A Modest Proposal: Instead of Saying Tribal, Let’s Say Christian

David Brooks, competitor with Thomas Freidman for the title of the New York Times sophist-in-chief, dropped this phrase into his painfully superficial column on the coronavirus on Friday, March 20, “All those tribal us-them stories don’t seem quite as germane right now.”

There it is again: tribal.

Is the Slide Into Tribal Politics Inevitable?” was the headline of a Trump election post mortem in the New York Times on November 17, 2016. Amy Chua’s much heralded 2018 book Political Tribes: Group Instinct and the Fate of Nations is another example. For a long time now we have been swamped with a tsunami of tribal associations from academics, pundits and bloggers in every nook and cranny of the mainstream media universe.

You might not notice the frequency or find it the least bit off-putting. I do because I pay close attention to the vocabulary of white supremacy.

There are, of course, appropriate uses of the word, including by people who self-identify as members of tribes, pueblos and other Native organizations. Its use as a pejorative reflects centuries of propaganda portraying conflict among indigenous people through the white gaze. Sometimes tribal and its variations are deployed faintly as though it’s just a convenient and neutral description. Sometimes it’s uttered in an overtly condescending way.

This is not to deny that there were conflicts between Native peoples in what is now called North America. And other places inhabited by people of color too. The question is, what to make of that?

As a white man, when I hear or see a word like tribalism, a fuzzy scene of bare-chested battling warriors in headdresses comes to mind. Others may conjure imagery suggesting a different idea of “primitive” people. That’s no accident. It’s how we have been trained.

White supremacy is nothing if not a high-powered myth-making machine. After all, skin color does not actually make any human “better” in any way whatsoever than any other human. It takes complex social constructs and social systems to allege otherwise.

Language does a lot of the work. Here’s an example, “…the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.”

Did you recall that passage from your civics class? Probably not. But it’s definitely in the subconscious of your inherited social mind. It’s from the Declaration of Independence.

If we are going to stereotype, why not tribal as a positive, describing instances when indigenous people avoided or reduced conflict. Weren’t they being tribal then too?

Bruce Pascoe, author of a 2014 long overdue revision of racist stereotypes about aborigines in Australia says they constructed, “a system of pan-continental government that generated peace and prosperity.” Here in the U.S., all the murdering, treaty breaking, buffalo exterminating and land stealing has apparently overwhelmed the role of “smoking the peace pipe” in the cowboys and Indians version of our collective memory.

Actually, the very idea that the primary form of organization of indigenous people is by tribe as opposed to by nation or some other phrase is itself part of the ideology portraying whites as “civilized” and non-whites as primitive, barbaric or savage.

Most often, hand wringing about so called tribalism trivializes what our current political conflict is about. It’s like reducing the Civil War to violence between the Northern Tribe and the Southern Tribe. As if war for its own sake is just the nature of those homo sapiens arbitrarily situated on either side of the Mason-Dixon line. Which would be another way of saying it wasn’t about slavery.

As with the Civil War, present-day disputes are also about fundamental values and interests. All the more reason why it’s hard to see how mischaracterizing them as “tribal” adds anything worthwhile to the discussion. Has it even somehow successfully embarrassed Mitch McConnell and Chuck Schumer into getting along better? Obviously not.

Here’s a better idea. Let’s say our society is becoming more Christian.

After all, some of the nastiest of all human-on-human conflicts have been between Christians and those of other faiths. Gas chambers were invented by German Protestants to efficiently massacre six million followers of a different religion. Not a thousand years ago. Less than a hundred years ago.

Apaches, Zulus, or Mayans didn’t do that. Sunni’s or Shiites or any other kind of Muslim didn’t do it either. White Christians did.

For that matter Christians have been slaughtering and enslaving people of color all over the planet for 500 years now. And still are. Why not then, say we are suffering from Christian politics.

Don’t like that? That’s understandable.

At the very least though let’s put tribal politics, tribalism and its other variations into the dictionary of obsolete white supremacist language like the ”n” word. If it makes people feel better, perhaps such words and phrases could be memorialized in a dedicated gallery of the white supremacy museum, maybe next to the collection of statues of Christopher Columbus and Robert E. Lee.

Even though political conflict now pales in intensity compared to earlier eras in U.S. history, some pundits use polarized or hyper-partisan. Those can work for now.

Better still, we could use the lens of Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King’s triple evils of militarism, materialism and racism, updated to include patriarchy and environmental destruction, to frame what these debates are really about.

More articles by:

Frank Joyce is a lifelong Detroit based activist and writer. He is a member of the National Writers Union (NWU) and is the former Communications Director of the UAW. He and Karin Aguilar-San Juan co-edited, The People Make the Peace: Lessons from the Vietnam Anti-War Movement. He is currently working on a book about unlearning white supremacy.  

Weekend Edition
August 07, 2020
Friday - Sunday
John Davis
The COVID Interregnum
Louis Yako
20 Postcard Notes From Iraq: With Love in the Age of COVID-19
Patrick Cockburn
War and Pandemic Journalism: the Truth Can Disappear Fast
Eve Ottenberg
Fixing the COVID Numbers
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Every Which Way to Lose
Paul Street
Trump is Not Conceding: This is Happening Here
Robert Hunziker
The World on Fire
Rob Urie
Neoliberal Centrists and the American Left
John Laforge
USAF Vet Could Face ‘20 Days for 20 Bombs’ for Protest Against US H-Bombs Stationed in Germany
Andrew Levine
Clyburn’s Complaint
Kavaljit Singh
Revisiting the Idea of Pigou Wealth Tax in the Time of Covid-19
Paul Ryder
Here Come the 1968 Mistakes Again
T.J. Coles
Fighting Over Kashmir Could Blow Up the Planet
David Macaray
Haven’t We All Known Guys Who Were Exactly like Donald Trump?
Conn Hallinan
What’s Driving the Simmering Conflict Between India and China
Joseph Natoli
American Failures: August, 2020
Ramzy Baroud
Apartheid or One State: Has Jordan Broken a Political Taboo?
Bruce Hobson
The US Left Needs Humility to Understand Mexican Politics
David Rosen
Easy Targets: Trump’s Attacks on Transgendered People
Ben Debney
The Neoliberal Virus
Evelyn Leopold
Is Netanyahu Serious About Annexing Jordan Valley?
Nicky Reid
When the Chickens Came Home to Roost In Portlandistan
Irma A. Velásquez Nimatuj
The Power of the White Man and His Symbols is Being De-Mystified
Kathy Kelly
Reversal: Boeing’s Flow of Blood
Brian Kelly
Ireland and Slavery: Framing Irish Complicity in the Slave Trade
Ariela Ruiz Caro
South American Nations Adopt Different COVID-19 Stategies, With Different Results
Ron Jacobs
Exorcism at Boston’s Old West Church, All Hallows Eve 1971
J.P. Linstroth
Bolsonaro’s Continuous Follies
Thomas Klikauer – Nadine Campbell
Right-Wing Populism and the End of Democracy
Dean Baker
Trump’s Real Record on Unemployment in Two Graphs
Michael Welton
Listening, Conflict and Citizenship
Nick Pemberton
Donald Trump Is The Only One Who Should Be Going To School This Fall
John Feffer
America’s Multiple Infections
Kollibri terre Sonnenblume
Thinking Outside the Social Media Echo Chamber
Andrea Mazzarino
The Military is Sick
John Kendall Hawkins
How the Middle Half Lives
Graham Peebles
The Plight of Refugees and Migrant Workers under Covid
Robert P. Alvarez
The Next Coronavirus Bill Must Protect the 2020 Election
Greg Macdougall
Ottawa Bluesfest at Zib: Development at Sacred Site Poses Questions of Responsibility
CounterPunch News Service
Tensions Escalate as Logging Work Commences Near Active Treesits in a Redwood Rainforest
Louis Proyect
The Low Magic of Charles Bukowski
Gloria Oladipo
Rural America Deserves a Real COVID-19 Response
Binoy Kampmark
Crossing the Creepy Line: Google, Deception and the ACCC
Marc Norton
Giants and Warriors Give Their Workers the Boot
David Yearsley
Celebration of Change