home / subscribe / donate / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq
Exclusive in the CounterPunch Print Edition!
You Want to Deal With a Humanitarian Crisis, Mr Obama?
“Right now Israel, with full support from the U.S. is denying 1.5 million people in Gaza ALL the necessities of life.” Read Kathleen and Bill Christison’s searing emergency bulletin to Obama. “This is a U.S.-created, U.S.-supported disaster…Put meat on the bones of your talk about compassion…” Also in the new issue of our subscriber-only newsletter, Barbara Rose Johnston brings us a detailed report on the drive for justice in Guatemala after another catastrophe sponsored by the U.S. – the building of the Chixoy Dam. Finally, Alexander Cockburn sets out the record of assaults on freedom in the Bush years. Get your Legacy Edition today by subscribing online or calling 1-800-840-3683 Contributions to CounterPunch are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now! CounterPunch books and gear make great presents.
|
Today's Stories December 5 / 7, 2008 Alexander Cockburn Brian Cloughley Paul Craig Roberts Liaquat Ali Khan Farzana Versey Peter Lee Peter Morici Yinon Cohen / Johnny Barber Alan Farago Jeremy Scahill Mike Whitney Carl Finamore Marjorie Cohn Norm Kent Binoy Kampmark David Yearsley December 4, 2008 Ece Temelkuran Ralph Nader Harry Browne Eamonn Fingleton Conn Hallinan Mike Whitney Stewart J. Lawrence Paul Fitzgerald / Karyn Strickler Jennifer Matsui Website of the Day December 3, 2008 Andrew Cockburn Sheldon Rampton Robert Weissman Yifat Susskind William Blum Alan Singer David Macaray Martha Rosenberg Mats Svensson Website of the Day December 2, 2008 Jeremy Scahill Paul Craig Roberts Ayesha Ijaz Khan Sarah Anderson / William Blum John Ross Dave Lindorff Nicola Nasser Steve Conn Robert Bryce Website of the Day December 1, 2008 Patrick Cockburn Damien Millet / Vijay Prashad Deepak Tripathi Joshua Frank P. Sainath Alan Farago Binoy Kampmark Chris Genovali David Michael Green Stephen Martin Website of the Day November 28-30, 2008 Alexander Cockburn Mike Whitney Ted Honderich Tom Kerr Mike Ely David Yearsley Deepak Tripathi Sonja Karkar Ramzy Baroud Robert Weitzel Robert Roth Carlos Fierro David Macaray David Rosen James Cockcroft Stan Cox Steve Conn Stephen Martin Richard Rhames Kim Nicolini Lorenzo Wolff Poets' Basement November 27, 2008 Tariq Ali Steve Hendricks Ralph Nader John Walsh Dave Lindorff Christopher Brauchli Matthew Koehler Website of the Day
November 26, 2008 Michael Hudson Alan Farago Stanley Heller Kevin Zeese Steve Conn Ray McGovern Ron Jacobs Eric Walberg Martha Rosenberg Matt Siegfried Website of the Day
November 25, 2008 James Abourezk Ralph Nader Patrick Irelan John Ross Fred Gardner Dan LaBotz Tom Barry Norman Solomon Richard Morse Chris Strohm Website of the Day November 24, 2008 Mike Whitney Pam Martens Laray Polk David Ker Thomson Uri Avnery Joe Mowrey Ramzi Kysia Kevin Zeese Dave Lindorff David Macaray Howard Lisnoff Website of the Day November 21 / 23, 2008 Alexander Cockburn Michael Hudson Mike Whitney Barbara Rose Johnston / Serge Halimi Alan Farago Ralph Nader Saul Landau Robert Bryce Shannon May Binoy Kampmark Jack Ely Ramzy Baroud Missy Beattie Larry Portis James McEnteer Christopher Brauchli David Yearsley Adam Engel Ron Jacobs Lorenzo Wolff Poets' Basement Website of the Weekend November 20, 2008 P. Sainath Brian McKenna Paul Craig Roberts Andy Worthington Peter Lee Dr. Eyad al-Serraj Sen. Russ Feingold Lance Selfa Ray McGovern Benjamin G. Davis Tracy McLellan Website of the Day November 19, 2008 M. Shahid Alam Mario A. Murillo Martine Boulard Robin D. G. Kelley Behrooz Ghamari-Tabrizi Jonathan Cook Steve Conn George Wuerthner Michael Winship Stephen Martin Website of the Day November 18, 2008 Chellis Glendinning George C. Wilson Franklin Lamb Bill and Kathleen Christison Roger Burbach John Ross Wajahat Ali Damien Millet / Marc Gardner Eric Walberg Wendy Williams Website of the Day November 17, 2008 Michael Hudson Paul Craig Roberts Mike Whitney Steve Conn Andy Worthington Jonathan Cook Rannie Amiri David Macaray David Michael Green Charles Modiano Website of the Day November 14 / 16, 2008 Alexander Cockburn Jeffrey St. Clair Mike Whitney Sasan Fayazmanesh Moshe Adler Anthony DiMaggio Jean Bricmont Sheldon Rampton Douglas Valentine Joseph Nevins / Tom Barry Ron Jacobs Larry Portis Mary Lynn Cramer Obama's Brain Trust: Seems Like Old Times Sherry Wolf Peter Cervantes-Gautschi Jacob Hornberger Lance Selfa Benjamin Dangl Seth Sandronsky Russell Mokhiber Allan Stellar Kelly Overton Martha Rosenberg Richard Rhames David Yearsley Lorenzo Wolff Poets' Basement Website of the Weekend
November 13, 2008 Pam Martens Vijay Prashad Patrick Cockburn Jonathan Cook Ralph Nader Bill Quigley Lee Sustar Omar Barghouti Steve Conn Howard Lisnoff Jeff Cohen Website of the Day November 12, 2008 Johanna Berrigan Steve Conn Patrick Bond Bokar Ture / Alan Farago Dave Lindorff Karl Grossman David Macaray George Wuerthner Susie Day Website of the Day
|
Weekend Edition It Begins With IndividualsRelational ActivismBy NANCY STOHLMAN In September 2002 I, along with hundreds of Denver activists and other “subversives,” gathered in the Denver Police Department to claim our Denver Police Spy Files, the secret and now illegal dossiers that the DPD had been keeping on Denver activists. We were anarchists, Buddhists, ex-nuns, non-profit organizers, radical Marxists and Green party politicians, American Indian Movement leaders and transsexuals. But to the Denver Police, we were all the same. To them we were all “criminal extremists,” reduced to our lowest common denominator. We’ve seen how this mistaken unification has affected feminism. An important critique of feminism is that the experiences of a white, middle-class woman are likely to be very different from that of an aged homeless woman, or a Latina prostitute, or an immigrant woman. In many ways there is more separating these women than there is uniting them: economics, race, education, sexual identity, culture. Falsely homogenized on biology alone, their individual experiences are buried for the sake of a united front: Women. Like feminism, one of the problems of The Left is the assumption that we need to be unified in order to succeed. But the experiences of a liberal 60-year-old Christian woman working for a non-profit organization are much different from a 20-year-old anarchist starting an urban renewable community, or a Gulf War vet against the war, or a Marxist working for immigrant rights, or an 50-year old male American Indian movement leader, or rabbis working to stop the oppression of Palestine, or a Puerto Rican lesbian getting arrested at the School of the Americas. And not only are there a variety of issues but there are also a variety of tactics, ranging from education and advocacy to direct action and civil disobedience. But because of this need for “unity”, factions of The Left are constantly doing battle, trying to push their agendas and tactics to the forefront. As a result there is infighting, backstabbing, fracturing and burnout. Endless debates about which strategy is the most effective and which issue the most pressing. In short, a peace and justice movement without much internal peace or justice. Norma Alarcon, in talking about feminism, says that “The subject (and object) of knowledge is now a woman, but the inherited view of consciousness has not been questioned at all. As a result, some Anglo-American feminist subjects of consciousness have tended to become a parody of the masculine subject of consciousness.” The dominant society relies on concentrations of power and hierarchy. People squander lifetimes trying to climb power ladders. So while the function of The Left is to question and oppose these problems of the dominant societies, it still unconsciously functions through those same ideologies. Alpha personalities still dominate, often educated white males. Different groups form to work on identical issues because we don’t know how to deal with strong personalities, nor do we want to digest any criticism. We reward workaholism until people burn out and disappear. We speak disrespectfully of other groups, other issues, other tactics. But if activism is trying to eschew the dominant culture we first have to disentangle ourselves from the trappings of its ideology. We’ve become so good at critiquing our world that we’ve forgotten how to critique ourselves. And just as a common denominator of “women” makes it impossible to critique the relationships within feminism, “activism” masks the faulty relationships of the people within The Left. Relational activism begins with individuals. It begins with a commitment to full respect living, both for others as well as towards ourselves. It unmasks the cultural one-up/one-down mentality: right vs. wrong, power vs. powerless, and exposes how The Left has succumbed to the ideology of the dominant culture, always one-upping the other as too violent vs. not violent enough, too radical vs. not radical enough, too liberal vs. not liberal enough. The goal should be respectful “same as” relationships rather than stepping on one another in order to climb a ladder constructed by the very society that we want to transform. What does a nonviolent Democrat who believes in electoral politics have in common with an anarchist who believes in civil disobedience? Maybe not much. And this is the problem: as long as the success of The Left requires that these two people become unified, there will always be power struggles. We need to establish solidarity and the full respect of our differences without the requirement of unification in order to end the power struggles within the movement, to understand that activism is a machine whose parts work in tandem. Once we stop competing, we can start collaborating. The Dalai Lama says, “World peace begins with inner peace. World disarmament with inner disarmament.” And this is where we can win. The Left is human, with all its human shortcomings and strengths. And as humans, we have the ability to evolve. Nancy Stohlman is the co-editor of Live From Palestine (South End Press). She’s a former member of the International Solidarity Movement and the former organizer of the Colorado Campaign for Middle East Peace. She currently lives in Denver. You can reach her at nancystohlman2@hotmail.com. |
Now Available from CounterPunch Books! Waiting for
Lightning
|