Let’s (Third) Party

A friend of mine has a dog I call Chad because he always hangs around me. Remember the “hanging chad” dispute over the 2000 election results in Florida and Bush v. Gore? And how Democrats and the press heaped so much blame on poor Ralph Nader as to almost suffocate him? All that demonizing dealt a blow to third-party politics that it has yet to recover from. And that’s a pity, because we desperately need to upgrade our putative two-party system’s software.

Before we move on to the current electoral crisis, what about Florida in 2000? Didn’t Nader’s 2.5% Green Party share nail the election for Bush? Even if you assume that a statewide recount that included all disputed ballots would have come out narrowly for Bush, as factcheck.org concludes, the focus on Florida misses the big picture. Let’s face it; Al Gore ran a lackluster campaign. He backpedaled, issuing hardly a peep about the love of his life, climate change. He inspired so insipidly that he even lost Tennessee—his home state—which would have taken him to victory. Yet he still piled up more popular votes (50,999,897 – 48.38%) than Bush (50,456,002 – 47.87%). You could just as easily say the Electoral College stole the election as Ralph Nader did.

Ever since I started making noises about supporting presumptive Green Party candidate Jill Stein for president lots of people tell me a vote for her is a vote for Trump. Every one of those people has abiding antipathy toward that man. Most of them seem lukewarm at best about Hillary Clinton. No surprise; they’re the most unpopular presidential candidates ever, tied at a 37% favorability rating in a July 2016 Gallup poll (negative sentiments toward politicians have been steadily rising for two generations).

But what if the anti-Trumpists are right? Could Jill spoil everything? Here’s what two questions a Quinnipiac poll asked of voters in three key swing states In mid July tell us:

1. If the election for President were being held today, and the candidates were Hillary Clinton the Democrat and Donald Trump the Republican, for whom would you vote?

Screen Shot 2016-08-04 at 12.01.00 PM

2. If the election for President were being held today, and the candidates were Hillary Clinton the Democrat, Donald Trump the Republican, Gary Johnson the Libertarian, and Jill Stein the Green party candidate, for whom would you vote?

Screen Shot 2016-08-04 at 12.01.44 PM

Before deconstructing these numbers, be advised that they could be an aberration and will likely change the next time they are compiled. That said, let’s see what they reveal.

The undecided pegged at about 8% regardless of who’s running. However, the number of people who would not vote drops by two percent (four in PA). With third parties on the ballot, Clinton loses 3, 5, and 7 percentage points (FL, OH, PA, respectively), while Trump loses 2, 4, and 3 points, respectively. Those who would not vote for any of the above come out to 11, 10, and 11 percent (FL, OH, PA, respectively) for a two-way race and 5, 5, and 6 percent, respectively, in the four-way race.

*These numbers indicate that when third parties appear the ballot, several things happen:

*The margins of victory widen but don’t flip; Trump’s existing lead over Clinton basically doubles.

*More people participate; the none-of-the-above numbers get cut in half

Third parties become more salient than ever; they would garner 13% of the vote

The results indicate that Gary Johnson would out-poll Jill Stein almost two-to-one, yet more respondents would abandon Hillary than would desert Trump, implying that is a fair number of Democratic voters in those states would go Libertarian rather than Green. That surprises me, but there it is. The results are probably skewed by the fact that Johnson has received far more media coverage than Stein, and Mitt Romney has now endorsed him, for whatever that’s worth.

Given the anti-progressive bent of mainstream media, nationwide I expect Libertarians to do relatively well compared to the Greens, perhaps two-to-four times as well. So, if Trump wins in November, should we blame Gary Johnson?

I don’t think so. After all, Hillary’s numbers have been tumbling as Trump’s ascend. The blame should rest squarely on Hillary Clinton and her partner-in-crime, the Democratic National Committee. But there are still a lot of people out there who will say it’s the fault of third parties for wanting something they can’t have.

But Democratic and Republican voters, too, want something they can’t have: a functioning democracy. They won’t have that no matter who wins, and they can’t blame it on Gary or Jill.

Barring unpleasant political surprises, it’s hard for me to believe Trump will emerge on top of anything but his ego in November. The media and the chattering class, not to mention GOP leaders and their think tanks, are almost uniformly down on him. Tell me, please, when was the last time that our elites failed to fix a national election? Now that the choices are clear-cut, the smart money from financial circles and others with deep pockets is flooding into Hillary’s purse. There aren’t enough angry white men to make a difference. Angry people of color of both sexes will likely cancel their votes anyway.

Still, if enough registered voters stay home through disgust, lack of interest, or prefer none of the above, the slices taken by third parties could flip some outcomes in winner-take-all states. That’s what makes anti-Trump (it would be charitable to call them pro-Hillary) people lose sleep, and it explains some of the negative reactions I’ve gotten when I talk up Jill Stein. But even if Trump somehow were to win, it still wouldn’t be her fault. Or Gary Johnson’s. It will be the doing of the one white-collar-crime ring that rules us all.

Extra Credit

More articles by:

Geoff Dutton is an ex-geek turned writer and editor. He hails from Boston and writes about whatever distortions of reality strike his fancy. Currently, he’s pedaling a novel chronicling the lives and times of members of a cell of terrorists in Europe, completing a collection of essays on high technology delusions, and can be found barking at Progressive Pilgrim Review.

July 18, 2019
Timothy M. Gill
Bernie Sanders, Anti-Imperialism and Venezuela
W. T. Whitney
Cuba and a New Generation of Leaders Respond to U.S. Anti-People War
Jonathan Cook
How the Goliath of the Jerusalem Settler Movement Persuaded the World It’s Really David
William Hartung
Merger Mania: the Military-Industrial Complex on Steroids
John G. Russell
The Devolution Will Be Televised: Our Body-cam President
Judith Deutsch
Psychology Stories: Children
Dean Baker
The Coal Industry is Not a Major Employer
Binoy Kampmark
Corporate Gangster: Adani’s Pursuit of Scientists
Thomas Knapp
National Polls Don’t Mean Much. Here’s Why.
Thomas Mountain
Africans Solving African Problems; Bringing Peace to Sudan
Ann Garrison
History Is Happening: WikiLeaks, the Global Fourth Estate
Elliot Sperber
Don’t Open the Door 
July 17, 2019
Manuel García, Jr.
Ye Cannot Swerve Me: Moby-Dick and Climate Change
Charles Pierson
Sofi’s Choice
Gary Leupp
Epstein, Jane Doe, and Trump
Rebecca Gordon
I Had an Abortion and Now I’m Not Ashamed
Peter Bolton
In the US and Brazil, Two Trends Underline the Creeping Fascism of Both Governments
Michael Kidder
“Go Back Where You Came From:” an Episode From Canada
Steve Early - Rand Wilson
How Big Strike 30 Years Ago Aided Fight for Single Payer
John W. Whitehead
Sexual Predators in the Power Elite
Michael Welton
Teach the Children Well: the Unrealized Vision In Teaching and Learning in the Residential Schools
Khury Petersen-Smith
Iran’s Not the Aggressor, the US Is
Russell Mokhiber
Kip Sullivan and Dr. Matthew Hahn on How Value Based Programs Are Undermining Medicare and Single Payer
George Ochenski
A Fearless and Free Press is Essential to Our Democracy
Lawrence Wittner
Billionaires and American Politics
Dean Baker
Cheap Shots at the Trump Economy
July 16, 2019
Conn Hallinan
The World Needs a Water Treaty
Kenneth Surin
Britain Grovels: the Betrayal of the British Ambassador
Christopher Ketcham
This Land Was Your Land
Gary Leupp
What Right Has Britain to Seize an Iranian Tanker Off Spain?
Evaggelos Vallianatos
Democratic Virtues in Electing a President
Thomas Knapp
Free Speech Just isn’t That Complicated
Binoy Kampmark
The Resigning Ambassador
Howard Lisnoff
Everybody Must Get Stoned
Nicky Reid
Nukes For Peace?
Matt Johnson
The United States of Overreaction
Cesar Chelala
Children’s Trafficking and Exploitation is a Persistent, Dreary Phenomenon
Martin Billheimer
Sylvan Shock Theater
July 15, 2019
David Altheide
The Fear Party
Roger Harris
UN High Commissioner on Human Rights Bachelet’s Gift to the US: Justifying Regime Change in Venezuela
John Feffer
Pyongyang on the Potomac
Vincent Kelley
Jeffrey Epstein and the Collapse of Europe
Robert Fisk
Trump’s Hissy-Fit Over Darroch Will Blow a Chill Wind Across Britain’s Embassies in the Middle East
Binoy Kampmark
Juggling with the Authoritarians: Donald Trump’s Diplomatic Fake Book
Dean Baker
The June Jobs Report and the State of the Economy