Torture in Oz

One of the least convincing arguments ever submitted for any consideration is the idea that “people don’t do that sort of thing”. It is against their nature. It is against a perceived code. It has the weak standing of a gentleman’s agreement, a sort of arrangement made on the cricket greens trodden upon by chaps wearing white flannels. You simply don’t play dirty, because you have a strict ethical system that trumps any chance of that happening.

The disconcerting nature of this is evident in the debate surrounding Australia’s National Security Legislation Amendment Bill (No. 1), a demon-like creation of the conjurer and Attorney-General, Senator George Brandis. Its problems are so numerous it should sink under the weight of its own ominousness. It suggests a further criminalisation of whistleblowers, leakers and journalists and also gives a rather bright green light to intelligence officials to run riot in paramilitary fashion against enemies of the state.

Brandis can’t see what the fuss is about. “Under no circumstances has ASIO ever or would ASIO ever be authorised to torture.” But the sentiment here is that of impossibility – Australians, and indeed Australian intelligence services – would not engage in a form of conduct that would run foul of the UN Torture Convention and an assortment of other laws. “This is not something that any Australian government agency, no matter what the circumstances, could ever do.”

The opposition, meeker than ever, did express some concern, though it was obviously not expressed very heatedly, if at all, when such Labor figures as Tanya Plibersek, Penny Wong and John Faulkner were scrutinising it. The Shadow attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, treated the problem as one of minor scribbling and wording, suggesting the precise conundrum a state faces when it wishes to roughen suspects or obtain intelligence.

“It might be a matter of just a simple amendment that can be made to this legislation which is being debated in the parliament next week that absolutely puts beyond doubt that there’s no immunity anywhere in Australian law that could in any way suggest that any Australian government employee could engage in an act of torture.” At the stroke of a pen, the problem, for Dreyfus, would disappear, an astonishingly empty legal analysis if ever there was one.

The problem here is the wording of exemption in the bill itself. That it stipulates those circumstances of exoneration so clearly (under section 35K), is a suggestion that anything short of that will be within the margins of the law. Intelligence and regulatory agencies would only be liable in actions that cause death or serious injury to any person; involve the commission of a sexual offence against any person or cause significant loss of, or serious damage, to property.

This is the classic legislative pitfall – the specific stipulations invariably create the doors of exception, or as Paul Sheehan has observed, those “150 shades of grey, ranging from ethical ambiguity to outright black ops”. Those exceptions are simply dismissed as remote possibilities, and even impossibilities by the “Australian values” brigade.

The only senator who seems to have provided any sliver of merit to the debate has been the quizzical Senator David Leyonhjelm, one of the politicians who holds the balance of power in the chamber. Brandis has naturally dismissed his fellow senator’s claims of impending Stasiland as “absolute rubbish” – after all, he doesn’t understand the unwavering qualities of the law abiding spirit inherent in the intelligence and security establishment. Radicalised Muslims are naughty; ASIO agents never are.

Again, Brandis seeks refuge in procedural formulae, rather than the consequences of the bill’s wording. He deems it sufficient that a bipartisan committee examined the bill twice, not once taking issue with the scope of the immunity from prosecution, the shoddy compensation regime, and the lessening of oversight.

Instead, Brandis claims that the new laws will bring ASIO in line with the Australian Federal Police, and its operations, which is in itself a troubling problem. By that very observation on Brandis’ part, ASIO is being given a broader policing scope, one that involves interrogation, detention, and good old psychological mauling.

Leyonhjelm differs from the nasty conventional wisdom in spectacular fashion. He has spoken of receiving legal advice that this bill, passed in its current form, would leave the way open to a torture system. And he also sees it spreading like uncontrollable bacilli in the security state. “Any torture would not be limited to a terrorist suspect but could extend to anyone associated with a suspect, including family members.”2 Those acts inflicted on the individuals in question would further be compounded in their injuriousness by the fact that they had to be kept secret. Whatever happens, speak no evil.

As the bill winds its way to the vote, the amendments are promising to be few and toothless. The Attorney General has all the cards at this point, and is determined to convert ASIO into a playground bully with policing potential. The Australian Federal Police have every reason for being miffed at this, as do the civil libertarians.

Dr. Binoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne. Email: bkampmark@gmail.com

More articles by:

Binoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne. Email: bkampmark@gmail.com

March 18, 2019
Scott Poynting
Terrorism Has No Religion
Ipek S. Burnett
Black Lives on Trial
John Feffer
The World’s Most Dangerous Divide
Paul Cochrane
On the Ground in Venezuela vs. the Media Spectacle
Dean Baker
The Fed and the 3.8 Percent Unemployment Rate
Thomas Knapp
Social Media Companies “Struggle” to Help Censors Keep us in the Dark
Binoy Kampmark
Death in New Zealand: The Christchurch Shootings
Mark Weisbrot
The Reality Behind Trump’s Venezuela Regime Change Coalition
Weekend Edition
March 15, 2019
Friday - Sunday
Andrew Levine
Is Ilhan Omar Wrong…About Anything?
Kenn Orphan
Grieving in the Anthropocene
Jeffrey Kaye
On the Death of Guantanamo Detainee 10028
Stan Cox – Paul Cox
In Salinas, Puerto Rico, Vulnerable Americans Are Still Trapped in the Ruins Left by Hurricane Maria
Ben Debney
Christchurch, the White Victim Complex and Savage Capitalism
Eric Draitser
Did Dallas Police and Local Media Collude to Cover Up Terrorist Threats against Journalist Barrett Brown?
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Straighten Up and Fly Right
Jack Rasmus
Trump’s $34 Trillion Deficit and Debt Bomb
David Rosen
America’s Puppet: Meet Juan Guaidó
Jason Hirthler
Annexing the Stars: Walcott, Rhodes, and Venezuela
Samantha M. - Angelica Perkins
Our Green New Deal
Mel Gurtov
Trump’s Nightmare Budget
Steven Colatrella
The 18th Brumaire of Just About Everybody: the Rise of Authoritarian Strongmen and How to Prevent and Reverse It
Evaggelos Vallianatos
Riding the Wild Bull of Nuclear Power
Michael K. Smith
Thirty Years Gone: Remembering “Cactus Ed”
Dean Baker
In Praise of Budget Deficits
Howard Lisnoff
Want Your Kids to Make it Big in the World of Elite Education in the U.S.?
Brian Cloughley
Trump’s Foreign Policy is Based on Confrontation and Malevolence
John W. Whitehead
Pity the Nation: War Spending is Bankrupting America
Priti Gulati Cox
“Maria! Maria! It Was Maria That Destroyed Us!” The Human Story
Missy Comley Beattie
On Our Knees
Mike Garrity – Carole King
A Landscape Lewis and Clark Would Recognize is Under Threat
Robert Fantina
The Media-Created Front Runners
Tom Clifford
Bloody Sunday and the Charging of Soldier F
Ron Jacobs
All the Livelong Day      
Christopher Brauchli
Banking, Wells Fargo-Style
Jeff Mackler
After Week-Long Strike, Oakland Teachers’ Contract Falls Short
Chuck Collins
Bring Back Eisenhower Socialism!
Binoy Kampmark
Grounding Boeing
James Munson
Why Are We Still Sycophants?
Jill Richardson
Politicians Are Finally Catching Up on Marijuana
Warren Alan Tidwell
Disasters Don’t Discriminate, But Disaster Recovery Does
Robert Koehler
Artifial Morality
Matthew Stevenson
Pacific Odyssey: Goodenough Island in MacArthur’s Wake
Alex McDonald
U.S. Iran Policy: What is Great?
Tracey L. Rogers
Stop Making Women Apologize
John Sarbanes – Michael Brune
To Clean Up the Planet, Clean Up DC First