieged territory is home to more than two million people but has yet to receive any vaccine. This comes as Israeli health officials reported a nearly 95% drop in symptomatic coronavirus infections among 600,000 Israelis who received Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine. About 30% of Israeli citizens have received at least one vaccine dose — the highest rate of any major nation — but that figure excludes Palestinians in the Occupied Territories who remain largely unvaccinated.

*25 March, 2021: the number of vaccines received so far by the Palestinian people represents only a ‘drop in the sea’. After recent annual consultations with Member States, the United Nations Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices* today expressed deep concern over reports that Israel, while donating surplus COVID-19 vaccines overseas, has failed to fulfill its international legal responsibility and obligation to ensure the vaccination of the Palestinian population. Israel sent vaccines to Guatemala and Honduras – two countries that moved their embassies to Jerusalem.

*According to Ha’aretz: Additional vaccine doses will allow Israel to provide booster shots to entire population through 2022.

*Israel’s vaccine data: 53.5% of the population fully vaccinated.  As of April, 3% of Palestinians have been vaccinated. The population of Israel/Palestine is approximately equally divided, with 5.5 million Palestinians living in the West Bank, Gaza, and within Israel’s green line. The Gaza Strip has received only about 120,000 vaccine doses. In the West Bank, most ICUs are at 100% capacity. Non-intensive hospital beds are at 97% capacity.

*In Gaza, Israel controls the import of everything through closures of land/sea/air borders. As of 3/20, there has been a dire shortage of health facilities, medicine (deficit 45% drugs, 31% med supplies, 65% lab and blood bank), PPE. As of 4 /7/21, Gaza has its highest daily number of infections since the start of the pandemic with a positivity rate as of 4/24 at 43%

*Daily infection rates are now surpassing 2,000 new cases every 24 hours; a significant portion of the new cases are being traced to newer, more deadly variants, including the British variant.

For updates, Dr. Alice Rothchild of the Jewish Voice for Peace Health Advisory Council provides updates on the current Covid situation in Palestine.

At the international level, there are innumerable collective and individual demands to end medical apartheid, challenging (1) nation states for their apartheid practices contravening international law, particularly as they affect the social determinants of health; the UN has been ineffective in implementing the Apartheid Convention, a “crime against humanity”; and (2) intellectual property rights over vaccine patents, and the power of the unelected World Trade Organization which will meet on May 5 to make this life/death decision affecting millions of people worldwide. Covid-19 as of April 2021 has killed 2.5 million people. In Canada, the federal government decided to draw on a supply of coronavirus vaccines from COVAX, a World Health Organization program designed to help some of the world’s poorest countries access more affordable vaccines. While other countries, like New Zealand and Singapore, similarly received vaccines from COVAX, Canada won distinction for being the only G7 country to dip into the fund.

In an April 24, 2021 Letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Ontario medical students state:   “Clearly, the unprecedented rapid and global scientific progress has been made at the expense of low- and middle-income countries (LMICs)…. Canada has joined some high-income countries and has not supported the IP waiver.” Petition e-3181 (Health)petition was read into the parliamentary record: “We, the undersigned, people of Canada, call upon the Government of Canada to support the proposal from India and South Africa for a waiver from certain provisions of the TRIPS Agreement for the prevention, containment and treatment of COVID-19 at the WTO TRIPS Council without delay.”

Pharmaceutical patents fall under the WTO Trade-related Agreement on Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), meaning that access to this life-saving vaccine falls to a small group of people whose sole mandate is to protect and ensure the free flow of capital. The unelected decision-makers never advocate for the free flow of refugees, for children trapped in ICE, for slaves on cargo ships, for intellectual “property”, for life’s necessities like potable water.

Judith Deutsch is a member of the Socialist Project, Independent Jewish Voices, and  former president of Science for Peace. She is a psychoanalyst in Toronto. She can be reached at:   judithdeutsch0@gmail.com.

[i]
[i]
[CDATA[ $('input[type="radio"]
[CDATA[ $('input[type="radio"]
[CDATA[ $('input[type="radio"]
[CDATA[ $('input[type="radio"]