The Second Spanish Invasion of Northern California

The Spanish wine corporation Grupo Codorn?u is accustomed to doing things in a big way.  It is reputed to own a greater expanse of vineyard acreage than any wine company in Spain, which in turn has more land under grapevine cultivation than any nation in the world.  It is perhaps the world’s largest distributor of the Spanish sparkling wine Cava, producing more than 100 million bottles of it annually at a wine factory in Barcelona, which are distributed en masse to over 100 countries spanning the globe.

Codorn?u’s portfolio also features what may well be the world’s largest vineyard, a 4,000-acre span of tendril and vine that acts as source of grapes for one among the many wineries in its portfolio, Raimat ? “recognized,” according to the company’s web site, “as Spain’s preeminent wine estate.” This monolithic grape plantation covers a surface area of 6.25 square miles.
It is not at all surprising that in one of the various wine country regions where Codorn?u is invested, it is proposing to carry out the largest conversion of designated forestland to vineyards ever to occur there.  What may be slightly surprising is that said region, the California North Coast, is located nearly half a world away from the company’s Iberian headquarters.

The proposal in question, first pitched to the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CALFIRE) in different form all the way back in 2001, currently calls for clearing approximately 153-acres on a 324-acre estate known as “Fairfax,” located just outside of Annapolis on the northernmost Sonoma Coast, just south of the Mendocino County line.  Countless such displacements of forests by vineyards have occurred across the years, although never officially on the same scale.

Codorn?u’s plan would culminate roughly as follows: an underpaid migrant workforce will wade into 153 acres of chemically sterilized barren land where groves of redwood, doug fir, and manzanita had only just stood, the trees’ root systems having just been cleaved from the earth by a small fleet of Caterpillars D-9s or D-10 bulldozers, and install rows of pinot noir and other “premium” grape varieties, which the company will use as a source of the wines it makes under the “Artesa” label based in the Napa Valley. Codorn?u founded Artesa in Napa’s Carneros region in 1991, in the midst of a period whereby investments in prestigious California Wine Country appellations were emerging as more and more lucrative options for Europe’s greatest wine baronies ? viz., the Rothschilds in Napa Valley and Roederer Estate in the Anderson Valley.

That period arguably ended with the self-immolation of the global economy in 2008, although Codorn?u has persisted with its original plan essentially intact.  According to vintners in the area, the gold ridge soil of the area combined with the coastal influences of the climate extend the growing season, thus making for a complex ? and, potentially, highly prestigious ? wine.

If the plan goes through, it would deal a severe blow to a landbase struggling to recover from years of clear-cut forestry practices, also putting a new straw in the Gualala River watershed, which is already horribly damaged and nowadays supports only a relative handful of fish. One of the river’s three forks, the Wheatfield Fork, dried up entirely in 2008, despite having flowed year-round throughout its recorded history.  This catastrophic turn was a likely consequence of intensive vineyard development in the region across the previous ten years, which greatly exacerbated damage wrought over years of logging (mostly), as well as ranching and fruit tree cultivation (secondarily).

Codorn?u likely would have successfully carried out its forest-to-vineyard conversion several years ago but for the work of Friends of the Gualala River (FoGR), a small non-profit group that runs on the strength of a handful of volunteers who live in Annapolis and Gualala, and which is sustained financially by small donations from local residents.  FOGR has consistently hired specialists in the relevant scientific disciplines to challenge the conversion project as it has slowly played out through the regulatory system.  As a consequence, that process has become an increasingly hard slog for Codorn?u/Artesa, which first wrote a THP in 2001, then withdrew it in 2004, suddenly introducing a new one in 2009.  It released its first draft Environmental Impact Review for the project in 2009, then essentially revised several pages of the document and recirculated it earlier this year.  The more than 10 years the company has taken to put forward its final EIR is nearly unprecedented.

Looming in the background of the Codorn?u proposal is the plan by Premier Pacific Vineyards (PPV) to convert approximately 1,700 acres of redwoods to grapes on nearby hilltops, in the same watershed, which I’ve described earlier and will also do so in far more detail in an upcoming piece.  The executives at PPV are undoubtedly watching closely to see how, or if, the “Fairfax” project ultimately pans out.

While it would be prohibitively expensive for many vineyard developers to get bogged down in a regulatory quagmire involving competent environmentalist foes, particularly having made such an alarmingly destructive proposal, not so for Codorn?u.  According to one source, the company has annual revenue of nearly $500 million.

In fact, the company spent a total of $50 million across two phases to construct the Artesa Winery complex in Carneros, a lavish facility that closely reflects the ostentatious image it has yoked to its American operations.  Drawing on Codorn?u’s stature as the longest-running wine company in Spain (founding year: 1553), the company goes to elaborate lengths to play up the artistry of its wines, implying that they draw on ancient oenological traditions with a nouveau twist.  “Artesa” translates as “craftsman” in Catalan, the language of Barcelona, Spain.

Artesa’s Carneros facility is a modernist-style winery built right into a hillside and covered with lush native grasses, shaped in the kind of pyramidal configuration that creates the illusion of a temple just unearthed ? as one fawning wine critic described it.  To create the design, the winery’s construction crew leveled the hillside in question, essentially removing the entire hilltop (irony, not tragedy, is the genre to which at least part of the story of Codorniu’s American operations belongs).  Stairs framed by cascading water lead into the winery, with the courtyard, staircase, and winery itself all adorned with opulent steel and stained glass sculptures.  The interior features sleek furnishings, an array of neon colored walls bonded to glass walls, with fine wood furnishings placed sparingly throughout the room, which when combined with the collection of sculptures, paintings, glass figures, and ancient-looking oak barrels, create the unmistakable impression that one is lodged not inside a winery, but rather an art studio.

Of course, this approach to image-making has countless precedents in Wine Country.  As the journalist-historian of the region James Conaway observed in his book Napa, when describing the marketing strategy the wine industry adopted in the Napa Valley in the ’80s and ’90s,

“’The winemaker’s art,’ in fact a craft, was a phrase repeated throughout history; winemakers realized early on that art is more marketable than craft, and more prestigious.  Robert Mondavi and his family, on the release of Opus One, compared the different vintages of their elegant new Cabernet to Picasso and Cezanne — and charged an unprecedented $30 a bottle… If wine was art, the winery was perforce a studio. Some became unofficial galleries as well.”

Artesa has outdone nearly all other wineries, however, by actually having featured its own artist-in-residence at the winery, a nationally famous Napa Valley sculptor named Gordon Huether.  The amount the company spends annually to maintain its modernist art image, then, would seem to be is greater than the wine production budgets of many modern wineries.

Codorn?u’s financial and cultural stature is far greater in its home country than in the United States, of course.  Take one member of the company’s former majority owning family, Manuel Ravent?s, who parlayed his stature as a one-time owner of Codorniu to become director at Criteria CaixaCorp, the principal investment holding arm of Europe’s largest savings bank, La Caixa, which has tens of billions of dollars under management.  Ravent?s is also a director of Spain’s largest health insurance company, VidaCaixa Group.  Ravent?s formerly was a director of Spain’s largest oil refining company, Respol, the 15th largest such outfit in the world.

In spite of its financial successes, Codorn?u as a company does not always makes wise investments.  The decision by its Napa proxies to go to such extreme lengths to develop a pinot noir vineyard outside Annapolis was made during the height of the premium grape rush, which statistically peaked in the late-’90s in terms of the number of vineyard acres being planned, tapering off noticeably after the Silicon Valley bubble burst in 2002.  Since 2008, the market for high-end wine has been severely glutted in particular, with countless Sonoma and Mendocino growers having to sit on their grapes or sell them at an unprofitable price.

The market for Pinot Noir remained on the ascendancy far longer than it otherwise would have, however, because of how much consumer interest in that varietal arose after the 2004 release of the movie Sideways.  As the great Frankfurt School philosopher Theodor Adorno once wrote, “The culture industry not so much adapts to the reactions of its customers as it counterfeits them.”

But even this particular counterfeit no longer carries as much weight it did pre-2008.  Last month, Friends of the Gualala River mailed an appeal to the current Codorniu CEO, calling on him to pull the plug on the project.  The letter was signed by a coalition including numerous national and California environmental organizations.  The letter “cite[s] unacceptable impacts of the project due to irreversible loss of redwood forest and soils, impacts on recovery of severely threatened steelhead trout, Coho salmon, rare wildlife species, river flows, and water quality,” as a prelude to it states on the FOGR web site,  A number of new clips concerning the downturn in the regional wine market were attached to the letter, in an effort to persuade the Codorniu brain trust to see the economic folly in carrying their plan forward.

The letter has resulted in considerable publicity on behalf of the struggle to prevent the Fairfax conversion. An Associated Press story on the topic by a writer named Jason Dearen hit the wire last week.  It was picked up by newspapers and internet publications throughout the country, including the San Francisco Chronicle and Washington Post.

The story was at first published on the Santa Rosa Press Democrat’s web site.  Mysteriously, it then vanished from the web site of the California North Coast’s illustrious newspaper of record hours after the initial posting.  “Article No Longer Available,” the page where the article once appeared succinctly reads.

All of this isn’t even to mention perhaps the most salient aspect of Codorniu’s invasion of the remote reaches of the California North Coast: the fact that the “Fairfax” property is one of the most important surviving sacred sites of the Kashaya Pomo people, whose contemporary homebase is the Stewarts Point Rancheria a few miles from Annapolis.  Burial grounds have been discovered at the site, as well as strong evidence of a previous village site. I will describe in a future article  the regulatory proceedings surrounding the Fairfax conversion in far more detail, set against the backdrop of the efforts by Kashaya elders to protect the site from being bulldozed for grapes, and instead turn it into an education center focused on Kashaya history and lifeways.

Until then, a few final words on the project.  When I first began gathering documentation on the wine industry’s activities across the North Coast, I made a day-long visit to CALFIRE’s North Coast regional headquarters off Steele Rd., near Santa Rosa City College in northern Santa Rosa.  In particular, I was interested in understanding more details concerning the spate of forest-to-vineyard conversions in the area in recent years.  I asked at the front desk if anybody was available to guide me through the process of using the CALFIRE reading room.  An engaging young forester in her late-20s early-30s emerged from somewhere amid the bowels of CALFIRE’s trailer and office complex, parked me inside the small trailer where the reading room is located, then emerged with an Excel chart displaying all proposed and completed forest projects in Sonoma, Lake, and Mendocino Counties across the past 10 years.  She asked me to select one of these projects so she could pull out the file and walk me through how it is organized.

I immediately selected the Artesa/Fairfax file as our case study, it having the largest number in a column indicating the amount of acreage to be converted.  As we leafed through the collection of documents, her explaining the philosophical underpinnings of CALFIRE’s cataloging system as we went, her level of interest in the project was visibly growing.  She seemed a little bit dumbfounded.  Finally, she let slip a candid assessment of the project represented by the archival record splayed out on the table before us.
“Wow, they actually had to withdraw their initial proposal,” she exclaimed, though not loud enough that anybody other than me could hear.  “That must mean there’s really something wrong this project!”

There is indeed.  It simply remains to be seen if the regulatory system will officially recognize it.

Will Parrish is a political organizer and freelance writer from Northern California, much of whose work first appears in the Anderson Valley Advertiser. He can be reached at  wparrish@riseup.net.

More articles by:

Will Parrish is a freelance investigative journalist based in Northern California.  His web site is www.willparrishreports.com. Follow him on Twitter @willparrishca.

February 17, 2020
Sheldon Richman
Anti-BDS Laws Violate Our Freedom
John Horning
NEPA is Our National Defense System

Evelyn Leopold
How the UN’s Middle East Peace Plan Was Trounced by Its Own Members
Stephen Cooper
“Just Mercy” and Justice Don’t Exist in Alabama
Patrick Cockburn
Sinn Fein’s Victory is Ireland’s ‘Brexit Moment’ When Left-Out Voters Turn on the Elite
Ralph Nader
“Democratic Socialism” – Bring it on Corporate Socialists!
Phillip Doe
Every Day’s a Holiday for the Oil Business in Colorado
Binoy Kampmark
Fashion Fetishism, Surgical Masks and Coronavirus
Cesar Chelala
The Democrats’ New Chapter
Robert Koehler
The Wall: Separating Democracy From Voters
Peter Cohen
Time to Retire the “He Can’t Beat Trump” Trope
Sr. Kathleen Erickson
Lessons From Ministering on the Border
Alvaro Huerta
Another Five Lessons for Democrats to Defeat Trump in 2020
Wim Laven
Donald Trump’s Plan for America: Make it Ignorant
Christopher Brauchli
You Tube’s Trump Predicament
Steve Klinger
Trump Shoots Romney at Prayer Breakfast; GOP Shrugs
Elliot Sperber
Ode to the City Bus 
James Haught
Megachurch Mess
Weekend Edition
February 14, 2020
Friday - Sunday
Andrew Levine
Mayor Mike, Worse Than Mayor Pete
Bruce E. Levine
“Sublime Madness”: Anarchists, Psychiatric Survivors, Emma Goldman & Harriet Tubman
Jeffrey St. Clair
Roaming Charges: Leader of the Pack
Jennifer Matsui
The Doomsday Cuckoo Clock
Paul Street
Things Said in Confidence to 4000 Close Friends This Week
Jonathan Cook
Even With Corbyn Gone, Antisemitism Threats Will Keep Destroying the UK Labour Party
Thomas Klikauer
Cambridge Analytica: a Salesgirl’s Report
Joseph Natoli
Vichy Democrats vs. the Master Voice
David Rosen
Sanders vs. the Establishment Democrats: McGovern All Over Again?
Louis Proyect
Marx, Lincoln and Project 1619
Robert Hunziker
Amazon Onslaught
Russell Mokhiber
NPR and the Escalating Attack on Single-Payer Health Care
Ramzy Baroud
Breaking with Washington: Arabs and Muslims Must Take a United Stance for Palestine
Mike Miller
Race and Class: Overcoming the Divides
Michael Brennan
Timeline: How the DNC Manipulated 2016 Presidential Race 
Jacob G. Hornberger
U. S. Lies and Deaths in Afghanistan
Rev. William Alberts
Trump Served Up Projection at the National Prayer Breakfast
Nick Pemberton
The Overwhelming Sex Appeal Of Bernie Sanders
David Swanson
Why This Election Is Different
Dan Bacher
Western States Petroleum Association Tops CA Lobbying Expenses with $8.8 Million Spent in 2019
Christopher Ketcham
The Medium Warps the Message Straight to Our Extinction
Erik Molvar
Trump’s Gutting of NEPA Will Cut the Public Out of Public Lands Decisions
William Kaufman
Tulsi Gabbard: A Political Postmortem
Colin Todhunter
Menace on the Menu in Post-EU Britain
Gregory Elich
Mnangagwa’s Neoliberal Assault on the Zimbabwean People
Ron Jacobs
The Lies of Industry and the Liars Who Sell Them
Binoy Kampmark
Subverting the Blacklist: Kirk Douglas’s Modest Contribution