FacebookTwitterRedditEmail

Globalizing the War on Indigenous People: Bolsonaro and Modi

Photo: G. Miranda, FUNAI, Survival International.

A man who has repeatedly romanticized dictatorship and advocated the use of torture seems like an odd choice for guest of honor at the annual celebration of the constitution in the biggest democracy in the world. However, it makes perfect sense that Brazil’s notorious President, Jair Bolsonaro, has been invited to India’s Republic Day parade by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Authoritarian nationalism is on the rise across the globe and anti-democratic leaders are now at the helm of the world’s biggest democracies, including India and Brazil, as well, of course, as the USA. This is bad news for everyone, but minorities are particularly at risk as these demagogues claim that “their” rights must be sacrificed for the national good. Bolsonaro and Modi have already taken several significant strides down this dangerous path.

While Bolsonaro’s war against Brazil’s indigenous peoples has been covered extensively by the international press and received a great deal of attention on social media, far less noise has been made about what’s happening to the forest-dwelling people of India. India is home to more tribal people than any other country on Earth: Out of the estimated 370 million indigenous and tribal people worldwide, over 100 million live there.

There is growing national and international concern about the impact on Muslims of India’s Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) and National Register of Citizens (NRC), but this legislation is catastrophic for tribal communities too.  According to tribal activist and writer Gladson Dungdung:

“Adivasis [tribal people] will be denied their citizenship, detained in the detention camps and intruders will be rehabilitated in their land and territories. This is unacceptable. Adivasis are first settlers of the country, they must be kept out of the CAA/NRC and their land, territories and resources must be protected.”

Land theft is a core element of the existential threat facing indigenous and tribal people at the mercy of dominant societies worldwide. In recent years, this threat has accelerated in both India and Brazil as Modi and Bolsonaro’s administrations pursue populist, majoritarian agendas that entail commandeering indigenous land and resources “for the good of the nation.”

Last week, Kayapo chief and activist Raoni Metuktire convened a meeting of Brazilian indigenous peoples “with the goal of coming together and denouncing that a political project by the Brazilian government of genocide, ethnocide and ecocide is underway.” This meeting was partly in response to Bolsonaro’s latest attack: proposed new legislation to open up indigenous reserves for resource extraction, such as mining for gold and oil, and economic activities like agriculture and tourism. If the bill passes, indigenous communities will have no power to veto such projects.

State-sanctioned land theft is occurring in India on an almost unfathomable scale. There are up to 8 million forest-dwelling people currently facing eviction from their land; a number roughly equivalent to the population of New York. This is the result of the government’s gross mishandling of a court case that challenged the Forest Rights Act (FRA), legislation which guarantees the rights of people living in India’s forests. Demonstrating its contempt for the people concerned, the Indian government’s Ministry of Tribal Affairs didn’t even turn up at court hearings to defend its own law.

The outcry against this exceptionally flawed decision has led to the eviction order being suspended – for now. The next Supreme Court hearing on the case will take place imminently. V.S. Roy David of the National Adivasi Alliance (NAA), a group representing tribal peoples in India, has said: “We unequivocally appeal to the Supreme Court to re-evaluate this retrograde anti-people order which will throw millions of Adivasis and other traditional Forest Dwellers into the streets.”

Survival International has campaigned for decades for the rights of forest-dwelling tribes in India. It highlights the catastrophic outcomes of previous evictions, such as that of the Chenchu people from Pecheru village, evicted in the 1980s in the name of conservation. Chenchu survivors report that of the 750 families that used to live in the village, just 160 families survived after the eviction took place. Many starved to death.

Resistance, from people like Chief Raoni, V.S. Roy David, Gladson Dungdung and their domestic and international allies, has already proved powerful and effective. The Bolsonaro and Modi regimes have both proposed laws to erode protections and provisions for indigenous and tribal peoples, but the protests that followed forced the administrations to abandon these proposals, at least for now:

In 2019, a secret draft amendment to India’s colonial forest law was leaked to the press. It allowed forest guards to shoot tribal people, to issue communal punishments, to seize property and arrest citizens with impunity. It also allowed authorities to extinguish rights provided under the FRA and hand over forest land to private companies. Eight months after it was leaked, following national and international protests, the Indian government withdrew the proposed changes to the law although many fear it will be brought back in another guise.

The Bolsonaro regime proposed to end the indigenous healthcare system, SESAI, a decentralized care model with 34 Special Indigenous Health Districts, run in collaboration with local communities and tailored to their needs. Indigenous people saw the dissolution of SESAI as a direct threat to their lives, and especially the lives of their children and elderly. The proposal sparked outrage and protest among indigenous peoples all over the country. From Paraná to Rondônia, from Pernambuco to Mato Grosso do Sul, indigenous groups occupied public buildings and highways in support of SESAI. The Minister backed down and made assurances that the programme would not be abolished, only a week or so after the proposition was first floated.

Brazil and India are states founded on and distinguished by diversity. Both have provisions to protect the rights of their indigenous and tribal citizens enshrined in their constitutions. Anyone who believes in constitutional democracy must stand in alliance with the indigenous and tribal people of India and Brazil: for tribes, for nature, for all humanity.

Jess Franklin is an editorial consultant at Survival International.

More articles by:
bernie-the-sandernistas-cover-344x550
February 05, 2020
Jonathan Cook
The Holocaust, the BBC and Antisemitism Smears
Kenneth Surin
Boris Johnson’s Brexit Got “Done”
Peter A. LaVenia
After Iowa, Does Bernie Have What It Takes?
Tom Crofton
Retail Politics, Iowa Style
Melvin Goodman
Bolton’s Battle With Government Censorship
Ariela Ruiz Caro
The Dramatic Fall of Chile as Latin America’s Neoliberal Role Model
Howie Hawkins
Left Election Strategy: Lesser Evil or Independent Left?
Binoy Kampmark
Teflon Lies and Mowing Lawns: The Afghanistan Papers
Ted Rall
Democrats’ Wimpy Impeachment Has Made Trump Stronger Than Ever
Eleanor Eagan – Max Moran
Who Exactly are Biden and Buttigieg’s Campaign Money Bundlers?
Rajan Menon
The Shame of Child Poverty in the Age of Trump
George Wuerthner
Preserve the Sacred Lands of the Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem
Winslow Myers
“Where’s my Roy Cohn?”
Nyla Ali Khan
In a Time of Increasing Polarization in Kashmir, Evoke Those Scholars and Saints Who Symbolized Pluralism
John Stanton
How the World Ends: a Story
Elliot Sperber
In the Gloaming
February 04, 2020
Peter Harrison
Re-Contextualizing Fascism
Paul Street
How to Not Remove a Fascist
Robert Hunziker
A Radical Call To Action
Patrick Cockburn
We Live in a Disintegrating World
Joyce Nelson
Saugeen Ojibway Nation Has Saved Lake Huron From a Nuclear Waste Dump
John Eskow
Doomsday Clocks and Apple Watches
Marshall Auerback
Do Davos Billionaires and Bankers Really Believe That There Won’t Be Any More Booms and Busts?
Marshall Sahlins
Why Economics is an Impossible Science (In One Paragraph)
Binoy Kampmark
Brexit Day
Binoy Kampmark
Muddling Democrats: Chaos in the Iowa Caucus
John Kendall Hawkins
The Tribute Poems of AZ and KSM
Talasi Brooks
Trump’s Environmental Review Rollbacks Will Put Ranchers in Charge of Public Lands
Kim C. Domenico
Sedition or Sedation?: Liberalism and Neuroses
Gary Leupp
NATO and the Impeachment Trial
Scott Tucker
DNC Declares War on Sanders…Again
Daniel Warner
Can Roger Federer Beat Greta?
Stephen Cooper
A Historic Conversation with Legendary Drummer Santa Davis
February 03, 2020
Sheldon Richman
Trump Would Make Palestinian Subjugation Permanent
Matthew Stevenson
Live From Iowa: Caucus Night
John Feffer
America’s Coronavirus: Containing the Outbreak of Trumpism
Robert Fisk
Trump’s Banal “Deal of the Century” is Impossible to Take Seriously
Kent Paterson
Super Bowl Gluttony
Steven Salaita
The Politics of Online Friendship
Ralph Nader
Misleading Categories and Trump’s Swamps
Norman Solomon
The Creation Myth of the Buttigieg Campaign
Richard Moser
Bossing Grown Folks Around: the Open Letter to the Greens
Shawn Fremstad
The Public Charge Rule for Immigrants Evokes the Antebellum Slave Codes
Thomas Knapp
Government Organizations Shouldn’t Enjoy Trademark Protection
Robert Koehler
Maneuvering Hell for Our Advantage
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail