Voices of the Silenced

Celebrity chic, however well intended, always risks of the unexpected. It’s hard to feel otherwise, as I Live Here, by the American actress Mia Kirshner and a group of talented artists and writers, clearly illustrates. The four sleek pamphlets relating stories of the displaced from the war in Chechnya—and comparable atrocities in Mexico, Burma, and Malawi—burst with creative energy but simultaneously fall flat on the emotional level. The empathy they are intended to elicit in readers is largely missing, having been displaced by a numbing emotional distance.

In an interview that appeared in Glamour.Com (September 2008), Kirshner stated that in 2001, after a series of successful movie and TV roles, she felt that her life was empty and she needed to explore something more meaningful. Thus began a seven-year journey that took her to some of the world’s most troubled places, where she met and interviewed displaced people typically ignored by the complacent inhabitants of the stable Western world. The result became four “graphic” narratives, a project of the I Live Here Foundation in Vancouver. The nonprofit is “dedicated to telling stories of silenced and unheard people through a series of books and other projects about our world. We establish creative writing programs where we work, building an artistic dialogue between strangers.”

Part of the problem for me is Kirshner’s presence at the beginning and sometimes in later sections of each story. I found her perspective intrusive, bordering on the “oh gosh” level: “Is this really me observing all this misery?” That may sound unfair because the goals of the foundation are worthy and there is ample documentation that if traumatized people can put their feelings into words, illustrations, even photographs, catharsis may result. Second, although the stories of several abused and afflicted peoples are related here, sometimes quite powerfully, how can catharsis for the victim result if it is western artists who create the illustrations or even record the narratives of their misery?

The four booklets read together depict a world where the downtrodden have few options that can lift them beyond their oppressive environments. The first booklet traces the lives of thousands of refugees who have fled from Grozny, Chechnya to Ingushetia, the nearby city in Russia. There, they live in squalor and a refugee status that has undermined any possibility of family stability. Men in these conditions appear to live by their worst instincts. Women, usually left to take care of children, become possessive caregivers. One woman remarks that if “her daughters had stayed with her husband, they would not have been virgins for their wedding days.” Thus, refugee status brings out irreconcilable tensions within families, to say nothing of the authorities who want to control them.

The lengthy graphic narrative called “Chechen War, Chechen Women” not only chronicles the misery of the Russian/Chechnya war but describes a history of negative encounters between the two populations. The repetitions of history are particularly depressing in this sequence, as one is reminded of other global hotspots that have become little more than replications of earlier events—the endless nightmare of repression from encounters between one cultural or ethnic group and another.

A second booklet chronicles the stories of young (often pre-adolescent) boys conscripted into military action for the warring factions in Burma. In these camps, traumatized children are initiated into adulthood by the violent brutalities they observe around them. A second part of the Burma sequence describes the brothels on the Thailand/Burmese border where young girls—like the young boys kidnapped to become soldiers—are forced into prostitution and often early deaths from AIDS.

The focus on the abuse of women continues in the narrative closest to our own borders: Ciudad Juárez, in Mexico. Ostensibly a commentary on the disappearance of hundreds of young women in the city, the focus is primarily on one young woman named Claudia and her mother’s attempt to grapple with her disappearance. I found the reality of the story belabored, felt it would be much better served by mainstream journalism.

The final booklet utilizes the convention of an illustrated children’s storybook to narrate the sad account of a Malawian child’s awareness of his pregnant mother’s “wasting disease,” AIDS. Malawi’s a pretty sad country these days, not just because of AIDS but also because of extreme poverty.

I’d like to think that some good will come of Mia Kirshner’s project for the I Live Here Foundation, but I’d need to be more of an optimist than I am.

I Live Here
By Mia Kirshner, J. B. Mackinnon, Paul Shoebridges, and Michael Simons
Four mixed media pamphlets.
Pantheon, $29.95

CHARLES R. LARSON is Professor of Literature at American University in Washington, D.C.


More articles by:

Charles R. Larson is Emeritus Professor of Literature at American University, in Washington, D.C. Email = clarson@american.edu. Twitter @LarsonChuck.

September 20, 2018
Michael Hudson
Wasting the Lehman Crisis: What Was Not Saved Was the Economy
John Pilger
Hold the Front Page, the Reporters are Missing
Kenn Orphan
The Power of the Anthropocene
Paul Cox – Stan Cox
Puerto Rico’s Unnatural Disaster Rolls on Into Year Two
Rajan Menon
Yemen’s Descent Into Hell: a Saudi-American War of Terror
Russell Mokhiber
Nick Brana Says Dems Will Again Deny Sanders Presidential Nomination
Nicholas Levis
Three Lessons of Occupy Wall Street, With a Fair Dose of Memory
Steve Martinot
The Constitutionality of Homeless Encampments
Kevin Zeese - Margaret Flowers
The Aftershocks of the Economic Collapse Are Still Being Felt
Jesse Jackson
By Enforcing Climate Change Denial, Trump Puts Us All in Peril
George Wuerthner
Coyote Killing is Counter Productive
Mel Gurtov
On Dealing with China
Dean Baker
How to Reduce Corruption in Medicine: Remove the Money
September 19, 2018
Bruce E. Levine
When Bernie Sold Out His Hero, Anti-Authoritarians Paid
Lawrence Davidson
Political Fragmentation on the Homefront
George Ochenski
How’s That “Chinese Hoax” Treating You, Mr. President?
Cesar Chelala
The Afghan Morass
Chris Wright
Three Cheers for the Decline of the Middle Class
Howard Lisnoff
The Beat Goes On Against Protest in Saudi Arabia
Nomi Prins 
The Donald in Wonderland: Down the Financial Rabbit Hole With Trump
Jack Rasmus
On the 10th Anniversary of Lehman Brothers 2008: Can ‘IT’ Happen Again?
Richard Schuberth
Make Them Suffer Too
Geoff Beckman
Kavanaugh in Extremis
Jonathan Engel
Rather Than Mining in Irreplaceable Wilderness, Why Can’t We Mine Landfills?
Binoy Kampmark
Needled Strawberries: Food Terrorism Down Under
Michael McCaffrey
A Curious Case of Mysterious Attacks, Microwave Weapons and Media Manipulation
Elliot Sperber
Eating the Constitution
September 18, 2018
Conn Hallinan
Britain: the Anti-Semitism Debate
Tamara Pearson
Why Mexico’s Next President is No Friend of Migrants
Richard Moser
Both the Commune and Revolution
Nick Pemberton
Serena 15, Tennis Love
Binoy Kampmark
Inconvenient Realities: Climate Change and the South Pacific
Martin Billheimer
La Grand’Route: Waiting for the Bus
John Kendall Hawkins
Seymour Hersh: a Life of Adversarial Democracy at Work
Faisal Khan
Is Israel a Democracy?
John Feffer
The GOP Wants Trumpism…Without Trump
Kim Ives
The Roots of Haiti’s Movement for PetroCaribe Transparency
Dave Lindorff
We Already Have a Fake Billionaire President; Why Would We want a Real One Running in 2020?
Gerry Brown
Is China Springing Debt Traps or Throwing a Lifeline to Countries in Distress?
Pete Tucker
The Washington Post Really Wants to Stop Ben Jealous
Dean Baker
Getting It Wrong Again: Consumer Spending and the Great Recession
September 17, 2018
Melvin Goodman
What is to be Done?
Rob Urie
American Fascism
Patrick Cockburn
The Adults in the White House Trying to Save the US From Trump Are Just as Dangerous as He Is
Jeffrey St. Clair - Alexander Cockburn
The Long Fall of Bob Woodward: From Nixon’s Nemesis to Cheney’s Savior