Shooting in a Medical Lot: a Portland Mystery

Photos of the red Toyota Tacoma taken by the FBI after the shooting of Moncada and Contreras.

It was only a day after an ICE officer murdered Renee Good, when six Border Patrol officers patrolling east Portland in four separate vehicles began tailing a red Toyota Tacoma pickup truck, supposedly based on an anonymous tip, eventually pulling it over into the parking lot of a medical center.

There’s no indication that the driver of the truck had committed any moving violations and Border Patrol doesn’t enforce Oregon traffic laws in any event. The Tacoma hadn’t been reported stolen. Neither of the occupants of the truck was the registered owner, so there’s no way Border Patrol could know for sure who they were stopping. They were simply two Hispanic-looking people, a man and a woman, in a Toyota truck. The agents didn’t have a warrant and had no probable cause for the stop. It was another case of racial profiling, a so-called Kavanaugh stop, after the Supreme Court justice who said such incidents amount to only a minor inconvenience. In this instance, it led to a married couple being shot.

The Border Patrol agents parked their unmarked vehicles around the Tacoma, attempting to box in the truck, a common tactic that has given immigration agents an excuse to escalate if a confrontation ensues.

The six agents got out of their vehicles and approached the truck with their guns drawn, pointing to the ground, according to an FBI document. One of the Border Patrol officers later said the driver of the truck, later identified as Luis Nino-Moncada, looked “anxious and [was] visibly moving around in the driver’s seat.” And who wouldn’t be “anxious,” a mere day after Renee Good was shot in the face by an ICE officer in similar circumstances. And it turned out that Nino-Moncada had good reason to be fearful.

According to depositions from several of the Border Patrol officers taken by the FBI, several agents ordered Nino-Moncada and his wife, Yorlenys Zambrano-Contreras, to get out of the truck. Instead, Nino-Moncada put the Tacoma in reverse, hitting one of the Border Patrol vehicles (a rental). Then he moved forward, backed up again and tried to angle his way forward out of the box the Border Patrol vehicles had placed him in. At that point, one of the Border Patrol officers fired several shots into the driver’s side window. I repeat: the side window. Nino-Moncada was hit twice: once in the arm and once in the leg, while Zambrano-Contreras sustained a more serious bullet wound to the chest.

The FBI claims they couldn’t find any video of either the traffic stop or the shooting: no body cam or dashboard footage, no cellphone or security cam video–highly unusual given that ICE and BP agents are encouraged to film their encounters to provide titillating footage for DHS and the White House to exploit on Social Media.

Even though wounded, Nino-Moncada was able to maneuver the Tacoma past the armed agents and their cars. He drove more than eight miles to an apartment complex in Northeast Portland, where the couple sometimes stayed. How he was able to elude Border Patrol’s finest and their six vehicles is something of a mystery. With both Nino-Moncada and his wife bleeding profusely, he called 9-11, not the normal response of a hardened gang member, as he was later accused of being.

Portland Police and paramedics arrived and transported the couple to the hospital. While paramedics applied a tourniquet to the bullet wound on his arm, reportedly said, “Fuck ICE” several times. Though this statement would later be used against him as evidence of animus toward immigration agents, he would hardly be alone in harboring this sentiment, especially after they’d just shot him and his wife for little to no reason.

No Border Patrol agents were injured in this bizarre incident. The wounds suffered by the Feds were to one of their cars, which FBI agent Daniel Jeffreys said sustained “significant damage,” though the photo of the Tacoma released in the charging documents shows a pristine-looking vehicle, which is a pretty good advertisement for the durability of a Toyota truck.

The Border Patrol agent, however, told the FBI investigators a now familiar refrain: he feared that Nino-Moncado might hit them with his truck. Might. Of course, he didn’t run them over or even nudge them, even after one of the agents had tried to kill him and his wife.

As soon as Border Patrol learned of the couple’s whereabouts in the hospital, the federal agents showed up and took them into custody. Zambrano-Contreras was transferred to the ICE detention center in Tacoma, Washington and later charges were filed against her in the Western District of Texas. Nino-Moncada was held in Portland, awaiting federal charges for “aggravated assault” on federal officers.

But before the couple had even been identified in the press, the smearing began. DHS took to social media to celebrate the shooting and arrest of Nino-Moncacdo and Zambrano-Contreras, claiming they were domestic terrorists and members of the Tren de Aragua gang. A day later, DHS revised its assessment downward, claiming that the couple were “suspected gang members,” but still offered no proof for the allegation.

Then Pam Bondi asserted herself into the mix, revising the unsubstantiated smear that the couple for TdA gang members: “Anyone who crosses the red line of assaulting law enforcement will be met with the full force of this Justice Department. This man – an illegal alien with ties to a foreign terrorist organization – should NEVER have been in our country to begin with, and we will ensure he NEVER walks free in America again.”

Portland Police Chief Bob Day appeared to give Bondi’s allegations some limited support when he said that the couple had been in a “nexus of association” with suspected TdA gang members. But the nexus was pretty nebulous by Day’s own admission. Through the investigation of the shooting on July 11, there became a nexus to them. Whether they were involved, I do not know. As far as I am aware, they haven’t been named as, you know, suspects.”

What’s it all about? Last summer, Zambrano-Contreras apparently agreed to have sex with a Portland man who ended up forcing her to perform oral sex on him, attempted to strangle her and then stole her money and purse. She called friends to help her get her money and belongings back. One of the friends, a man known as “Alex”, got into an altercation at the apartment and apparently, a shot was fired and the bullet casing was matched to another shooting. There’s no evidence as to who fired the shot or whether the casing was from that shooting.

“The shooting of Mr. Moncada by federal officers and the subsequent accusations leveled against the victim of that shooting follow a well-worn playbook that the government has developed to justify the dangerous and unprofessional conduct of its agents,”  said Fidel Cassino Du-Clou, the Oregon Federal Public Defender representing Nino-Moncada. “The federal government has claimed without evidence that he is a member of Tren de Aragua, just as they have many other Venezuelan citizens.”

The only people injured in this entire affair were Nino-Camara and Zambrano-Contreras. Yet, they’re the ones recuperating from bullet wounds in federal custody, smeared as terrorists.

Jeffrey St. Clair is co-editor of CounterPunch. His most recent book is An Orgy of Thieves: Neoliberalism and Its Discontents (with Alexander Cockburn). He can be reached at: [email protected] or on Twitter @JeffreyStClair3.