FacebookTwitterRedditEmail

Trump Administration Falsely Blames Environmental Lawsuits for Forest Fires

Photo by Ervins Strauhmanis | CC BY 2.0

It is clear that the Trump administration is leading on one thing: making stuff up. Ryan Zinke, Sonny Perdue, Steve Daines and Greg Gianforte followed Donald Trump’s lead in using alternative facts in their recent press conference near the Lolo Peak Fire. The Trump administration apparently believes that it is because of lawsuits that we have forest fires during this exceptionally hot, dry and windy summer.

The Alliance for the Wild Rockies is a powerful group and we fight hard to preserve forests, but we certainly don’t control the weather or the warming climate. Moreover, there is no lawsuit in the Lolo Peak area, and the Lolo Peak area has already undergone extensive logging.

In the Trump administration’s alternative reality, climate change has nothing to do with forest fires because, as Trump has pronounced, “global warming is a Chinese hoax.” The 2014 National Climate Assessment estimates wildfires in Montana will increase by 400 percent to 700 percent in the next 50 years if climate change is not addressed.

Protecting old growth forests from logging is one way to do this. National forests absorb an astounding 10 percent of the carbon that America creates and unlogged and old growth forests absorb the most.

The politicians at the Lolo Peak Fire press conference could do something about the main driver of wildfire — they could commit to addressing climate change – starting with participation in the Paris Climate Accord. But instead they promote more coal burning and taxpayer-subsidized logging on public lands, which will only exacerbate climate change.

The Trump administration has even complained that our lawsuit temporarily pausing the Stonewall timber sale resulted in the wildfire burning in the northern part of the Stonewall project area. Not surprisingly, their argument is not supported by facts. That wildfire started with a lighting strike outside of the planned treatment units, so the fire would have started regardless of whether the project units were logged. Indeed, natural wildfires regularly burn in this area, as evidenced by the fact that the Park Creek fire is now surrounded on three sides by formerly burned areas, which have mostly stopped the spread of this fire. Significantly, it also does not appear that any of the timber sale’s commercial logging units have burned.

These fact-challenged politicians also claimed that we have shut down half the timber sales in Montana, a contention that even the U.S. Forest Service denied. Instead, our region of the Forest Service has met 89 percent of its timber logging targets over the last 15 years and the target has been increasing almost every year. 2017 is not over yet, but a February Great Falls Tribune article titled “Logging in Helena-Lewis and Clark National Forest best in decades” reported that loggers had never seen this much timber available.

These politicians also neglected to mention that the state’s largest wildfire — 270,000 acres that destroyed 16 homes in eastern Montana — burned mostly through grasslands, not forests, which is probably why they held their pro-logging press conference in front of Lolo Peak rather than in eastern Montana.

The Trump administration calls it “frivolous” when citizens prevail in lawsuits forcing the government to comply with its own laws. To the contrary, it is the basis of our democracy and civil justice system that citizens have the power to force the government to follow its own laws. So despite the barrage of lies, insults, fear-mongering and scapegoating directed at us, we will not back down. We will continue to fight to protect and conserve our priceless public lands and the fish and wildlife that depend on them for survival. Join us.

More articles by:

Mike Garrity is the executive director of the Alliance for the Wild Rockies.

bernie-the-sandernistas-cover-344x550
January 16, 2020
Peter Harrison
The Wonders of Modern Life Briefly Explained: An Anthropology of the Industrial Revolution
Kenneth Surin
Politics and Business in Seattle
George Ochenski
Trump Dooms the Future by Gutting the National Environmental Policy Act
Kerron Ó Luain
The Longue Durée: Commemorating RIC and Black & Tan Colonialism
John Kendall Hawkins
False Profits and Anti-Christs™
Nick Licata
Climate Crisis: We Need Radical Change Now, Not in the Future
Binoy Kampmark
Short of Time: Julian Assange at the Westminster Magistrates Court
Norman Solomon
Biden, Buttigieg and Corporate Media Are Eager for Sanders and Warren to Clash
Daniel Warner
How Donald Trump Successfully Wagged the Dog, and More
Allegra Harpootlian
How the President Became a Drone Operator
Dean Baker
Another Geithner Scandal
Lawrence Davidson
Death by Illogic, Lies and Stupidity
January 15, 2020
Mark Schuller
Where is the Reporting on PetroCaribe?
Evaggelos Vallianatos
Australia on the Chasm of Climate Catastrophe
Paul Edwards
American Murder
Gala Pin
City Problems: A Fairly True Barcelona Story
Richard Greeman
France at a Crossroads
Kenn Orphan
Missiles, Lies and Assassinations
Eleanor Eagan
Biden’s Unexamined List of High-Powered Fundraisers
Binoy Kampmark
Vague Imminence: US policy, Pre-emptive Force and Qasem Soleimani
Howard Lisnoff
Fifty Years and Still the Unrelenting Drumbeat of War
Thomas M. Magstadt
A Fine Republic, But Can We Keep It?  
Patrick Cockburn
Who Wins and Who Loses in the Iran Crisis?
Michael Welton
Traversed by Tensions: Quebec’s Religious Symbols Law
Stephen Cooper
Hey Los Angeles: More Public Restrooms, Please!
January 14, 2020
Kenneth Good
The Deadly Failures of Conservative Government in Australia in the Face of Ferocious Fires
Melvin Goodman
Trump’s Latest Debacle: an Incompetent and Deceitful National Security Team
Thomas S. Harrington
An Interview with Embattled Catalan President Quim Torra
John Feffer
The 40 Year Cold War With Iran
Ron Jacobs
Iranian Opposition—1970s to 2020
Yoav Litvin
Zionism and ‘Anti-Semitism’: A Chronicle of a Smear Foretold
Patrick Cockburn
Demonizing the Shia: How the West Perpetuates False Claims About Iran’s Regional Influence
Cathy Breen
And We Allow This Madness to Continue
Ramzy Baroud
Justice at Last? ‘Panic’ in Israel as the ICC Takes ‘Momentous Step’ in the Right Direction
Sam Husseini
Biden’s Pack of Lies About the Iraq War
Nicolas J S Davies - Medea Benjamin
10 Ways Trump’s Actions Against Iran Hurt Americans and the Region
Philip Doe
The Pretend Administration:  Colorado Governor Polis and Fracking
Ellen Brown
The Fed Protects Gamblers at the Expense of the Economy
David Swanson
Charlottesville City Council Passes Resolution Against War on Iran
January 13, 2020
Gabriel Rockhill
Understanding France’s General Strike in the Context of the Yellow Vests and Global Class Warfare
Sheldon Richman
Trump’s Escalation Imperils Innocents
Bishop Thomas Gumbleton
A Call to Catholics: Let Us End Our Complicity in War
Ramzy Baroud
Embracing Palestine: How to Combat Israel’s Misuse of “Antisemitism”
Harry Blain
The Useless War Powers Act
Helen Yaffe
Farewell to Two Cuban Revolutionaries: Faure Chomón and Harry (‘Pombo’) Villegas
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail