The Neutral Choir

When injustice becomes routine, silence itself turns political.

Banu Mushtaq, 2026.

The West, grown timid in its thought,
Calls caution wisdom, fear the free;
What seldom bribe nor threat once bought
Now bends its knee to earn a fee.

The scholar, in a narrowed room,
Counts citations, guards his bread;
Beyond the quad the sirens boom –
He footnotes what the children dread.

Austerity has swept the floor
And thrown the books into the rain;
The mind, made poor, must beg once more
For leave to name the source of pain.

Elsewhere, upon the lacquered stage,
The clever dine on borrowed gold;
The contract closes like a cage,
every dangerous word is sold.

The culture mill keeps feeling clean:
Well-managed grief, approved desire;
Each star rehearses being seen
While keeping both feet from the fire.

The cold equations sold as feeling
Make anguish marketable and clear;
They flatter us with easy healing,
Then leave no dissonance to fear.

‘I’m not political’, they say,
As smoke turns noon to setting sun;
The neutral singer looks away
And hums as though no harm were done.

Plain facts stand shivering at the gate,
Too coarse for theory, bad for art;
The age prefers to curate fate
And keep catastrophe apart.

And I, who judge the bought and meek,
Still warm my hands beside the blaze;
I praise the truth, yet seldom speak
When speech might interrupt my days.

Conscience requires no learned phrase,
No panel’s tact, no critic’s nod;
It sickens through our neutral days
And makes indifference its god.

One day the shelves themselves will burn
While choirs repeat an approved refrain;
We shall have nothing left to learn
Except what silence helped sustain.

Vijay Prashad is the Director of Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research. His most recent book (with Grieve Chelwa) is How the International Monetary Fund Suffocates Africa (from Inkani Books).