Mills Are Being Closed by National Economic Trends, Not Environmental Regulations

Lumber mill, Roseburg, Oregon. Photo: Jeffrey St. Clair.

The recent announcement of the Townsend RY Lumber Mill closure in Townsend, Montana continues a trend seen throughout the country. Although RY Lumber suggests this is due to environmental regulations or lawsuits, a broader context demonstrates this is a flawed argument.

The timber industry has been going through a transition for decades. The bulk of all wood production has been moving to the Southeastern states for a variety of economic reasons.

Consider that in some parts of Montana, it might take up to60-100 years to grow a tree to 12 inches diameter, but you can produce a similar-sized tree in Georgia or Mississippi in ten years. All the time you are waiting for trees to grow to merchantable size in Montana, they are exposed to insects, drought, fires, and other sources of mortality. Meanwhile, in the Southeast, you get to cut 3-4 rotations or more of trees in the same time period.

In the Southeast, you can run logging operations year-round due to the lack of snow. And since the landscape is relatively flat, road construction costs are far lower than building logging roads in Montana.

Lastly, the bulk of wood consumers in the country living in the eastern part of the country, so once you have produced a wood product, it is closer to the markets.

For all these and other reasons, the trend has been for the wood products industry to relocate to the southeastern United States.

Maine provides an excellent analogy to decipher the falsehood in the claims of Montana’s timber industry that supply is the problem. At one time, Maine had over 100 operating wood product mills. Indeed, timber companies owned more than half of the state’s land area.  Despite this advantage in timberland access, in the past 25 years, two-thirds of Maine’s remaining mills have closed.

Why? It’s not due to a lack of wood, as is suggested for RY Lumber. Private timber companies owned half of Maine at one time, so they had access to their own lands for timber.

There are almost no listed endangered species in Maine (except lynx), and so far, this has not slowed logging operations.

And even compared to Montana, trees grow faster in Maine, but producers there still can’t compete with timber operations in the Southeast where tree growth is much quicker.

What has been happening in Maine is that as mills became obsolete and need modernization and upgrades, the industry moved their operations to the Southeast. If you are going to invest in new and better equipment, it makes sense to do so in a place where you can get a more rapid and a better return on your investment.

Logging operations on federal lands in Montana are subsidized by taxpayers both in economic ways as well as the environmental damage from logging activities. Despite these subsidies, Montana timber companies cannot effectively compete with more efficient operations in other parts of the country where the geographic, climatic, and economic conditions are more favorable to timber production.

And like Maine, we can expect to see a continuous decline in Montana’s wood products industry, not because of wood supply but due to larger economic issues.

More articles by:

George Wuerthner has published 36 books including Wildfire: A Century of Failed Forest Policy. He serves on the board of the Western Watersheds Project.

February 24, 2020
Stephen Corry
New Deal for Nature: Paying the Emperor to Fence the Wind
M. K. Bhadrakumar
How India’s Modi is Playing on Trump’s Ego to His Advantage
Jennifer Matsui
Tycoon Battle-Bots Battle Bernie
Robert Fisk
There’s Little Chance for Change in Lebanon, Except for More Suffering
Rob Wallace
Connecting the Coronavirus to Agriculture
Bill Spence
Burning the Future: the Growing Anger of Young Australians
Eleanor Eagan
As the Primary Race Heats Up, Candidates Forget Principled Campaign Finance Stands
Binoy Kampmark
The Priorities of General Motors: Ditching Holden
George Wuerthner
Trojan Horse Timber Sales on the Bitterroot
Rick Meis
Public Lands “Collaboration” is Lousy Management
David Swanson
Bloomberg Has Spent Enough to Give a Nickel to Every Person Whose Life He’s Ever Damaged
Peter Cohen
What Tomorrow May Bring: Politics of the People
Peter Harrison
Is It as Impossible to Build Jerusalem as It is to Escape Babylon?
Weekend Edition
February 21, 2020
Friday - Sunday
Anthony DiMaggio
Election Con 2020: Exposing Trump’s Deception on the Opioid Epidemic
Joshua Frank
Bloomberg is a Climate Change Con Man
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Billion Dollar Babies
Paul Street
More Real-Time Reflections from Your Friendly South Loop Marxist
Jonathan Latham
Extensive Chemical Safety Fraud Uncovered at German Testing Laboratory
Ramzy Baroud
‘The Donald Trump I know’: Abbas’ UN Speech and the Breakdown of Palestinian Politics
Martha Rosenberg
A Trump Sentence Commutation Attorneys Generals Liked
Ted Rall
Bernie Should Own the Socialist Label
Louis Proyect
Encountering Malcolm X
Kathleen Wallace
The Debate Question That Really Mattered
Jonathan Cook
UN List of Firms Aiding Israel’s Settlements was Dead on Arrival
George Wuerthner
‘Extremists,’ Not Collaborators, Have Kept Wilderness Whole
Colin Todhunter
Apocalypse Now! Insects, Pesticide and a Public Health Crisis  
Stephen Reyna
A Paradoxical Colonel: He Doesn’t Know What He is Talking About, Because He Knows What He is Talking About.
Evaggelos Vallianatos
A New Solar Power Deal From California
Richard Moser
One Winning Way to Build the Peace Movement and One Losing Way
Laiken Jordahl
Trump’s Wall is Destroying the Environment We Worked to Protect
Walden Bello
Duterte Does the Right Thing for a Change
Jefferson Morley
On JFK, Tulsi Gabbard Keeps Very Respectable Company
Vijay Prashad
Standing Up for Left Literature: In India, It Can Cost You Your Life
Gary Leupp
Bloomberg Versus Bernie: The Upcoming Battle?
Ron Jacobs
The Young Lords: Luchadores Para La Gente
Richard Klin
Loss Leaders
Gaither Stewart
Roma: How Romans Differ From Europeans
Kerron Ó Luain
The Soviet Century
Mike Garrity
We Can Fireproof Homes But Not Forests
Fred Baumgarten
Gaslighting Bernie and His Supporters
Joseph Essertier
Our First Amendment or Our Empire, But Not Both
Peter Linebaugh
A Story for the Anthropocene
Danny Sjursen
Where Have You Gone Smedley Butler?
Jill Richardson
A Broken Promise to Teachers and Nonprofit Workers
Binoy Kampmark
“Leave Our Bloke Alone”: A Little Mission for Julian Assange