Our Il Duce

The first amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America states: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech , or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.”

Those words are a simple but powerful act of democracy in which free speech and free press can be guaranteed in a free society but now, such guarantees are under severe threat by the 45th president of the United States and those he has surrounded himself with.

Just 24 hours after being sworn in as president of the USA, Donald Trump sent White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer to drill some discipline into the media. Their crime? Reporting the low numbers at the presidential inauguration. At the White House press room, Spicer went into Rottweiler mode and barked out his insistence that the numbers were much higher than reported. Although we all saw the poor turnout, either on the ground in Washington or live on TV, the new regime at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue wants us to believe an ‘alternative fact.’ In other words, a style of censorship and propaganda has reared it’s ugly head in the land of the free.

Censorship and propaganda were fiercely important tools used by many ruling regimes throughout history. Italy’s fascist dictatorship wielded these tools in order to control public opinion of Il Duce.

In Mussolini’s Italy a special ministry was set up to oversee the controllment of communication. The Ministero della Cultura Popolare (Ministry of Popular Culture) controlled what newspapers published, what radio could broadcast and what cinemas could and could not show. One such film which did not pass the test at the ministry of popular culture was Charlie Chaplin’s Great Dictator. The 1940 film lampooned the likes of Hitler and Mussolini and of course, it  did not go down too well with dur furher and Ill duce. Over 70 years later, the very thought of banning a piece of screen satire is considered an extreme act but satire still attracts the ire of those it lampoons. When Saturday Night Live lampooned Donald Trump he declared his hatred for it and called it unfair.

Mussolini’s ministry of pop culture was one of the most over worked departments in his dictatorship. It’s iron fist handed out daily slogans for people to adhere to, such as Ill Duce ha Siempre Ragione (the leader is always right). The words that pored out of Mussolini’s mouth were akin to gospel. His powerful nationalism of ‘ Italy first ‘ whipped up a frenzied support base with the aid of censorship and propaganda. He was portrayed as a macho man, one who would clamp down on corruption and crime. Mussolini’s propaganda machine even managed to make people believe that he single handedly made Italy’s trains run on time! The light was never turned off in his office as a ploy to make people think Ill Duce was working hard into the early hours, when in reality he was in bed. Had the technology been around in those days, I suspect he would have been tweeting in bed!

The press in Mussolini’s Italy was instructed on what to report and what not to report. Of the things that were strictly off limits with regards to Mussolini was his birthday and illnesses. The totalitarian leader wanted to portray a man who never fell victim to sickness or never fell victim to the aging process! He held an obesssion with his appearance and any photos taken of him would have to get his approval before going to press. Any unflattering pictures showing the dictator’s bulging belly or double chin were either binned or photoshopped.

A double chin problem also plagues Donald Trump who, before taking office as president, summoned media executives to Trump Tower to verbalise his upset with some media outlets who published unflattering photos of his double chin!

Media outlets in Mussolini’s Italy that reported opposing news about the regime were instantly suppressed while pro Mussolini media was awarded for its loyalty with state subsidies. In 1926 a law was passed which saw newspapers needing a special permission from the government to publish anything. This was Mussolini’s style of stranglehold on an Italy he wanted to make great again. He wanted to resurrect the Roman empire with himself at the helm of it, unchallenged and unquestioned.

In those bleak days of European fascism, citizens of totalitarian regimes were told untruths until they eventually believed them or at least accept them reluctantly. In Trump’s inauguration speech he painted a dark picture of America, one where crime is rife and corruption rules the day. It was this similar style of fear mongering which the likes of Mussolini espoused in the 1920s and 30s. He decreed that Italy was such a hopeless case that it needed a strong man to fix it. Trump’s inauguration speech was just an extension to all those other speeches he made on the campaign trail, the ones that drilled the concept of a broken nation that needs to be made great again.

A series of bullishly blatant ‘alternative facts’ sent Trump hurtling to the White House and there is now an uneasy thought that he, and those around him, will and can continue with those same ‘alternative facts’ to shape their own version of a dystopian America. There is a lot to fear but, there is lot to be optimistic about. Totalitarian type regimes usually birth a strong resistance to it and that was evident with the Women’s March on Washington the day after Trump’s Inauguration, a movement made possible by the type of rights enshrined in the first amendment.

As Donald Trump begins his stint as commander in chief, it might be only a matter of time before reality will interupt his world of ‘alternative facts’. How ironic would that be for the billionaire who thrived in the world of reality TV!

Pauline Murphy is a freelance writer from Ireland.