Even Conservatives Are Now Telling Trump His Immigration Policies “Have Gone Too Far”

Photo by Markus Spiske

When I think of Miami, I can’t think of it without Cuban coffee, Venezuelan arepas, or Nicaraguan fritanga. That’s no coincidence: in the early 1960s, the city became a refuge for those seeking freedom from tyranny and communism, shaping Miami into the city we all know and love. So much of the local culture and economy relies on immigration — making Miami the perfect example of how unrestrained ICE enforcement can chill a thriving society. 

Nine years ago, I left Venezuela looking for what my country could not offer: safety from persecution and economic opportunity. I have seen neighbors, friends, and family members do the same. Now they are concerned about the sharp increase in deportations of those without a criminal record or with a temporary legal status they previously thought was secure.

Even some Republicans are noticing. Last week, Rep. Maria Elvira Salazar, a Cuban-American Republican Congresswoman endorsed by President Trump, released an ad saying: “Mr. President, some of your immigration enforcement efforts have gone too far.” She cites ICE data from July showing that 50% of detainees had no criminal convictions or pending charges. 

In Salazar’s district, that matters: Miami-Dade County is about 70.6% Hispanic and 54.5% foreign-born, according to the Census Bureau. 

The harsh reality of such enforcement, which goes beyond Trump’s call to deport the “worst of the worst,” causes fear in those who might not be undocumented, but rather have a temporary status or are waiting for their cases to be adjudicated. A city like Miami cannot thrive when a majority of its residents fear to live their daily lives — just as US law entitles them to. 

Applying for asylum is a lawful process under US immigration law. Applicants undergo fingerprinting and background checks, and while a case is pending, an eligible applicant can obtain employment authorization. Still, permanent immigration status is not guaranteed. For Venezuelans like me, this matters. 

On September 4th, the Board of Immigration Appeals decided Maduro’s ouster constituted a change in Venezuela’s political conditions, requiring a reassessment of asylum eligibility. This opens the door to deny claims for cases still pending. 

Yet a change in leadership did not automatically eliminate fears of persecution as Venezuelans perceive it. The UN agrees: a fact-finding mission determined that arbitrary arrests and torture continue while the institutions supporting them remain intact. 

For example Javier Oropeza, a former Venezuelan mayor and opposition leader spent the last two years in exile. He was detained on September 17 by Venezuelan authorities two days after returning to the country. His detention sparked unrest, and authorities eventually released him. But his case proves that fear of persecution, especially for less prominent figures, is still very much real. 

Venezuelans whose claims are denied fall into the category of immigrants without a criminal record who may be picked up in ICE raids and sent to a country where conditions essentially remain the same. In some cases, they are detained while their claim is still pending.

Luis Galeano, a Nicaraguan journalist, fled the Ortega-Murillo regime after he was stripped of his Nicaraguan citizenship in 2023. He came to the United States, applied for asylum, obtained a work authorization, and built a life here. In September, amid the increased presence of immigration authorities in Miami, he was detained while working as a Lyft driver. He is now being held at Krome Detention Center in Miami-Dade County, while his case is pending. 

Fear of detention also comes from attending regular immigration appointments. Orlando Delgado arrived in Florida and applied for asylum protesting in his native Cuba.  As a documented political dissident, he had a legitimate credible fear claim, yet he was detained during a routine immigration court appearance back in 2025. As he described it, agents closed the court abruptly and took him into custody, leaving his wife without a husband, his seven-month-old baby without a father, and both without their only source of income.

The DHS has defended courthouse arrests by insisting that “nothing prohibits arresting a lawbreaker where you find them,” even after the Justice Department admitted in March that the memo used to justify them “does not and has never applied to civil immigration enforcement actions in or near immigration courts.” 

So what can those in the midst of immigration proceedings rely on when the government cannot agree on what the rule is?

America has a legitimate interest in enforcing its immigration laws, but arbitrarily treating people like criminals when they follow the law benefits no one.

Daniel Pinero is a Venezuelan dissident living in the US.