Health Insurance Death Spiral

The most startling implication of Anthem/Blue Cross of California’s announcement last week that it is going to raise individual health insurance rates by up to 39 percent this year is not that insurance companies are arrogant and untouchable. That was already well known.

What has to be more alarming for the 800,000 Californians who are covered by Blue Cross individual health insurance policies is that their insurance rates appear to have entered what insurance industry underwriters call a death spiral.

In response to the announcement, President Barack Obama told CBS News, “That’s a portrait of the future if we don’t do something now.” Everyone from Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius to Congressional committee chairman to California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner, a Republican gubernatorial candidate, weighed in, promising investigations and asking Blue Cross for delays in implementation.

Their castigations of Blue Cross feel satisfying because part of the reason for the rate increase is an overreach by Blue Cross, as they pursue their endless quest for greater profits even in a time of extreme economic hardship. But they miss the more technical, scarier point: even Blue Cross doesn’t like to raise rates this much. They’d much rather get their slow and steady increases and keep the game going longer.

No, Blue Cross was forced into a huge increase because of the accelerating breakdown of the finance structure of the for-profit insurance industry. With this magnitude of increase, the day will come much sooner when real change in the industry is unavoidable.

A death spiral is no better than it sounds. A death spiral occurs when rising rates cause healthy people to leave the coverage pool (dropping coverage altogether). This exodus of the healthy is a feedback loop that causes rates to rise even faster as fewer and less healthy people are left paying premiums to cover all the cost of their claims without the cost dilution effect of premiums paid in by those who file fewer claims. The higher the rates go, the more people leave, the greater the rate increase must be in the next cycle, causing more people to leave, etc.

As Blue Cross itself explained in a statement issued late Monday, “Therefore, as medical costs increase across our member population, premium increases to the entire membership pool result. Unfortunately, in the weak economy many people who do not have health conditions are foregoing buying insurance. This leaves fewer people, often with significantly greater medical needs, in the insured pool.”

This is not good news for individual policy holders anywhere in the nation, some 13 million people in 2008. As costs continue to rise, the death spiral will gather steam in individual state pools.

The health care reform bills pending in Congress attempt to address this problem by forcing all the healthy people back into the pool by mandating that they purchase coverage. Congress recognizes that the cost of this coverage is already unaffordable, so the bills provide subsidies to help pay the premiums. By the time the bill would go into effect in 2014, rate increases will have greatly outpaced increases in the subsidy amount, which is tied to increases in the poverty level. This will leave big premiums for people to pay, even with subsidies.

The insurance companies already are arguing that the penalties proposed in the bills for not purchasing insurance are too low to be effective, so by 2014 people who can’t afford ever more onerous premiums will be more likely to elect not to purchase coverage and pay the lesser penalties instead.

The answer to the problem: eliminate all these distinct pools and replace them with one, big nationwide pool, with everybody in and nobody out, as would be provided by a single-payer system. Multiple pools, multiple insurance carriers, multiple marketing systems, and all the other redundant layers of bureaucracy required in the for-profit insurance scheme simply add unnecessary cost – and no value – to the delivery of health care.

Jeff Sher lives in the Bay Area. He can be reached at: jeffsher@sbcglobal.net

More articles by:

Jeff Sher is a journalist specializing in the health care industry. He lives in San Francisco.

Weekend Edition
August 16, 2019
Friday - Sunday
Paul Street
Uncle Sam was Born Lethal
Jennifer Matsui
La Danse Mossad: Robert Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein
Rob Urie
Neoliberalism and Environmental Calamity
Stuart A. Newman
The Biotech-Industrial Complex Gets Ready to Define What is Human
Nick Alexandrov
Prevention Through Deterrence: The Strategy Shared by the El Paso Shooter and the U.S. Border Patrol
Jeffrey St. Clair
The First Dambuster: a Coyote Tale
Eric Draitser
“Bernie is Trump” (and other Corporate Media Bullsh*t)
Nick Pemberton
Is White Supremacism a Mental Illness?
Jim Kavanagh
Dead Man’s Hand: The Impeachment Gambit
Andrew Levine
Have They No Decency?
David Yearsley
Kind of Blue at 60
Ramzy Baroud
Manifestos of Hate: What White Terrorists Have in Common
Evaggelos Vallianatos
The War on Nature
Martha Rosenberg
Catch and Hang Live Chickens for Slaughter: $11 an Hour Possible!
Yoav Litvin
Israel Fears a Visit by Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib
Neve Gordon
It’s No Wonder the Military likes Violent Video Games, They Can Help Train Civilians to Become Warriors
Susan Miller
That Debacle at the Border is Genocide
Ralph Nader
With the Boeing 737 MAX Grounded, Top Boeing Bosses Must Testify Before Congress Now
Victor Grossman
Warnings, Ancient and Modern
Meena Miriam Yust - Arshad Khan
The Microplastic Threat
Kavitha Muralidharan
‘Today We Seek Those Fish in Discovery Channel’
Louis Proyect
The Vanity Cinema of Quentin Tarantino
Bob Scofield
Tit For Tat: Baltimore Takes Another Hit, This Time From Uruguay
Nozomi Hayase
The Prosecution of Julian Assange Affects Us All
Ron Jacobs
People’s Music for the Soul
John Feffer
Is America Crazy?
Jonathan Power
Russia and China are Growing Closer Again
John W. Whitehead
Who Inflicts the Most Gun Violence in America? The U.S. Government and Its Police Forces
Justin Vest
ICE: You’re Not Welcome in the South
Jill Richardson
Race is a Social Construct, But It Still Matters
Dean Baker
The NYT Gets the Story on Automation and Inequality Completely Wrong
Nino Pagliccia
Venezuela Retains Political Control After New US Coercive Measures
Gary Leupp
MSNBC and the Next Election: Racism is the Issue (and Don’t Talk about Socialism)
R. G. Davis
Paul Krassner: Investigative Satirist
Negin Owliaei
Red State Rip Off: Cutting Worker Pay by $1.5 Billion
Christopher Brauchli
The Side of Trump We Rarely See
Curtis Johnson
The Unbroken Line: From Slavery to the El Paso Shooting
Jesse Jackson
End Endless War and Bring Peace to Korea
Adolf Alzuphar
Diary: What About a New City Center?
Tracey L. Rogers
Candidates Need a Moral Vision
Nicky Reid
I Was a Red Flag Kid
John Kendall Hawkins
The Sixties Victory Lap in an Empty Arena
Stephen Cooper
Tony Chin’s Unstoppable, Historic Career in Music
Charles R. Larson
Review: Bruno Latour’s Down to Earth: Politics in the New Climatic Regime
Elizabeth Keyes
Haiku Fighting