• Monthly
  • $25
  • $50
  • $100
  • $other
  • use PayPal

Spring Donation Drive

CounterPunch is a lifeboat piggybank-icon of sanity in today’s turbulent political seas. Please make a tax-deductible donation and help us continue to fight.
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail

People Music: Malignant Phallic Narcissism v. Being Ordinary

Mozart Family by Johann Nepomuk della Croce – Public Domain

David Yearsley’s fine article “Disaster Music” in April 12 CounterPunch generates thoughts about what can be called People Music. At present, global political and environmental events unfold disastrously. Yearsley writes about people in the past facing the forces of natural catastrophes, framed as People versus God in Handel’s powerful music: “…earthquakes on land and beneath the ocean will presage the coming of the Lord,” and Yearsley writes “The tsunami of retribution is the seal on God’s covenant.”

The 18th century, the Age of Enlightenment/Age of Reason, “the best of all possible worlds”, also saw vicious, now forgotten wars fought solely for power, including the 7 Years war with up to 1.4 million fatalities, the War of Spanish Succession with up to 1.2 million fatalities. Fifty years after Handel, during revolutionary times, Mozart’s greatest operas depict People versus People. There is no God figure. The finales of Don Giovanni and The Marriage of Figaro show psychopathologies of conscience interfacing with class structure and law. These extraordinarily beautiful operas tell far more about people than behavioral psychologies and the checklist diagnostic classifications of American psychiatry [DSM].

The differences between Handel and Mozart have repercussions today: climate change is often personified as an omnipresent force that “we” need to battle against, and Earth is abstracted as a generous or punitive Mother we need to protect and re-find. In much climate framing there is relative inattention and insufficient rage about the criminality and banality of actual perpetrators and colluders who are the ones who bring horror to the world’s people. War, according to international law, is a supreme crime, but not anthropogenic climate catastrophe.

The two Mozart operas focus on entitled aristocratic men. Wealthy Don Giovanni kills the father of a woman he tries to abduct. He seduces thousands of women whose nationalities and physical characteristics are recorded on a list kept by his servant whom he humiliates and taunts. Don Giovanni believes he can have whatever he wants. He is boastful and his meanness comes through in many scenes. In the finale, the father’s ghost comes to demand that Don Giovanni repent. Three times he repeats “Pentiti” and Don Giovanni resoundingly replies “No”. The ghost father’s “deathly cold hand” clasps Don Giovanni’s hand to drag him to his fate in Hell. Don Giovanni does not have an inner conscience; there is no guilt, no inner pain, and he cannot even acknowledge that his tormentor is the father he has killed. The only possible brake comes from external authority. He experiences physical sensations but not emotional feelings. He does not connect the physical pain that begins to consume him with what he has done.

“Who lacerates my soul?
Who torments my body?
What torment, oh me, what agony!
What a Hell! What a terror! where do those flames of horror come from?”

In The Marriage of Figaro, Count Almaviva claims the droit de seigneur, the right of “first night” over his servant Figaro’s fiancee. The plot revolves around couples: the count and countess, the servant Figaro and his fiancée, an older couple, and a homosexual person’s first infatuation. Out of these people’s capacity to love and to feel concern about the Countess’ pain due to the Count’s narcissistic, thoughtless betrayal, they devise a way to confront him with his hurtful behavior. In the finale, the Count suddenly sees through other people’s eyes what he has done. His face expresses inner pain and shame. In the Metropolitan Opera staging, the Count bows down before his wife and with lowered eyes he sings “Perdone” and rests his hand on hers. Three times he says to her “Perdone” and she answers that she is kinder than him and that she will forgive him. The music expresses the utmost tenderness.

Finnish psychoanalyst Pentii Ikonen has written about what he terms the phallic-narcissistic universe. A body-focused narcissistic phase of early childhood is an expectable time of pride and pleasure for both boys and girls, a time of “look at me. See what I can do.” Yet fixations and developmental arrests at this phase are deeply pathological and dangerous to others. “What matters is one’s own purpose, not the purpose of the other, and so mutuality is of no concern…. The mutuality that takes another into consideration is seen as a sign of weakness or guile.” Ikonen writes of the disappointment of living within limits. He states that phallic fantasies are in one way or another violent; there is a phallic equivalence between destructiveness and sexuality so that “any sort of breaking (spoiling or conquering) will pass for a phallic display of sexual power or potency.” Phallic meanness is irrational. “It is motivated solely by the desire to hurt another, to injure him or even kill him. The motive is not the need for food or money, nor revenge, jealousy or competition over something, although imagined malice will often masquerade as some such motive.”[1]

Certainly these traits are readily observable in many women and men in positions of power. What draws them together are the incapacity to use realistic guilt and shame and to have a constant sense of the realness of other people. Quinn Slobodian’s history of ‘Geneva School neoliberals shows them to be oblivious to ordinary human experience, ominously similar to Hannah Arendt’s understanding of Eichmann. It was reported that after the first atom bomb test at Alamogordo, “the overjoyed inhabitants [ nuclear scientists] of Los Alamos gathered in groups all over town to celebrate. ‘There were tears and laughter…. We beat each other on the back, our elation knew no bounds … the gadget worked!’…. Feynman got his bongo drums out and led a snake dance through the whole Tech Area.” Years after Hiroshima and Nagasaki, many brilliant scientists still can’t see the human world. [2]

Contrast this with First Nations political prisoner Leonard Peltier puts it beautifully: “You must understand….I am ordinary. Painfully ordinary. This isn’t modesty. This is fact. Maybe you’re ordinary, too. If so, I honour your ordinariness, your humanness, your spirituality. I hope you will honour mine. That ordinariness is our bond, you and I. We are ordinary. We are human. The Creator made us this way. Imperfect. Inadequate. Ordinary. Imperfection is the source of every action. This is both our curse and our blessing as human beings. Our very imperfection makes a holy life possible. We’re not supposed to be perfect. We’re supposed to be useful.”

This does not in any way imply that being ordinary means acquiescing to malignantly narcissistic and indifferent people. Mozart’s Marriage of Figaro shows ways that people can be decent and confront appalling behavior in the powerful. Ordinary people throughout history “rage against the dying of the light” (Dylan Thomas).

[1] Ikonen, Pentti (1998). From oedipal problems to phallic universe. Child Analysis: Cleveland.

[2] Conant, Jennet (2005). 109 East Palace: Robert Oppenheimer and the secret city of Los Alamos. Simon and Schuster: New York. P. 314-316. Also see the work of Daniel Ellsberg and Robert J. Lifton.

More articles by:

Judith Deutsch is a member of the Socialist Project, Independent Jewish Voices, and  former president of Science for Peace. She is a psychoanalyst in Toronto. She can be reached at:   judithdeutsch0@gmail.com.

bernie-the-sandernistas-cover-344x550

Weekend Edition
May 17, 2019
Friday - Sunday
Melvin Goodman
Trump and the Middle East: a Long Record of Personal Failure
Joan Roelofs
“Get Your Endangered Species Off My Bombing Range!”
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Slouching Towards Tehran
Paul Street
It’s Even More Terrible Than You Thought
Rob Urie
Grabby Joe and the Problem of Environmental Decline
Ajamu Baraka
2020 Elections: It’s Militarism and the Military Budget Stupid!
Andrew Levine
Springtime for Biden and Democrats
Richard Moser
The Interlocking Crises: War and Climate Chaos
Ron Jacobs
Uncle Sam Needs Our Help Again?
Eric Draitser
Elizabeth Warren Was Smart to Tell FOX to Go to Hell
Peter Bolton
The Washington Post’s “Cartel of the Suns” Theory is the Latest Desperate Excuse for Why the Coup Attempt in Venezuela has Failed
Doug Johnson Hatlem
Analysis of Undecideds Suggests Biden’s Support May be Exaggerated
Peter Lackowski
Eyewitness in Venezuela: a 14-year Perspective
Karl Grossman
Can Jerry Nadler Take Down Trump?
Howie Hawkins
Does the Climate Movement Really Mean What It Says?
Gary Leupp
Bolton and the Road to the War He Wants
Jill Richardson
Climate Change was No Accident
Josh Hoxie
Debunking Myths About Wealth and Race
David Barsamian
Iran Notes
David Mattson
Social Carrying Capacity Politspeak Bamboozle
Christopher Brauchli
The Pompeo Smirk
Louis Proyect
Trotsky, Bukharin and the Eco-Modernists
Martha Burk
Will Burning at the Stake Come Next?
John W. Whitehead
The Deadly Perils of Traffic Stops in America
Binoy Kampmark
The Christchurch Pledge and a Regulated Internet
David Rosen
Florida’s Sex Wars: the Battle to Decriminalize Sex Work
Ralph Nader
Trump: Importing Dangerous Medicines and Food and Keeping Consumers in the Dark
Brett Haverstick
America’s Roadless Rules are Not Protecting Public Wildlands From Development
Alan Macleod
Purity Tests Can be a Good Thing
Binoy Kampmark
Modern Merchants of Death: the NSO Group, Spyware and Human Rights
Kim C. Domenico
Anarchism & Reconciliation, Part II
Peter LaVenia
Game of Thrones and the Truth About Class (Spoiler Warning)
Manuel E. Yepe
The Options Trump Puts on the Table
Renee Parsons
The Pompeo/Bolton Tag Team
David Swanson
Where Lyme Disease Came From and Why It Eludes Treatment
Cesar Chelala
Lowering Your Risk of Alzheimer’s Disease
Kollibri terre Sonnenblume
Our Problems are Deeper than “Capitalism” (and “Socialism” Alone Can’t Solve Them)
Chris Zinda
Delegislating Wilderness
Robert Koehler
War’s Unanswered Questions
Robert P. Alvarez
Let Prison Inmates Vote
Barbara Nimri Aziz
A Novel We Can All Relate To
David Yearsley
Carmen’s Mother’s Day Lessons
Charles R. Larson
Review: Ziya Tong’s “The Reality Bubble”
Elliot Sperber
Pharaoh’s Dream
Elizabeth Keyes
Somewhere Beyond Corporate Media Yemenis Die
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail