Bhutan: Heaven is Still Far Away for the Himalayan Kingdom at 7,000 Feet Above Sea Level

Bhutanese are the happiest people on earth, according to the Gross National Happiness index first introduced by their king in 1972. But most Bhutanese, especially the youngsters, now regard the index as a royal palliative which, after 46 years, still hasn’t made their lives markedly better.

The general election last Thursday in the Himalayan Kingdom, a constitutional monarchy since 2008, was fought mostly on domestic issues from corruption and income inequality to youth unemployment and criminal gangs. The centre-left party DNT headed by a 50-year old medical surgeon Lotay Tshering, who campaigned on diversifying the economy away from hydropower and creating more employment, won 30 of the 47 seats in the national assembly.

As the nation’s new Prime Minister, Tshering has his work cut out for him. A de facto protectorate of India since the two countries signed the Treaty of Friendship in 1949, India supposedly “guides” Bhutan’s foreign policy. The reality is that Thimphu is a hostage of New Delhi practically on all fronts, not just foreign policy. It wasn’t until 1972 that Bhutan was given India’s blessing to join the United Nations. Thanks to India’s “guidance” , Thimphu till today has no diplomatic relations with any of the UN permanent members, including its giant neighbor China.

The 2-month long Doklam standoff last year between China and India, over an incident at the Bhutan-China border, put Thimphu in an awkward position. The border face-off stripped away all pretenses that New Delhi only “guides” the kingdom’s foreign policy. It dawned on Thimphu that India would take care of its own interest ahead of Bhutan’s. Many Bhutanese were at the time unhappy with India taking into its own hands a sovereignty issue affecting Thimphu.

In return for India’s largesse–Bhutan is the biggest recipient of aid from New Delhi – Thimphu forfeits its sovereignty. That bargain worked well for decades until the end of monarchy and the first democratic elections in 2008. Voices calling for more self-determination and diversification of international relations and the economy began to emerge. The momentum for change has gathered force and urgency since last year after the Doklam episode.

Despite GDP growth averaging 6% over the last decade, signs that not all is well with the economy have become increasingly visible. Youth unemployment in excess of 10%, well above the national average of 3%, can no longer be ignored or wished away. The trajectory of good GDP growth is under threat by the introduction of Goods and Services Tax in India last year (most of the landlocked Bhutan’s trade goes through India), aggravated by delays of several hydropower projects which are crucial to expansion in export earnings and government revenue from sale of electricity to India.

External debts at 121% of GDP are excessive by international standards. Indian loans to Bhutan to build hydro dams account for 90% of GDP. Of course, few outside Bhutan have a clue because India gets a free pass from western corporate media which chose not to report it. New Delhi charges 9 to 10% interest on the hydropower loans made to Thimphu. It’s sheer hypocrisy for India to go round denouncing China’s funding of Belt and Road projects in Pakistan, Maldives, Sri Lanka and Myanmar as debt traps when Bhutan’s debt situation is far more perilous and unsustainable than that of Maldives and others.

Some figures will show Bhutan’s high economic dependence on India.

1) 80% of exports go to India, with 40% in the form of sale of hydropower.

2) 90% of imports come from India.

3) Three-quarters of loans from India.

4) Almost all the migrant labor are in India working on road construction projects.

5) One-quarter of government revenue comes from hydropower sold to India.

In short, Bhutan’s economy is at the whims and mercy of New Delhi.

The new Tshering government wants to diversify the economy away from hydropower and from over-reliance on India. In particular, the Bhutanese want light industry and more ecotourism to create jobs for the young and avoid the vicissitudes of New Delhi politics. An obvious step for the new Thimphu administration is to rectify a glaring anomaly of not having diplomatic relations with its next door neighbor, China. Beijing stands ready to help Thimphu by investing in light, non-pollutive industry, bring ecotourists to Bhutan, and build infrastructures on the country’s difficult and treacherous terrain to open up the landlocked kingdom. All that Beijing is prepared to do without interfering with Thimphu’s domestic affairs and sovereignty.

Too good to be true? Tshering need not look far : Nepal is a recent precedent after the Communist Party in Kathmandu won power and started to avail itself of Chinese assistance and largesse.

More articles by:


June 20, 2019
Robert Hunziker
The Dangerous Methane Mystery
David Schultz
The Intellectual Origins of the Trump Presidency and the Construction of Contemporary American Politics
Sabri Öncü
Thus Spoke the Bond Market
Gary Leupp
Japanese and German Doubts on U.S. Drumbeat Towards Iran War
Binoy Kampmark
The Fragility of Democracy: Hong Kong, China and the Extradition Bill
Doug Johnson
On the Morning Consult Poll, Margins of Error, and the Undecideds in the Democratic Primary
Laura Flanders
In Barcelona, Being a Fearless City Mayor Means Letting the People Decide
Martha Rosenberg
Humor: Stop These Language Abuses
Jim Goodman
Current Farm Crisis Offers Opportunity For Change
Cesar Chelala
The Pope is Wrong on Argentina
Kim C. Domenico
Lessons from D.H. : A Soul-based Anarchist Vision for Peace-making
Jesse Jackson
Mobilizing the Poor People’s Campaign
Wim Laven
We Need Evidence-Based Decision Making
Cesar Chelala
Health Consequences of Overwork
June 19, 2019
Matthew Stevenson
Requiem for a Lightweight: the Mayor Pete Factor
Kenneth Surin
In China Again
Stephen Cooper
Abolishing the Death Penalty Requires Morality
George Ochenski
The DNC Can’t Be Allowed to Ignore the Climate Crisis
John W. Whitehead
The Omnipresent Surveillance State
William Camacaro - Frederick B. Mills
Guaidó’s Star Fades as His Envoys to Colombia Allegedly Commit Fraud With Humanitarian Funds for Venezuela
Dave Lindorff
What About Venezuela’s Hacked Power Grid?
Howard Lisnoff
Try Not to Look Away
Binoy Kampmark
Matters of Water: Dubious Approvals and the Adani Carmichael Mine
Karl Grossman
The Battle to Stop the Shoreham Nuclear Plant, Revisited
Kani Xulam
Farting in a Turkish Mosque
Dean Baker
New Manufacturing Jobs are Not Union Jobs
Elizabeth Keyes
“I Can’t Believe Alcohol Is Stronger Than Love”
June 18, 2019
John McMurtry
Koch-Oil Big Lies and Ecocide Writ Large in Canada
Robert Fisk
Trump’s Evidence About Iran is “Dodgy” at Best
Yoav Litvin
Catch 2020 – Trump’s Authoritarian Endgame
Thomas Knapp
Opposition Research: It’s Not Trump’s Fault That Politics is a “Dirty” Game
Medea Benjamin - Nicolas J. S. Davies
U.S. Sanctions: Economic Sabotage that is Deadly, Illegal and Ineffective
Gary Leupp
Marx and Walking Zen
Thomas Hon Wing Polin
Color Revolution In Hong Kong: USA Vs. China
Howard Lisnoff
The False Prophets Cometh
Michael T. Klare
Bolton Wants to Fight Iran, But the Pentagon Has Its Sights on China
Steve Early
The Global Movement Against Gentrification
Dean Baker
The Wall Street Journal Doesn’t Like Rent Control
Tom Engelhardt
If Trump’s the Symptom, Then What’s the Disease?
June 17, 2019
Patrick Cockburn
The Dark Side of Brexit: Britain’s Ethnic Minorities Are Facing More and More Violence
Linn Washington Jr.
Remember the Vincennes? The US’s Long History of Provoking Iran
Geoff Dutton
Where the Wild Things Were: Abbey’s Road Revisited
Nick Licata
Did a Coverup of Who Caused Flint Michigan’s Contaminated Water Continue During Its Investigation? 
Binoy Kampmark
Julian Assange and the Scales of Justice: Exceptions, Extraditions and Politics
John Feffer
Democracy Faces a Global Crisis