FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail

Forced Returns From Guantanamo

Most prisoners held at Guantanamo are desperate to return home. But a small number are so fearful of what awaits them in their country of origin that they would choose indefinite custody at Guantanamo over repatriation.

This group of doubly unfortunate prisoners includes the Uighurs, members of a Muslim minority from western China, as well as a number of Tunisians, Libyans, and Algerians. The men claim that they would face torture or other serious abuse if sent back to their home countries.

Until recently, the Obama administration had not forcibly repatriated anyone from Guantanamo. Rather than carrying out involuntary returns, it had found safe third countries to resettle detainees who feared persecution at home. These included men from China, Egypt, Libya, and Syria, among others.

But some ten days ago, the Obama administration set a worrying precedent. Without holding a fair legal proceeding to assess the detainee’s claimed fear of return, the administration transferred Aziz Abdul Naji back to his home country of Algeria.

Algerians at Guantanamo

Naji had been held at Guantanamo since 2002. His lawyers said that he had told them that he did not want to return to Algeria under any circumstances because he feared persecution from both the Algerian government and Islamist militants. He was not the only Algerian detainee to express fear at being forcibly returned to Algeria; indeed, one has said he would rather spend the rest of his life in US custody than return to Algeria. Of the eight Algerians who remain at Guantanamo, five have reportedly claimed that they fear abuse if returned.

Algerian human-rights groups say that torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment are at times used on those suspected of terror links.

The US government claims, in contrast, that detainees can be returned to Algeria safely. US officials say that the country’s human rights record has improved significantly over the past decade, even though the US State Department’s annual human-rights report on Algeria acknowledges that allegations of torture are still prevalent.

Diplomatic Assurances

The US has a legal obligation not to send people to countries where they would face torture. According to the Convention against Torture, which the US ratified in 1994, no one can be sent to a country where there are substantial grounds for believing that the person would be in danger of being subjected to torture or other ill-treatment. The Committee against Torture, the international expert body that monitors compliance with the Convention against Torture, said in 2006 that the United States “should always ensure that suspects have the possibility to challenge decisions of refoulement [return].”

In court filings in cases involving Algerian detainees, US officials have argued in favor of returns by claiming that the Algerian government has provided so-called “diplomatic assurances” to the United States. But these assurances — which consist of unenforceable promises to treat returned detainees humanely — do not provide an effective safeguard against torture and ill-treatment.

During the Bush presidency, Human Rights Watch documented that detainees who were sent home to Russia and Tunisia suffered abuse despite diplomatic assurances from the receiving countries that they would treat the returned men humanely.

The Need for an Individualized Assessment

Some 26 Algerians were originally held at Guantanamo. Before Naji’s involuntarily return, ten Algerians had voluntarily returned to Algeria. Most of these men were held incommunicado for 12 days after return by the Algerian Department of Intelligence and Security (DRS), as permitted under Algerian law. None of the men reported that they were physically abused while in custody.

The government subsequently charged several of the returned men with being members of a foreign terrorist organization and tried them in criminal court. All were acquitted. (Another detainee, Ahmed Belbacha, who remains at Guantanamo, was tried in absentia in November 2009 and sentenced to 20 years in prison. Under Algerian law, Belbacha has the right to a new trial upon his return to Algeria.)

Although the Algerian detainees who were returned voluntarily to Algeria have not reported serious abuse, this does not provide a firm basis for determining how future returnees will be treated. Some of the men who returned voluntarily were elderly, in ill health, or had wound up at Guantanamo as cases of mistaken identity. Some of the remaining detainees at Guantanamo, though never charged by the United States with any crime, might be perceived by the Algerian government as more dangerous than those who previously returned.

Although Naji sought to assert his claim of feared ill-treatment before a federal court, his petition was denied at the district and appellate level, and the Supreme Court refused to stay his transfer pending further appeal.

The Algerians who currently remain at Guantanamo should be granted access to a fairer procedure. If someone would rather stay at Guantanamo than go home, he should be given the chance to explain why in a proper legal setting.

JOANNE MARINER is a human rights lawyer based in New York and Paris.

 

WORDS THAT STICK

?

 

More articles by:

JOANNE MARINER is a human rights lawyer living in New York and Paris.

December 12, 2018
Arshad Khan
War, Anniversaries and Lessons Never Learned
Paul Street
Blacking Out the Yellow Vests on Cable News: Corporate Media Doing its Job
Kenneth Surin
The Brexit Shambles Rambles On
David Schultz
Stacking the Deck Against Democracy in Wisconsin
Steve Early
The Housing Affordability Crisis and What Millennials Can do About It
George Ochenski
Collaboration Failure: Trump Trashes Sage Grouse Protections
Rob Seimetz
Bringing a Life Into a Dying World: A Letter From a Father to His Unborn Son
Michael Howard
PETA and the ‘S’-Word
John Kendall Hawkins
Good Panopt, Bad Panopt: Does It Make A Difference?
Kim C. Domenico
Redeeming Utopia: a Meditation On An Essay by Ursula LeGuin
Binoy Kampmark
Exhuming Franco: Spain’s Immemorial Divisions
ADRIAN KUZMINSKI
Democratizing Money
Laura Finley
Congress Must Reauthorize VAWA
December 11, 2018
Eric Draitser
AFRICOM: A Neocolonial Occupation Force?
Sheldon Richman
War Over Ukraine?
Louis Proyect
Why World War II, Not the New Deal, Ended the Great Depression
Howard Lisnoff
Police Violence and Mass Policing in the U.S.
Mark Ashwill
A “Patriotic” Education Study Abroad Program in Viet Nam: God Bless America, Right or Wrong!
Laura Flanders
HUD Official to Move into Public Housing?
Nino Pagliccia
Resistance is Not Terrorism
Matthew Johnson
See No Evil, See No Good: The Truth Is Not Black and White
Maria Paez Victor
How Reuters Slandered Venezuela’s Social Benefits Card
December 10, 2018
Jacques R. Pauwels
Foreign Interventions in Revolutionary Russia
Richard Klin
The Disasters of War
Katie Fite
Rebranding Bundy
Gary Olson
A Few Thoughts on Politics and Personal Identity
Patrick Cockburn
Brexit Britain’s Crisis of Self-Confidence Will Only End in Tears and Rising Nationalism
Andrew Moss
Undocumented Citizen
Dean Baker
Trump and China: Going With Patent Holders Against Workers
Lawrence Wittner
Reviving the Nuclear Disarmament Movement: a Practical Proposal
Dan Siegel
Thoughts on the 2018 Elections and Beyond
Thomas Knapp
Election 2020: I Can Smell the Dumpster Fires Already
Weekend Edition
December 07, 2018
Friday - Sunday
Steve Hendricks
What If We Just Buy Off Big Fossil Fuel? A Novel Plan to Mitigate the Climate Calamity
Jeffrey St. Clair
Cancer as Weapon: Poppy Bush’s Radioactive War on Iraq
Paul Street
The McCain and Bush Death Tours: Establishment Rituals in How to be a Proper Ruler
Jason Hirthler
Laws of the Jungle: The Free Market and the Continuity of Change
Ajamu Baraka
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights at 70: Time to De-Colonize Human Rights!
Andrew Levine
Thoughts on Strategy for a Left Opposition
Jennifer Matsui
Dead of Night Redux: A Zombie Rises, A Spook Falls
Rob Urie
Degrowth: Toward a Green Revolution
Binoy Kampmark
The Bomb that Did Not Detonate: Julian Assange, Manafort and The Guardian
Robert Hunziker
The Deathly Insect Dilemma
Robert Fisk
Spare Me the American Tears for the Murder of Jamal Khashoggi
Joseph Natoli
Tribal Justice
Ron Jacobs
Getting Pushed Off the Capitalist Cliff
FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail