FacebookTwitterRedditEmail

The One-State Mirage

I was quite dismayed by Franklin Spinney’s recent column regarding the two-state solution. While I respect and value his graphics regarding the water resources, his logic is simply in error and requires a mature critique.

First, the very basic outlook of this article is that one cannot impact the behavior of the Israeli settlers. This is a simple logical flaw. The reality is that the settlers are there precisely because of a subsidy that involves American tax monies. This in turn means that, should Americans demand of their tax dollars cease being used to fund the illegal settlements, the Israelis will either have to do some serious financial restructuring or the settlers will have to move to subsidized housing inside Israel proper. Those who refuse to budge will have to do so in a Palestinian state. Think removing this subsidy is impossible? How long did it take Bill Clinton to get rid of the subsidy to poor mothers via Welfare?

Second, in all frankness, one must ask seriously whose agenda is benefitted by this logic. Omar Barghouti, founder of the BDS Movement, comes from a Palestinian family that has ties to both Fatah and Hamas. Mohammad Barghouti was a labor minister of the Palestinian Authority and Abdullah Barghouti was a leading commander in Hamas’ armed wing Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades. I have no interest in casting dispersions here but I think the BDS program is much more beneficial for Fatah than Hamas. For illustration, let us just consider the instance of a destroyed house in Gaza. Under a single state solution, it is highly likely that such a house would be rebuilt under a loan package administered by the Western financial system. It is also likely that the major military and political leaders in Hamas would be neutralized under the auspices of anti-terrorism. Such a loan would include in its fine print typical neoliberal financial devices that almost guarantee default, not unlike the sub-prime housing instruments that were sold by Countrywide in the lead-up to the 2008 economic crash. As such, the ethnic cleansing of Palestine would go from overt violence, as exemplified by home demolition, to covert forms, as in the case of gentrification. But under a two-state solution, the BRICS nations, along with things like the Development Bank within the Shanghai Cooperative Network, would be able to finance Palestinian reconstruction under loan terms that would be much more beneficial for the population.

Third, while the two state solution might seem further and further away due to the settlements, the reality is that the international consensus remains overwhelmingly in favor of the pre-June 1967 borders defining two states. There is nothing in the international consensus otherwise. My own opinion is that the hasbara 2.0 system sees the BDS platform as useful to its efforts and can utilize an argument for a one state solution to actualize the completion of the annexation of Palestinian land. Combined with the norms of gentrification, we could see this made a reality within a generation, thereby invalidating the so-called “demographic problem” that would invalidate the land as a “Jewish state”. Whether or not this is the motivation or goal of Omar Barghouti and the larger movement is incidental, the neoliberal power structure knows how to play this game much better than any activist does because it knows how the deck is stacked. I therefore am hesitant to engage with the BDS program’s conclusions while certainly respecting those who advocate for Palestinian rights. It is simply a matter of knowing that having one’s position advocated for by The New York Times is a bad sign for those you are advocating for.

The Palestinians deserve a state of their own wherein, through democratic means, they can finally rid themselves of the wretched Fatah collaborators like Abu Mazen. Under a single state, he would be ensconced in power under the banner of “moderation” and “appeasement of Israelis”. Who in their right mind wants such a thing?

More articles by:

Andrew Stewart is a documentary film maker and reporter who lives outside Providence.  His film, AARON BRIGGS AND THE HMS GASPEE, about the historical role of Brown University in the slave trade, is available for purchase on Amazon Instant Video or on DVD.

bernie-the-sandernistas-cover-344x550
Weekend Edition
January 17, 2020
Friday - Sunday
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: No Woman, No Cry
Kathleen Wallace
Hijacking the Struggles of Others, Elizabeth Warren Style
Robert Hunziker
The Rumbling Methane Enigma
Frank Joyce
Will the Constitution Fail Again?
Pete Dolack
Claims that the ‘NAFTA 2’ Agreement is Better are a Macabre Joke
Andrew Levine
Biden Daze
Vijay Prashad
Not an Inch: Indian Students Stand Against the Far Right
Ramzy Baroud
Sealed Off and Forgotten: What You Should Know about Israel’s ‘Firing Zones’ in the West Bank
Norman Solomon
Not Bernie, Us. Not Warren, Us. Their Clash Underscores the Need for Grassroots Wisdom
Ted Rall
America’s Long History of Meddling in Russia
David Rosen
The Irregulators vs. FCC: the Trial Begins
Jennifer Matsui
The Krown
Joseph Natoli
Resolutions and Obstacles/2020
Sarah Anderson
War Profiteering is Real
James McFadden
The Business Party Syndicate
Ajamu Baraka
Trump Prosecutors Make Move to Ensure that Embassy Protectors are Convicted
David Swanson
CNN is Trash
Rev. William Alberts
Finally a Christian Call for Trump’s Removal
Dave Lindorff
The ERA Just Got Ratified by Virginia, the Needed 38th State!
W. T. Whitney
Mexico Takes Action on Coup in Bolivia and on CELAC
Steve Early
How General Strike Rhetoric Became a Reality in Seattle 
Jessicah Pierre
Learning From King’s Last Campaign
Mark Dickman
Saint Greta and the Dragon
Jared Bernstein - Dean Baker
Reducing the Health Care Tax
Clark T. Scott
Uniting “Progressives” Instead of Democrats
Nilofar Suhrawardy
Trump & Johnson: What a Contrast, Image-wise!
Ron Jacobs
Abusing America’s Children—Free Market Policy
George Wuerthner
Mills Are Being Closed by National Economic Trends, Not Environmental Regulations
Basav Sen
Nearly All Americans Want Off of Fossil Fuels
Mark Ashwill
Playing Geopolitical Whack-a-Mole: The Viet Nam Flag Issue Revisited
Jesse Jackson
New Hope for One of America’s Poorest Communities
Binoy Kampmark
Harry and Meghan Exit: The Royal Family Propaganda Machine
Ralph Nader
Trump: Making America Dread Again!
Rob Okun
A Call to Men to join Women’s March
Kollibri terre Sonnenblume
We All Need to Be Tree Huggers Now
Tom Stephens
The New York Times’ Delusions of Empire
Julian Rose
Fake-Green Zero Carbon Fraud
Louis Proyect
The Best Films of 2019
Matthew Stevenson
Across the Balkans: Into Kosovo
Colin Todhunter
Gone Fishing? No Fish but Plenty of Pesticides and a Public Health Crisis
Julian Vigo
Can New Tech Replace In-Class Learning?
Gaither Stewart
The Bench: the Life of Things
Nicky Reid
Trannies with Guns: Because Enough is Enough!
James Haught
Baby Dinosaurs on Noah’s Ark
David Yearsley
Brecht in Berlin
FacebookTwitterRedditEmail