Je Suis Charlie…But I Have Others


Last Monday evening I had planned to write about the PEGIDA movement in Germany. Although in Dresden, their city of origin, the number of bitter marchers protesting the “Islamization” of the West had increased stubbornly to 18,000, I began to report happily that everywhere else in Germany they had been greatly outnumbered. In Berlin, only 300 turned up – and turned tail in the face of 5000 opposing them. Even politicians who had ignored them, had castigated their opponents by speaking of “terrorists of the right and left” or had used code words to express similar anti-immigrant feelings (and win votes) now opposed them almost in unison. Berlin city leaders followed the Dresden Opera House example by turning off the lights on Brandenburg Gate in protest against the racists. Church leaders in Cologne did the same, plunging their giant cathedral into welcome darkness, while 400 marchers were halted by 10,000 opponents. Thus, except in Dresden, Monday marked a victory against the efforts to set one group against another by those who called instead for friendship, togetherness and a welcome to those seeking asylum and a new, decent life.

But then came Wednesday and Paris, with its atrocious murders at Charlie Hebdo. Like so many millions I was shocked and horror-stricken. But I was also frightened. Now the PEGIDA crowd would shout, “You see! We told you so!” Even before Wednesday, polls had shown 57% of non-immigrant Germans mistrustful of Muslims. But only small numbers had taken part in the virulent marches. How many would now join in with flags, crosses and slogans? How many right-leaning leaders would once again find their raucous voices? And how could they now be counteracted? Would the tragic shots fired in the rue Nicolas Appert echo menacingly down the Alleen and Strassen of Germany? How could we now put brakes to the locomotive of hatred, already rushing dangerously from one end of Europe to the other, spewing sparks for new conflagrations which could burn us all?

Ach, what character flaw impels me to always buck the stream? Even now, with so many people stricken and determined to oppose murderous Islamists and defend freedom of a critical press, why am I stricken by so many doubts? Must sharp, iconoclastic satire, bravely spiting the powers-that-be with sharp pens and sharp words, purposely insult deeply-felt religious beliefs? A convinced atheist all my life, I have no sympathy whatsoever for religious fanatics, be they Muslim, Christian, Jewish, Hindu or Buddhist. Some of Charlie’s foes were my foes; I enjoy attacks on fanatics, whether in Teheran, Riyadh, West Jerusalem or West Virginia. For centuries they have caused far too much misery in our world. But that bothersome little voice whispers that, as a journalist, I might not have caricatured Christians while they faced lions in Rome’s old Coliseum, or even the most backward-looking Jewish daveners during Hitler’s reign. Attacking ISIS is good. But lampooning the beliefs of so many Muslims in Europe, who face daily discrimination in schools and jobs, with mosques and minarets attacked physically – and some peaceful Muslims as well? Should satire be unfettered? Almost always, yes! But perhaps not always libel – or in ridiculing prophets and beliefs which still provide solace to so many? Bloody fanatics must be opposed. But Moses, Jesus, Buddha and Muhammad are long dead. Attacking them may sometimes take courage, but is it wise or good?

No such worries justify Kalashnikov attacks and cold-blooded murder – definitely not of artists, writers, satirists. And the world has certainly seen far too many limitations on freedom! But why, must my memory, so weak on recent names, faces or events, again remain so strong on things long past? And why insist repeatedly that not only Muslims or Islamists can be bloody?

Must I recall the uprising in France’s colony of Madagascar in 1947, whose people, dreaming of independence, naively hoping for USA-assistance, began their fight, armed mostly with spears? A well-armed French army of 30,000 men adopted “a strategy of terror and psychological warfare involving torture, collective punishment, the burning of villages, mass arrests, executions and rape… In Mananjary, hundreds were killed, among them 18 women and a group of prisoners thrown alive out of an airplane”. An official estimate of the number killed was 89,000, but counting those who fled into the forest and were believed dead it was more likely over 100,000.

And press freedom? “The French media reported little on the event and few details of the rising and subsequent repression were reported … outside France.” On the 65th anniversary of the uprising in 2012, Madagascar’s prime minister requested that the French government declassify archival materials on the uprising. The request was not approved.

Why must I recall the bloody French war in Indochina soon thereafter? And what about Algeria? In 1841, eleven years after its conquest, visiting historian Alexis de Tocqueville commented: “Whatever the case, we may say in a general manner that all political freedoms must be suspended in Algeria.”

His advice was followed. After World War II Algeria also wanted independence – and had to fight for it. In the Battle of Algiers in 1957 General Massu’s paratroop division made use of its methods in Madagascar and Indochina, also against civilians, with illegal executions and forced disappearances, in particular through what would later become known as “death flights”. “Viewing Algerians as a sub-human race made the use of torture more agreeable if not enjoyable for the torturer.” General Paul Aussaresses ”referred to Algerian fighters and sympathizers as rats, criminals, rebels, militants, and bandits.” In his memoir he wrote of the “disappearances” of many prisoners: “Only rarely were the prisoners we had questioned during the night still alive the next morning.”

“First, the officer questions the prisoner in the ‘traditional’ manner, hitting him with fists and kicking him. Then follows torture: hanging…, water torture…, electricity…, burning (using cigarettes, etc.)… Cases of prisoners who were driven insane were frequent… Between interrogation sessions, the suspects are imprisoned without food in cells, some of which were small enough to impede lying down…some of them were very young teenagers and others old men of 75, 80 years or more.”

Henri Alleg, a Communist journalist and writer, disclosed that the French military even buried old men alive. He was himself tortured and described in horrifying detail the method now known as waterboarding and also electrical torture with hand generators.

And press freedom? With the government long denying any use of torture, more than 250 books, newspapers and films in metropolitan France and 586 in Algeria were censored; Alleg’s factual “La Question“ and Jean-Luc Godard’s film, “Le Petit Soldat”, were forbidden by a Socialist government headed by Guy Mollet. No, then and now, press freedom could never be taken for granted.

The war with Algeria still raged in October 1961 during the “Paris massacre”. Under orders from Chief Maurice Papon, later convicted as a war criminal, French police attacked a demonstration of 30,000 Algerians. The results were horrifying: many died when they were violently herded by police into the river Seine, with some thrown from bridges after being beaten unconscious. Others were killed in the courtyard of police headquarters while senior officers ignored pleas by other policemen shocked at the brutality. 10,000 were arrested, estimates on those killed range from 70 to 200.

No, brutality is not somehow restricted to Islam or Muslims. Even my short-term memory and US nationality force me to remember Abu Zubaydah, father of four daughters, arrested in Pakistan in 2002 and in US custody for over twelve years, During that time he was water-boarded 83 times, subjected to forced nudity, sleep deprivation, confinement in small dark boxes, stress positions. After physical assaults he lost his left eye. Videotapes were destroyed, but we know that the waterboarding sessions ‘resulted in immediate fluid intake and involuntary leg, chest and arm spasms’ and ‘hysterical pleas’. In at least one such session, he “became completely unresponsive, with bubbles rising through his open, full mouth’. After medical intervention he regained consciousness and ‘expelled copious amounts of liquid’.”

In 2006 he was transferred to Guantanamo’s Camp 7, where conditions were especially miserable. Then in 2007 the Review Tribunal told Zubaydah that he was “not significant”. “They told me ‘Sorry, we discover that you are not Number 3, not a partner, not even a fighter’.”

Gul Rahman was arrested at his doctor’s home after traveling to Islamabad for a medical checkup. He, too, was subjected to “48 hours of sleep deprivation, auditory overload, total darkness, isolation, a cold shower and rough treatment”. Gul Rahman died on 20 November 2002, reportedly after being stripped naked from the waist down and shackled to a cold cement wall in the “Salt Pit” with 36° F/2° C temperatures.

As one CIA interrogator reported, “a detainee could go for days or weeks without anyone looking at him.” His team found one detainee who “as far as we could determine had been chained to a wall in a standing position for 17 days.”  Some prisoners were said to be like dogs in kennels. In 2006, during a CIA briefing, President George W. Bush expressed discomfort at the “image of a detainee, chained to the ceiling, clothed in a diaper, and forced to go to the bathroom on himself”. This man was chained with one or both wrists to an overhead bar for 22 hours on two consecutive days. His imprisonment was concealed from the Red Cross International Committee.

British attorney Clive Stafford Smith reported on as many as twenty teenagers imprisoned at Guantanamo, some in long-term, solitary confinement. One Afghan human rights worker asserted that one lad was only 12 or 13 when he was captured.

Such victims’ names are rarely known or quickly forgotten. Despite that highly-valued Freedom of the Press. Again, I must recall July 2011 when NATO planes (35% of them French) bombed the Libyan state TV station, killing  three journalists and injuring 15. The International Federation of Journalists stated: “We utterly condemn this action, which targeted journalists and threatened their lives in violation of international law…Our concern is that when one side decides to take out a media organization because they regard its message as propaganda, then all media are at risk”. For some people like me the action recalled April 1999 when a NATO plane destroyed the TV and radio station of Belgrade, killing sixteen Serbian Radio-TV employees with one well-aimed rocket and calling it “a legitimate target” because it was a “propaganda mouthpiece”.

But the men at Charlie Hebdo were writers and creators, unique and irreplaceable. True, I feel certain. But did that not also apply to Charles Horman, US journalist and film-maker, killed during the USA-backed putsch in Chile in 1973 (and made famous by the film “Missing”)? Or, on the same occasion, to the wonderful singer-songwriter Victor Jara? What about the Belgian-organized, USA-supported torture and murder of the Congolese poet and political leader, Patrice Lumumba? Or of novelist and film-maker Ken Saro-Wiwa in Nigeria, hanged with the connivance of Shell Oil? Or the Palestinian Ghassan Kanafani, considered one of the greatest modern Arabic authors, whose car was booby trapped by the Mossad in July, 1972?

I cannot help thinking that there are far more too many very bloody, extremely wealthy criminals at large in the world, whose actions are rarely reported on, unless marital or extra-marital. Action based on a true belief in press freedom can be mercilessly punished, as it was learned by Julian Assange, Chelsea Manning, Edward Snowden – or Mumia Abu-Jamal!

What I now fear is a renewed misuse of the latest assassinations, encouraging mass feelings of revenge not just toward a few dead assassins or perhaps twisted religious beliefs, but toward anyone  with a darker skin color and differences in language or clothing – hence away from the true perpetrators, those worsening the very social conditions which breed fanaticism, and from their marionettes, who have career goals but no consciences and are already spouting their now hardly muted poison, cashing in on expanding  hatred. The PEGIDA marchers in Germany now plan to wear mourning arm-bands for Charlie – and look for belated applause by leaders of the major parties.

What we need is the very opposite! We must work to close gaps, clasp hands  and work together for a better world. We dare not forget those countless bloody deeds recorded largely in dusty archives – and their urgent lessons! I may well join in with “Je suis Charlie!” but must add: “I am Gul Rahman! I am Abu Zubaydah! I am Charles Horman and Ken Saro-Wiwa! I am Ghassan Kanafani and Victor Jara!”

With this broader view we must call to people in Dresden and other German cities. They have not been guilty of any crimes or real violence. But my own background makes me remind them that one or the other of their grandfathers may have joined in shooting down the great Yiddish poet Mordecai Gebirtig in Krakow on “Bloody Thursday”, June 4, 1942. Today’s generation bears no blame for such deeds. But they will bear much of the blame if Gebirtig’s great poem and song needs again to be shouted once again as new warning and alarm: ”Es brennt! Brothers, our town is burning!”

Victor Grossman writes the Berlin Bulletin, which you can subscribe to for free by sending an email to: wechsler_grossman@yahoo.de.

More articles by:

Victor Grossman writes the Berlin Bulletin, which you can subscribe to for free by sending an email to: wechsler_grossman@yahoo.de.

Weekend Edition
December 14, 2018
Friday - Sunday
Andrew Levine
A Tale of Two Cities
Peter Linebaugh
The Significance of The Common Wind
Bruce E. Levine
The Ketamine Chorus: NYT Trumpets New Anti-Suicide Drug
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Fathers and Sons, Bushes and Bin Ladens
Kathy Deacon
Coffee, Social Stratification and the Retail Sector in a Small Maritime Village
Nick Pemberton
Praise For America’s Second Leading Intellectual
Robert Hunziker
The Yellow Vest Insurgency – What’s Next?
Patrick Cockburn
The Yemeni Dead: Six Times Higher Than Previously Reported
Nick Alexandrov
George H. W. Bush: Another Eulogy
Brian Cloughley
Principles and Morality Versus Cash and Profit? No Contest
Michael Duggin
Climate Change and the Limits of Reason
Victor Grossman
Sighs of Relief in Germany
Ron Jacobs
A Propagandist of Privatization
Robert Fantina
What Does Beto Have Against the Palestinians?
Richard Falk – Daniel Falcone
Sartre, Said, Chomsky and the Meaning of the Public Intellectual
Andrew Glikson
Crimes Against the Earth
Robert Fisk
The Parasitic Relationship Between Power and the American Media
Stephen Cooper
When Will Journalism Grapple With the Ethics of Interviewing Mentally Ill Arrestees?
Jill Richardson
A War on Science, Morals and Law
Ron Jacobs
A Propagandist of Privatization
Evaggelos Vallianatos
It’s Not Easy Being Greek
Nomi Prins 
The Inequality Gap on a Planet Growing More Extreme
John W. Whitehead
Know Your Rights or You Will Lose Them
David Swanson
The Abolition of War Requires New Thoughts, Words, and Actions
J.P. Linstroth
Primates Are Us
Bill Willers
The War Against Cash
Jonah Raskin
Doris Lessing: What’s There to Celebrate?
Ralph Nader
Are the New Congressional Progressives Real? Use These Yardsticks to Find Out
Binoy Kampmark
William Blum: Anti-Imperial Advocate
Medea Benjamin – Alice Slater
Green New Deal Advocates Should Address Militarism
John Feffer
Review: Season 2 of Trump Presidency
Rich Whitney
General Motors’ Factories Should Not Be Closed. They Should Be Turned Over to the Workers
Christopher Brauchli
Deported for Christmas
Kerri Kennedy
This Holiday Season, I’m Standing With Migrants
Mel Gurtov
Weaponizing Humanitarian Aid
Thomas Knapp
Lame Duck Shutdown Theater Time: Pride Goeth Before a Wall?
George Wuerthner
The Thrill Bike Threat to the Elkhorn Mountains
Nyla Ali Khan
A Woman’s Selfhood and Her Ability to Act in the Public Domain: Resilience of Nadia Murad
Kollibri terre Sonnenblume
On the Killing of an Ash Tree
Graham Peebles
Britain’s Homeless Crisis
Louis Proyect
America: a Breeding Ground for Maladjustment
Steve Carlson
A Hell of a Time
Dan Corjescu
America and The Last Ship
Jeffrey St. Clair
Booked Up: the 25 Best Books of 2018
David Yearsley
Bikini by Rita, Voice by Anita