home / subscribe / donate / about us / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events

 

Inside the New Print Edition of CounterPunch: News from Pentagon-Babylon

How a Tiny Alaskan Indian Tribe Got Billions in Pentagon Contracts by Jeffrey St. Clair; Dems and Dives by Alexander Cockburn; Spooky Grants: More on the CIA's Recruitment of Campus Professors by David Price. Remember these stories are available exclusively in the print edition of CounterPunch. CounterPunch Online is read by millions of viewers each month! But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation for the online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now!

Call Toll Free 1-800-840-3683
or write CounterPunch, PO BOX 228, Petrolia, CA 95558

Coming Soon from CounterPunch Books
Other Lands Have Dreams:
From Baghdad to Pekin Prison
by KATHY KELLY

Click Here to Order!

Today's Stories

April 5, 2005

Gary Leupp
Bombing the Malwayia Minaret

 

April 4, 2005

Kevin Zeese
Liberals and Neocons for a Draft

Paul Craig Roberts
American Rot: When Opposing Voices Do Not Oppose

Larry Birns / Sarah Schaffer
Bush's Arms Sales Hypocrisy

Karyn Strickler
Blood on Ice: Seal Pup Slaughter on the St. Lawrence

Joshua Frank
The Minuteman Project: Paramilitaries on the Border

Michael Dickinson
It's Too Late Now for John Paul II to Repent

Surendra R. Devkota
Ending the Deadlock in Nepal

Derrick O'Keefe
Haiti, Yesterday and Today: an Interview with Laura Flynn

Uri Avnery
Djinn in the Box

Website of the Day
Libby, Montana: America's Most Toxic Town?

 

April 2 / 3, 2005

Alexander Cockburn
Death, Depression and Prozac

Jeffrey St. Clair
Trippwired

Stan Goff
A Trojan Jackass for the Anti-War Movement

John Ross
How to Change the World Without Taking Power

Saul Landau
Guns, Vitamins and God

Robert Creeley
Goodbye

Mike Roselle
Riding Shotgun with Woody Harrelson

Joshua Frank
Dead Wrong Intelligence

Fred Gardner
The Obvious Green Issue

Greg Moses
Photo ID Movement as White Privilege

Fran Quigley
The Economics of Global Poverty: an Interview with Jeffrey Sachs

Kurt Nimmo
The Strange Allure of Paul Wolfowitz

Nicole Colson
Pentagon Greenlights Murder in Iraq

Chris Genovali
Killing Grizzlies for Fun

Alan Farago
Dirty Water and Land Speculators in the Florida Keys

Lawrence Reichard
The M-19 and the Siege of Bogota

Ben Tripp
Civilization and War

Avantika Regmi
Chaos in Nepal

Lee Sustar
Off the Script in Kyrgyzstan

Ron Jacobs
Death of a Revolutionary: Vermont Loses an Honest Man

Dave Lindorff
The Black Arrow: a Review

Poets' Basement
Smith-Ferri, Curtis, Louise, Engel and Albert

Website of the Day
O2 Collective: No Breathing Tube Required

 

 

April 1, 2005

Tom Barry
Michael Chertoff: Legal Storm Trooper

Rahul Mahajan
WMD Commission: Yet Another Intelligence Failure

Charlie Cray / Jim Vallette
Dancing with Wolfowitz

Dave Lindorff
News Media Anguish Over Schiavo's Death

Zeynep Toufe
The Terri Schiavo Success Story

Suzan Mazur
Pension Funds and the Price of Oil

Michael Dickinson
Shut Your Mouth or Go to Prison!

Stan Cox
Iraq Reconstruction Funds Invested on Wall Street

Ra Ravishankar
Et Tu, George?

Daniel Wolff
Patti Scialfa's Conversation with America

 

March 31, 2005

Sharon Smith
Leftwing Apologists for the Occupation

Ron Jacobs
Rounding Out Iraq's History

Tariq Ali
British Elections: Punish the Warmongers

Michael Dickinson
Cartoon Capers: Turkey's War on Political Cartoonists

Kanak Mani Dixit
The Struggle for Nepal's Future

Mitchell Zimmerman
The Bizarre Legal Philosophy of Justice Janice Rogers Brown

Xuan-Trang Ho
Guatemala and CAFTA: Return to the Bad Old Days?

Dave Zirin
Pay the Damn Players!

Joe Bageant
In Praise of Holy Madness

Jeff Halper
The End of a Viable Palestinian State

Website of the Day
Free Nepal

 

 

March 30, 2005

Gary Leupp
Curing Those People of Their Hatred: Condi's Pitch for a "Different Kind" of Middle East

Ralph Nader / Kevin Zeese
Report on Iraq Intelligence Failure: No One to Blame

Chase Madar
Wolfowitz's Career Move: From Failed Warrior to Humanitarian Banker

Toni Solo
Bush in Latin America

Jackie Corr
Blessed are the Rich: George Bush's Montana Visit

Ahmad Faruqui
Much Ado About F-16s

Mike Roselle
Refuting Dave Foreman: Days of Whine and Posers

Jude Wanniski
America's Gunboat Diplomacy

Francis A. Boyle
Why You Should Boo Illinois

Jeffrey St. Clair
Downwinders be Damned

Website of the Day
Help! Nicaraguan Workers Are Being Poisoned

 

March 29, 2005

Ralph Nader
Is the End of the Iraq War / Occupation Near?

Gary Leupp
Terri Schiavo's Death and the Birth of an "Elected" Iraqi Government

Sonia Cardenas
A Pandora's Box of Abuses: the Geneva Trap

Stew Albert
Take Back the Life Force!

Mark Weisbrot
Owning Up to the "Ownership Society"

Dave Lindorff
China's Report on Human Rights in US is No Cariacture

Carl G. Estabrook
The Subversive Commandments

 

 

March 28, 2005

Jeremy Scahill
Sgrena Sets the Record Straight: "There was No Checkpoint; No Self-Defense"

Sonali Kolhatkar
Forgetting Afghanistan...Again

Sasha Kramer
The UN's Betrayal of Haiti

Kevin Zeese
Don't Just Blame the Democrats

Tom Stephens
Sacred Law; Traditional Wisdom: Environmental Justice and Indigenous Peoples

Dr. Teresa Whitehurst
We're Walking Into a Trap

Newton Garver
Reflections on Bolivia

Paul Craig Roberts
A Bail Out Draft for a Cakewalk War?

Website of the Day
Stumped? Ask a Librarian, 24/7

 

 

March 26 / 27, 2005

Gary Leupp
God's Imperialists

Peter Linebaugh
To Render, to Impeach, to Habeas Corpus

Marc Robert
A European Student's Experience at Columbia University

Laura Carlsen
The Threesome in Crawford: Summit as Traveling Stage Show

Saul Landau / Puja Patel
The Price of Privatized "Development"

Dave Foreman
Nature's Crisis

Fred Gardner
Will San Francisco Pander to the Prohibitionists?

Jennifer Matsui
Terri Schiavo: America's Most Desperate Housewife?

Dave Lindorff
Provoking Iran

Dharma Adhikari
The Reversal of Democracy in Nepal

Joshua Frank
The Howard Dean Doctrine

Patrick Barr
Have Box Cutter, Will Travel: a True Story

Christopher Brauchli
F-16s to Pakistan

Ramzy Baroud
Israel's Record is "Not Reassuring"

Jackie Corr
When the Gov. of Montana Declared Martial Law in Butte

Ben Tripp
Off with Your Appurtenances!

Dr. Susan Block
Break a Taboo for Easter: Springtime for Sex and God

Mickey Z.
How Three Unrelated Books Relate

Justin Taylor
Beware of "Beware of God"

Richard Joseph
Cochabamba!: the Water War in Bolivia

Poets' Basement
Martin, Smith, Ford, Bortz and Albert

 

 

March 25, 2005

Scott Richard Lyons
Horror and Hope at Red Lake Nation

Yoshie Furuhashi
No Troops; No Wars

Pat Williams
How a Town Got Poisoned: Libby, MT and the Labor Movement

Mark Engler
Remembering Archbishop Romero: 25 Years After His Assassination

Rahul Mahajan
Culture of Life or Culture of Living Death?

Lance Selfa
Can the Democrats be Moved to the Left?

Ralph Nader
Corporate Cyborg: Cal Nurses Take on Schwarzenegger

John R. Llewellyn
Why Utah's Prosecutors are Soft on Polygamy: a Former Sheriff Speaks Out

Jo Guldi
Beyond Belief: Holy Week in France

 

March 24, 2005

Joshua Frank
The Selling (Out) of the Antiwar Movement

Talli Nauman
Vicente and George: Security by Any Other Name Would Smell Sweeter

Martin Espada
Why I Refused Coke's Money: a Poet Speaks Out About Colombia

Dave Lindorff
Another Social Security Snow Job

Elaine Cassel
When Fools Rush In: the Legal Implications of the Schiavo Case

Jack McCarthy
Jeb Bush's Mob: Snatch, Grab, Insert Tube

Jack Random
Juxtaposition: Terri Schiavo and the Red Lake Massacre

Barbara Ferguson
Wolfowitz Dating Muslim Woman and World Bank Employee

Suzan Mazur
Peak Oil: Debate or Vendetta?

Dorreen Yellow Bird
Suffering Red Lake Nation Endures the Worst of Days

Andrew Wimmer and Mark Chmiel
Torture: Old Hat or Open Wound?

 


March 23, 2005

Patrick Bond
A New War? On Wolfowitz's World Bank

Mike Whitney
Railroading Moussaoui

Becky White
Why I Hung from a Bridge to Defend the Wild Forests of the Siskiyou Mountains

Michael Donnelly
Dissecting the Changeling: How the AuCoin Express Was Really Derailed

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Remembering Ram Manohar Lohia: the Che of Non-Violence

Ashley Smith
Bush is What Hypocrisy Looks Like

David Swanson
The More Bush Talks, the Less Popular Privatization Becomes

Derrick O'Keefe
Enter Bono, Stage Right

Paul A. Moore
The Fire This Time: the Bush Bros. Racist Crackdown in Florida

Dalton Walker
My Reservation Will Never Be the Same

Patrick Cockburn
The US Frees Iraqi Kidnappers to Become Spies

 

 

March 22, 2005

William Blum
Anti-Empire Report: Democracy--or is it the US Military--on the March

Jim Vallette
Cheney's Oil Change at the World Bank

Greg Moses
A Palm Sunday Chat with Sis Levin

John Farley
Bush's Culture of Life: Let the Insurance Companies Pull the Plug When the Sick Cost Too Much

Ron Jacobs
Halt the Anniversary Rallies and Stop the Damn War

M. Junaid Alam
How the Democratic Party Fosters Conservatism

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
An Immoral and Illegal War: Destroying Iraq Isn't Enough for Them

Dave Lindorff
"Saving" Schiavo; Killing the News

James Petras
Fateful Quadrangle: Cuba and Venezuela Face Off Against the US and Colombia

 

 

March 21, 2005

John Walsh
In the Bars on the Road to Fayettevile: War Support Paper Thin

Werther
The Legacy of George Kennan, Chief Architect of the Cold War

Mike Stark
Where is the "Culture of Life" in Maryland? Time is Running Out for Vernon Evans

David Swanson
Feeding Tubes for the Third World: Put the Hungry into Comas, Then Feed Them!

James T. Phillips
Happy Meals: Behind the Grill at a Baltimore Diner

Mike Ferner
Serving, Refusing, Impeaching

Robert Jensen
The World Waits for an Answer

Paul Craig Roberts
A Threat Greater Than Terrorism

Stew Albert
Vegetable Nation

Website of the Day
American Press Blotter: Jacko, Terry and Steroids vs. the World

 

 

March 19, 2005

Alexander Cockburn
Three-Card Monte and the One-Party State

Tom Reeves
Exposing the Coming Draft: a Draft by Any Other Name is Still Wrong

Saul Landau
The Grandchildren of Roy Cohn: the Politics of the Repressed

Alan Maass
Making Bankruptcy a Life Sentence

Ron Jacobs
Submit or Else: the Nuclear Demon that Won't Go Awayy

David Green
The Holocaust Industry Comes to the University of Illinois

John Blair
Hey, Dick! I'm Still Free: a Blow for Freedom of Speech in Indiana

Steve Greenfield
The Decline of the Green Party: the Numbers are In

Ben Tripp
Nature isn't Real

Mike Roselle
A History of White People in the Conservation Movement

Joshua Frank
Hope in Red State America: Lessons from the Big Sky Country

Mark Weisbrot
The World Bank: a Bigger Problem Than Wolfowitz

Dave Lindorff
Congress on Steroids

Sarah Schaffer
Lula's Nukes: Bush Bullies Iran, Ignores Brazil's Nuclear Ambitions

Warren Hastings
Why the Queen Should Chop Off Tony Blair's Head for Treason

Poets' Basement
Lodge, Albert. Landau, Engel, Davies, Capaccio

 

March 18, 2005

Dave Zirin
The Congressional Urine Testers: Baseball's Theater of the Absurd

Richard Thieme
The Church Committee Candidate: I was a Victim of the KGB

John Walsh
Misdirecting the Anti-War Movement

David Swanson
Hunger Striking for a Living Wage at Georgetown

Ben Terrall
In the Spirit of Rachel Corrie: Confronting Caterpillar in San Leandro

David Boyle
Just Say "No" to Harvard

Dorreen Yellow Bird
Coping with Teen Suicide on the Standing Rock Reservation

Mokhiber / Weissman
Global Bully Goes to Guatemala

Greg Moses
They Don't Shoot Donkeys...Do They?

Website of the Day
800 Protests: Find One Near You

 

March 17, 2005

Christopher Brauchli
Rendered Unto Caesar: the Etymology of Torture

Bill Quigley
The St. Patrick's Four and the Resistance to the War in Iraq

Brian Cloughley
Bush's Herds: Willing to Kick Anyone in the Face

Gary Bass / Adam Hughes
Inside the Bush Budget: Rhetoric vs. Reality

Dave Lindorff
The Incredible Shrinking Coalition

Jude Wanniski
Wolfowitz at the World Bank: a Perfect Fit

Alexander Billet
Irish Republicanism at the Crossroads

John Ross
Wal-Mart Invades Mexico

Website of the Day
Campus Resistance

 

March 16, 2005

Ralph Nader
Filling the Congressional Cop-Out Gap: an Idea for Local Peace Activists

William Cook
Resurrecting the Neo-Con Failures

Kevin Zeese
Two Years of Occupation: Both US and Iraq are Worse Off

Jackie Corr
Why is Dick Cheney Laughing? The New Tax Cut Patriotism

Alan Maass
Bush's Class War Budget

David R. Kolker
Jailed Without Charges in Haiti

Cindy Ellen Hill
Speculative Policing in Northern Ireland

Paul Craig Roberts
America's Has-Been Economy

 

 

March 15, 2005

Gary Leupp
The Plan is Still on Track

Dave Lindorff
Free John Walker Lindh!

Greg Moses
The Fix-It Guys and Their Electoral Filters

Hadas Their / Katrina Yeaw
Military Recruiters Target Campus Activists

Alison Weir
Uprising on the Anniversary of Rachel Corrie's Death

Matt Koehler
A Line in the Ancient Forest: 50 Arrested in Blockade to Save the Siskiyous

Evelyn Pringle
Labeling Kids Mentally Ill for Profit

Harry Browne
War and Peace in Ireland

 

 

March 14, 2005

Ralph Nader
Restarting the Anti-War Movement

David Miller
Ministry of Defence in the Control Booth: Did the BBC Broadcast Fake News Reports?

Stan Cox
Look Deeper, Mr. Moyers

Mike Roselle
Why Women Should Take Over the Environmental Movement

David Swanson
Nursing Against the Odds: the Workers' View

Simona Sharoni
To End the War, Listen to Soldiers

Dave Lindorff
Corporate Surveillance

Dorreen Yellow Bird
Incidents at Standing Rock: Suicide on the Reservation

Tom Barry
John Bolton's Baggage

Website of the Day
Spinwatch

 

 

March 12 / 13, 2005

David H. Price
The CIA's Campus Spies

Noam Chomsky
The Toothpaste Election

Laura Carlsen
Women's Rights Eroding in Latin America

Stan Goff
On Revolutionary Optimism: the View from Cumberland Co, NC

Valentina Nicoli
The Game of Role-Playing and the Ambush of Giuliana Sgrena

Michael Leonardi
Head Shot: Lifting the Veil on the Sgrena / Calipari Incident

Saul Landau / Sarah Anderson
Blood Money and the Riggs Bank: Pinochet's Bank Finally Pays Up

Joe Bageant
It Ain't Easy Being White

Manuel García, Jr.
The Question of American Guilt

Greg Moses
Electoral Lessons from Cuyahoga and Harris Counties

James J. Brittain
Run, Fight or Die in Colombia

Ben Tripp
Communist Watch

Joshua Frank
A Red State Paradox: Montana on the Cusp

Fred Gardner
Pesticides Made Her Sick; Pot Got Her Well

Walter Brasch
Bush's Horse Killers

Ramzy Baroud
Reining in Syria on Behalf of Israel

Christopher Brauchli
Going All the Way for Usurers

Michael Donnelly
The Humiliation of Les "Timber Toad" AuCoin

Ron Jacobs
ZAP Comics: Still Kicking US Culture in the Ass

Richard Oxman
The Eternal Reciprocity of Tears

Poets' Basement
Smith-Ferri, Davies, Ford, Louise and Albert

 

March 11, 2005

Jerry Fresia
Targeting Giuliana

Ron Jacobs
Making Lebensraum in the Middle East for Tel Aviv's Fears & Washington's Dollars

Dave Lindorff
America's Magical Kingdom

William James Martin
Ben Gurion and the Origin of the "Pushing into the Sea" Myth

Muqtedar Khan
Modi's Operandi: American Business and Genocide Linked Again

Kathryn Ledebur
Bolivia on the Brink

Mike Whitney
Saddam's Capture: Just Another Bush Lie?

Dave Zirin
Neo-McCarthyism Slugs Baseball

Website of the Day
William Rivers Pitt, Another Hack for the Occupation

 

 

March 10, 2005

Paul Craig Roberts
So Much for the New Bush Economy

John Marc Leas, Colleen McLaughlin and Ashley Smith
Vermont Vs. the War

Larry Birns
The Pathological John Bolton

Michael Donnelly
The Re-Reinvention of an Oregon Timber Beast

Luis Gomez
In Bolivia, Reality Changes Once Again

Jackie Corr
Whatever Happened to the Social Security Trust Fund?

Uri Avnery
Bush's Guru: Natan Sharansky

Website of the Day
Red Alert in the Siskiyous!

 

 

March 9, 2005

Jeffrey St. Clair
Dirty Harry's Fear of Flying: Making Love, War and Profits at Boeing

Ward Churchill
Who's the Terrorist?

Robert Fisk
Another Species of Cedar: a Half Million Lebanese March for Syria

Bernice Powell Jackson
No Justice for America's Nuclear Guinea Pigs in the Marshall Islands

Mickey Z.
The Revolutionary of Potential Art

Dave Zirin
NHL Says: "Bring On the Scabs!"

Michael Donnelly
Standing Up to Ecocide in Oregon

James Reiss
Stopping by Words in Favor of Privatizing Social Security

Vijay Prashad
Get Modi: a State Terrorist Visits Florida

 

March 8, 2005

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush's Syrian Delusion

Robert Fisk
Lebanon's Nightmare

Kurt Nimmo
War is Peace: John Bolton to the UN

Suzan Mazur
Time for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission on Polygamy?

Evelyn Pringle
Neil Bush and Crest: Another Profiteering Scheme

Giuliana Sgrena
My Truth: "The Americans Don't Want You to Return"

Elaine Cassel
The Appalling Case of Abu Ali

 

 

March 7, 2005

Dave Zirin
Bloodlust in Annapolis: Gov. Ehrlich Wants to Kill Vernon Lee Evans

Brian Cloughley
More War Crimes

John Chuckman
The Creature Walks Among Us

Mike Whitney
Jose Padilla and the 10 Commandments

Mark Weisbrot
Haiti's Torment: Why Are US Human Rights Groups Silent?

Fred Gardner
The Cannabinoid Messenger

Richard Neville
The Italian Job

Uri Avnery
The Next Crusades

 

 

March 5 / 6, 2005

Alexander Cockburn
Arnold vs. the Nurses

Gary Leupp
What's Happening in Lebanon: an Interview with Fadi Agha, Advisor to President Lahoud

Ron Jacobs
Lies Military Recruiters Tell

Tom Reeves
Haiti: One Year After the Coup

Jenna Orkin
Memories of Kawaggi, Saudi Arabia

Tom Barry
Negroponte: Intel Czar or Policy Hack?

Joshua Frank
The Trials of Max Baucus

Moshe Adler
When Pfizer Came to New London: Corporate Giveways vs. Eminent Domain

Jane Stillwater
My Jury Questionnaire: "Do You Agree that a Corporation is a Person?"

Omar Barghouti / Jacqueline Sfeir
Double Standards on S. Africa and Israel: an Open Letter to UNESCO

Christopher Brauchli
Target: Al Jazeera

John Pilger
The Fall of Saigon: 30 Years Later

Raúl Zibechi
Colombia: Militarism and Social Movements

David Krieger
Saving the Nuclear Nonproliferation Agreement

Three Takes on Nepal

Surendra R. Devkota
Another Blow to the King of Nepal

Bhishma Karki
Nepal in Twilight

Joseph Pietri
Murder at the Palace

Ben Tripp
The Good Old Days

Poets' Basement
Hassen, Chief Running Late, Wuest, Albert and Collins

Website of the Weekend
O'Shaughnessy's: All About Medical Pot

 

 

March 4, 2005

Frederick Hudson
Caught in a Cage

 

March 3, 2005

Pat Williams
"Social Security Protects the Young as Much as the Old"

Brian Cloughley
Headlines, Beliefs and Deceptions

Dave Lindorff
Why Do the Democrats Pamper Greenspan?

Amira Hass
Oslo All Over Again

Greg Moses
In Oscar Texas: One Down, One to Go?

Lynne Landes
Exit Poll Madness

Nelson P. Valdés
Rapture Takes Leftists

John Ross
Mexico's Fox Schemes to Jail Front-Running Leftist

 

March 2, 2005

Saul Landau / Farrah Hassen
The "Noble Liars" Attack Syria

Mike Roselle
The State of Oregon vs. Mike Roselle: Criminalizing Environmental Dissent

M. Junaid Alam
Columbia University and the New Anti-Semitism

Suzan Mazur
Inside the Polygamy Cults of Southern Utah

Jackson Thoreau
Texas Congressman Calls for "Nuking Syria"

Michael Donnelly
No Love for Teresa Heinz; John Edwards Gets a Pass

Jeffrey St. Clair
Uncle Bucky Makes a Killing

Website of the Day
The Ghosts of Karl Marx & Ed Abbey

 

 

March 1, 2005

Scott Richard Lyons
Million Dollar Bigotry

David Lindorff
Stealing Workers' Pensions

Patrick Cockburn / David Enders
Bloodbath in Iraq

Ron Jacobs
The Last Poets Recalled

Tanya Garcia
USA Next: the Industry Front Group to Privatize Social Security

Joseph Pietri
The Drug Trail Ends in Kathmandu: Golden Tar Heroin and the Black Prince

Kona Lowell
Woody: Broken in Vietnam

Paul Craig Roberts
The Coming End of the American Superpower

Website of the Day
Petition: No US Intervention in Iran

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Hot Stories

Alexander Cockburn
Behold, the Head of a Neo-Con!

Subcomandante Marcos
The Death Train of the WTO

Norman Finkelstein
Hitchens as Model Apostate

Steve Niva
Israel's Assassination Policy: the Trigger for Suicide Bombings?

Dardagan, Slobodo and Williams
CounterPunch Exclusive:
20,000 Wounded Iraqi Civilians

Steve J.B.
Prison Bitch

Sheldon Rampton and John Stauber
True Lies: the Use of Propaganda in the Iraq War

Wendell Berry
Small Destructions Add Up

CounterPunch Wire
WMD: Who Said What When

Cindy Corrie
A Mother's Day Talk: the Daughter I Can't Hear From

Gore Vidal
The Erosion of the American Dream

Francis Boyle
Impeach Bush: A Draft Resolution

Click Here for More Stories.

 

 

Subscribe Online

 

April 5, 2005

US Economic Decline and the Rise of China

Riding the Dragon, Soaring on the Eagle

By DAN SMITH

While they prate of economic laws, men and women are starving. We must lay hold of the fact that economic laws are not made by nature. They are made by human beings.

Franklin D. Roosevelt

Everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but not their own facts.

Daniel Patrick Moynihan

Once upon a time, creditors exacted "a pound of flesh" from those who, having borrowed money at high interest rates, found themselves unable to repay loans on time and in full. John Perkins, author of Confessions of an Economic Hit Man (EHM), appearing on PBS television's NOW on March 4, 2005, described a modern twist in this vicious circle at the level of nation-states. Since World War II, the United States has deliberately manipulated the economic and political life of developing countries to create a new global imperium based on massive indebtedness as the basis for exacting many pounds of flesh. Posing as a friendly expert, the EHM advises countries to contract with large U.S. companies to build massive projects financed by loans from international financial organizations, justifying the projects as critical for improving the lives of ordinary citizens. But the loans are so large and the interest rates so high that the money cannot be repaid, and common people's lives get more, not less, desperate. Opposition by individual elected officials in victimized countries can trigger "accidents" (assassinations), and collective rejection or default may trigger military action. According to Perkins, the price for self-preservation, both personal and national, is to fall in behind U.S. "leadership."

 

Economic Overstretch

But this U.S. empire, built on enthralling debtor nations, may itself be in danger from economic overextension. While economists may opine learnedly about the significance (if any) of the U.S. federal debt for fiscal and monetary policy, many non-economist internationalists and ordinary citizens are convinced that the United States is increasingly vulnerable to the pressures and priorities of creditors who see the current administration as a heedless bull-in-a-china-shop recklessly threatening to destroy agreements and institutions that have helped stabilize international relations for several decades.

At the risk of statistical numbing, it might be instructive to sample a few U.S. economic facts as documented by Congress and the Treasury Department:

* Between January 2001 and July 2004, the portion of the U.S. debt privately held by foreigners rose from 30% to 42%.

* Between September 2003 and September 2004, foreigners increased their holdings by $400 billion, from $1.46 trillion to $1.86 trillion-financing virtually the entire $422 billion budget deficit for fiscal year 2004.

* U.S. Treasury Department statistics through July 2004 reveal that five of the seven top foreign holders of U.S. obligations are Asian, with Japan ($696 billion) and China ($167 billion) in first and second place, respectively. (The other three in Asia, ranked five, six, and seven, are South Korea at $62 billion, Taiwan at $58 billion, and Hong Kong at $50 billion.)

* Despite an overall increase in the value of foreign holdings for all of calendar year 2004, December saw a sharp monthly decline in foreign purchases of Treasury bonds and notes. Foreign Central Bank acquisitions nose-dived by two-thirds (from $21 billion to $7 billion) while private foreign purchases plummeted by nearly 75% (from $32.8 billion to $8.4 billion).

* Japanese non-Central Bank holdings dropped $3.1 billion (from $714.9 to $711.8 billion) from November to December 2004. South Korea's portion registered a slight decrease. In contrast, the Chinese increased their total holdings by $2.7 billion (from $191.1 billion to $193.8 billion).

* In late February 2005, South Korea's Central Bank revealed its intention to "diversify" by straying from the dollar to other currencies-undoubtedly the Euro, which has strengthened over the last few years.

These economic realities are noteworthy, because excessive debt can act as a reverse "nuclear deterrent" for a large debtor. That is, a debtor's ability to initiate or avoid action on the global stage is constrained (less "elbow room"), because those who "own" the debt may have priorities that differ from those of the debtor nation, and the creditors may decide to use their economic position to advance their preferred policies or to thwart those of the debtor. When this impasse goes "critical" in the form of "vital national interests," the fallback position is either selective or general violence in an effort to regain-or at a minimum maintain-the debtor nation's empire.


Legitimacy Crisis

Economic woes in the form of a weak currency, ballooning debt, and unsustainably large trade deficits are not the only indicators of cracks in the empire's edifice. Another in a series of international polls-this one in December 2004-looked at the role of the United States and China in the world. Nearly 23,000 individuals in 22 countries in Asia (6), Europe (8), North and South America (6), the Middle East (1), and Africa (1) were interviewed.

* In 14 countries, China is seen as a positive influence on world events by a plurality or majority-with the average across all countries standing at 48%. In contrast, the United States is viewed positively in only six countries and negatively in 15, with the averages being 38% and 4%, respectively.

* Among its six regional neighbors, approval for China ranges from 70% in the Philippines to South Korea's 49%, with only Japan lagging at 22%. Significantly, of all of China's neighbors, only Japan (at 35%) registered less than majority support for a more economically powerful China.

* Regarding military power, citizens in 17 of the 22 nations said a stronger China would not be a positive development-with the average negative response at 59%. Nonetheless, a clear majority in India (56%) viewed a stronger military role for China as a positive development. Negative responses from the remaining regional countries ranged from 79% in Australia to 46% in the Philippines. Equally interesting in light of the European Union's (EU)now-postponed plan to lift its embargo on arms sales to China, is that clear majorities in all five EU countries felt a militarily stronger China would be a negative development. Only Turkey, which has been trying for years to begin the process for EU membership, polled below 50% negative response to a more militarized China.

Even those who dismiss "street" polls as mere venting of popular passions or reflections of government propaganda can find little solace in the reality of China's growing influence in Asia.

China's Good Neighbor Policy

The numerous regional agreements between China and its neighbors indicate that Beijing has succeeded in ameliorating the fears and suspicions of most countries. This is most apparent in China's relationship with the 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), both mainland and island states.

* In November 2002, China and ASEAN concluded the Framework on Economic Cooperation, which, among other provisions, calls for a free-trade zone between China and the original six ASEAN states: Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore, and Thailand.

* ASEAN and China initialed a "Strategic Partnership for Peace and Security" in October 2003, with China also acceding to the terms of ASEAN's "Treaty of Amity and Commerce."

* November 2004 saw two important additional steps. One was an agreement to resolve trade disputes, and the second affirmed the intent of all parties to resolve quarrels concerning territory and jurisdiction in the South China Sea without "resorting to the threat or use of force."

China has also been shoring up its north and northwestern fronts. The 1996 Shanghai Five (China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan) agreement recognized China's drive for reunification (to fully incorporate Macao, Hong Kong, Tibet, and Taiwan), paved the way toward resolution of remaining international border disputes among the five, initiated a demilitarizing of common borders, and affirmed the principle of state sovereignty and noninterference in the internal affairs of each country. With the accession of Uzbekistan in 2001, the renamed Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) turned to regional economic arrangements and anti-terrorism concerns. With the declared intention of opposing "terrorism, extremism, and separatism," the SCO provides all six member countries a multinational platform for resisting U.S. calls for political liberalization and greater human rights.

Interestingly, India and Pakistan have both signaled an interest in joining the SCO, a bid that current members seem hesitant to approve. Of the six SCO nations, China would have the most to gain from such an expansion, for it would frustrate, to some degree, U.S. attempts to erect a "containment ring" around China. For its part, Beijing is countering these U.S. moves with more active diplomacy in what many might consider U.S. "home turf."

* On October 10, 2002, with all of the former Soviet Central Asian republics enrolled in the North Atlantic Treaty Organization's (NATO) Partnership for Peace, China formally requested the opening of a "strategic dialogue" with NATO. (In NATO's June 2004 Istanbul summit, the alliance the alliance signaled a potentially closer relationship by declaring that Central Asia and the Caucasus were "strategically important regions.")

* After years of effort and despite heavy U.S. pressure on the EU to maintain the ban, China seemed on the brink of persuading the European Union to lift the arms embargo imposed after the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989. But with enactment of the anti-secession law codifying Beijing's threat to employ force should Taiwan take overt steps toward or declare independence, the EU decided to delay lifting the embargo for at least six months.

* For its part, China had said it would not have tried to buy "expensive" and "obsolete" European arms, but U.S. analysts worry that China might get technology such as the EU's Galileo navigation satellite. Tellingly, Australia-the main regional "Western" country and a steadfast U.S. ally-never objected to the lifting of the EU embargo. Canberra wants more information on the EU arms trade "code of conduct" and asks to be notified of any sales by EU countries. (Australia lifted its own embargo in 1992 and is now negotiating terms for providing uranium ore to China's nuclear power industry.) Similarly, Israel and Russia, both of which have a history of military sales to China and imposed no post-Tiananmen embargos, never registered objections despite the sophisticated sales competition that the EU would represent.

* China's first-ever deployment of uniformed personnel on a UN peacekeeping mission took place in 2004, when Beijing sent 1,000 riot police to Haiti.

* International Business Machine Corp. has sold its personal computer division to the Chinese firm Lenovo Group Ltd., in which the Chinese government has a stake. The sale's finalization is subject to approval by Washington, which was finally given with some restrictions on access by non-U.S. personnel to collocated but unrelated high-tech projects.

* In testimony before the House Armed Services Committee on March 9, 2005, the head of the U.S. Southern Command noted that Chinese defense officials conducted 20 visits to Latin America and the Caribbean (prompting nine reciprocal visits to Beijing). Several of the visits were to the 11 countries whose U.S. military aid was stopped, because their governments refused to sign agreements that would exempt U.S. personnel from the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court.

 

North Korea and Taiwan

But economics and world image are not the only areas of concern for Washington. There are also the seemingly intractable issues of North Korea and Taiwan, both of which involve the United States as a central protagonist.

North Korea's nuclear weapons-anywhere from two to 15, depending on which U.S. intelligence agency is tallying-are not just a U.S. concern. But although Beijing does not want to see either North or South Korea (or an eventually reunited Korea) acquire a nuclear arsenal, it is not as beleaguered by the possibility as is Washington. In fact, Chinese officials have publicly questioned Washington's appraisal of Pyongyang's self-declared status as a nuclear weapons state.

Regarding the North Korean "problem," China finds itself uniquely positioned as the only country genuinely able to mediate and facilitate discussions. But as the history of the "six-party talks" illustrates, Chinese envoys have been sorely tested just to keep the deliberations going. For example, on February 10, 2005, North Korea announced it was leaving the talks, which had not been held since August 2004 because of U.S. demands that the North completely dismantle its nuclear program as a precondition for more assistance. After a four-day visit by a senior Chinese government official, the North's leader, Kim Jong Il, was said to be willing to resume the six-party discussions, if Washington showed "trustworthy sincerity." Just what counts as "sincere" remains undefined, but Pyongyang's past demands include written assurance that Washington does not seek regime change, guaranteed aid (including fuel), and conclusion of a peace treaty officially ending the Korean War.

U.S. military options are severely restricted by the ongoing war in Iraq, intelligence gaps regarding the location and vulnerability of North Korea's nuclear facilities, and the massive destruction that South Korea (especially Seoul) would sustain in either a preemptive or retaliatory military strike by the North. Nonetheless, rhetoric from the Bush administration aimed both at Kim Jong Il personally and at North Korea as a political entity-e.g., rogue state and "outpost of tyranny"-seems designed to keep the atmosphere roiling and to postpone the next meeting of the six parties indefinitely.

Given Washington's approach to negotiations, Chinese leaders may soon interpret the Bush administration's endgame as keeping China's border with North Korea under persistent threat of large-scale migration, should Pyongyang suffer economic meltdown or go to war against the South. This would dovetail with Beijing's perception that many in Washington view China as the emergent great-power competitor that the United States will have to confront early in the 21st century. CIA Director Porter Goss was quite explicit on this theme when he stated that "Beijing's military modernization and military buildup is tilting the balance of power in the Taiwan Strait." Yet of the four modernizations that China is pursuing, military modernization is the lowest priority.

Tensions in the Taiwan Strait

That said, China does not shirk from the question of Taiwan and military force. With neither Beijing nor Washington blinking, a series of intertwining events over the last 13 months has perceptibly raised tensions in the Taiwan Strait.

* In the run-up to the presidential election in March 2004, Taiwan's President Chen Shui-bian promised to rewrite the island's Constitution and free it from the "fiction" of being labeled part of China. He also proposed to seek approval of a "process" for independence via a referendum-sidestepping the Constitution-and even placed referenda to carry out the process on the March ballot. Chen was narrowly re-elected; the referenda were not approved. Under U.S. pressure to tone down his rhetoric, Chen then backpedaled on independence in his May 20 inaugural address.

* In July 2004, China, which had also castigated Chen during the Taiwan presidential race, conducted extensive military training in the Taiwan Strait while the U.S. exercise "Operation Summer Pulse 04" in the Pacific-a larger drill than usual-was under way.

* In the run-up to the December 2004 Taiwanese legislative elections, Chen again promised to move ahead with a 2006 referendum on independence specifying a 2008 implementation date, if his party won the December poll. His party lost, but the fact that Chen had reopened the independence question was enough to spur the mainland Chinese to introduce an "anti-secessionist" law at their National People's Congress.

* Beijing steadfastly insists that Taiwan and its status are internal concerns of the Chinese people, who need no "assistance" from other countries. The February 20, 2005 joint declaration by the Japanese foreign minister and the U.S. defense secretary that the state of affairs in the Taiwan Strait is a "common strategic objective" was an attack on the unified sovereignty of China, which both the United States and Japan have acceded to under the "one China" policy.

* In addition to annual State Department funding of the American Institute of Taiwan-transparently an unofficial embassy-Washington reportedly plans to send military officers to Taiwan as official representatives of the Pentagon.

* For years, many in Congress have advocated UN membership for Taiwan, though this status is granted only to legitimate national governments. On February 17, 2005, five members of the House of Representatives introduced legislation demanding that the Bush administration restore full and official diplomatic relations with Taiwan. Such a move would embolden Chen Shui-bian, who so far has been dissuaded from declaring Taiwan's independence both by the better judgment of the Taiwanese people and by Beijing's insistence on the island's peaceful reunification with the rest of China.

* Washington is trying to force Taiwan to accept and pay for $18 billion in new "defensive" weapons first authorized in April 2001. The adoption of the anti-secessionist law by the mainland's National People's Congress has energized debate in Taiwan's legislature over this U.S. aid package.

Beijing reportedly believes that one aim of the Bush administration is to turn China and Japan against each other. But China is now Japan's number one trading partner, and China has opened its doors to Japanese investments. Japan also recognizes China's role in facilitating the six-party talks with North Korea over the latter's purported nuclear weapons and long-range missile programs.

At the same time, Japan's expanding cooperation with the United States regarding ship-borne missile defense suggests that Tokyo's concerns over North Korean missiles have broadened to include the 700-800 missiles on China's mainland across from Taiwan. Moreover, the withdrawal of 12,500 U.S. troops from Korea, the repositioning of the remaining forces away from the Demilitarized Zone, statements by the U.S. Pacific Command that the troops left in Korea could be used regionally, and the twin possibilities that the combined UN command in Korea will be dissolved while the United States reconstitutes a corps headquarters in Japan all suggest a fundamental reorientation of Washington's attention in Asia away from the Korean peninsula. This policy shift is reminiscent of the perception drawn from Secretary of State Dean Acheson's January 1950 speech that Korea (and Taiwan) lay outside U.S. defense interests.

Although such maneuvering will not tempt Beijing to challenge Washington militarily, China's growing economic and diplomatic presence on the world scene is engendering greater confidence among Chinese leaders. For example, U.S. criticism of China's human rights record was uncharacteristically reciprocated by a spokesperson for China's governing Cabinet who specifically cited accounts of prisoner abuse by U.S. military and civilian personnel at Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo Bay, and other prisons in Iraq and Afghanistan.

In the foreseeable future, China's economic position vis-à-vis the United States and its role in the North Korean nuclear talks remains key to U.S.-China relations. On the economic front, because China's rapid growth has been fueled by a large surplus of exports over imports in trade with the United States, Beijing is not expected to "pull the plug" on U.S. trade short of looming and inevitable armed conflict resulting from a clear Taiwanese declaration of de jure independence. Beijing would like to regain political control of Taiwan without a fight, and to that end China will continue to enmesh the island in a web of economic relations that Taipei will increasingly be loathe to sacrifice.

Like all presidents ever since Richard Nixon "opened" China, George Bush has chosen, after initially hesitating, to try to ride the Chinese dragon--but with spurs on his boots. Having managed to climb on, he cannot get off without the risk of being thrown. For its part, China has decided to soar on the eagle to the sky's limit. Beijing believes that if it can hitch a ride while the eagle economically exhausts itself, China can at last preempt U.S. influence in Asia.

As the old song says, "dragons live forever."

Col. Daniel Smith, a West Point graduate and Vietnam veteran, is Senior Fellow on Military Affairs at the Friends Committee on National Legislation, a Quaker lobby in the public interest and a commentator for Foreign Policy in Focus. He can be reached at: dan@fcnl.org