home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq

 

What You're Missing in Our Subscriber-only CounterPunch Newsletter

A Just Settlement for the Middle East

Our new CounterPunch newsletter, just out, offers Michael Neumann's plan for a just settlement in the Middle East. Manuel Garcia concludes his widely applauded primer on the laws of physics and the myths of conspiracists by explainging the not-so-mysterious collapse of WTC 7. But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation towards the cost of this online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now

Get CounterPunch By Email for Only $35 a Year

Today's Stories

November 25 / 26, 2006

Gabriel Kolko
Factors in Our Colossal Mess

Saul Landau
Republic of the Repressed

William Blum
New Congress, Same Quagmire

Ralph Nader
The Trouble with the Bubble

Fred Gardner
The War on Us: Another 1.9 Million Victims

Daniel Wolff
Return to District 8, New Orleans

M. Shahid Alam
Pitting the West Against Islam

Aseem Shrivastava
India on 20 Cents a Day

Seth Sandronsky
The Washington Post's War on Social Security

Michele Naar-Obed
A Letter to the Judge Who Sentenced My Husband to Federal Prison for Protesting Nuclear Weapons

Website of the Weekend
The Black Agenda

 

November 24, 2006

Charles Glass
How to Let Lebanon Live

Gideon Levy
A Prayer in Paradise

Jonathan Cook
Syria as Fallguy

Ron Jacobs
Build a Fire on Main Street: Stop the War, Now!

Brian McKenna
Native Resurgence Spurs Hope: Giving Thanks to America's Indians

Kim Ives
The UN Fails Haiti, Again

 

November 23, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
The Democrats and the Slaughterhouse


November 22, 2006

Kathleen Christison
The Massacre at Beit Hanoun

Paul Craig Roberts
Bush's Lone Victory: Defeating the Bill of Rights

Mike Roselle
Green Muscle on Election Day: Now is the Time for Boldness

Dave Lindorff
The First Task of the New Congress

Greg Moses
Up From Chiapas: Giving Thanks to Women's Revolution

Dave Zirin
Born Under Punches: the Pimping of Mike Tyson

Nadia Martinez
Dealing with Ortega

Sherwood Ross
Why the World Needs Trade Unions Now More Than Ever

David Kalbfeisch
I Am A Navy Veteran Against Wars

Gilad Atzmon
Palestinian Solidarity in a Time of Massacres

Website of the Day
Sorry, Charlie: No Draft

 

November 21, 2006

Robert Bryce
The Ongoing Myth of Energy Independence

John V. Walsh
Spoilers of the World Unite!

Luis Hernandez Navarro
Lessons from the Teachers of Oaxaca

Kevin Zeese
An Interview with Michael Isikoff on Iraq

Peter Rost, MD
Rules of the Game: How Big Corporations Avoid Paying Their Taxes

Evelyn Pringle
Drug Your Fetus: How Big Pharma Hits on Pregnant Women

Roger Morris
Reason in an Age of Folly (and Felony)

Don Monkerud
Here Come the Democrats ... So?

Website of the Day
The Grind

 

November 20, 2006

David H. Price
American Anthropologists Stand Up Against Torture and the Occupation of Iraq

Col. Dan Smith
Usurpation of Power

Katherine Hughes
Compassion on Trial in War on Terror: Muslim Charities and the Case of Dr. Rafil Dhafir

Dave Himmelstein
Ziodammerung: Netanyahu and the End Times

Robert Jensen
Opportunities Lost

Joe Mowrey
America's Progressive Nightmare: Here Come the Armani Democrats

Mike Whitney
Housing Bubble Smack Down: Alan Greenspan, Homewrecker

Carl N. McDaniel
Living Within Limits

Robert Fisk
Shia Walk

Ramzy Baroud
Killing Hope in Beit Hanoun

Website of the Day
Iraq: the Hidden Story

 

November 18 / 19, 2006
Weekend Edition

Alexander Cockburn
Top Dems to Voters: "Shut Up! We've Got a War to Run!"

Ralph Nader
The Hole in Bush's Brain: How Karl Rove Lost the Senate

Barucha Calamity Peller
Who Will Live on in the Oaxaca Uprising?

John Ross
Halliburton Wrecks Mexico

Dave Lindorff
The Albatross: Why the Democrats Should Cut Loose Joe Lieberman

Fred Gardner
The Adverse Effects of Marijuana: California Medical Survey

Ron Jacobs
Back in the Aether Again: Thomas Pynchon's Stunning Return

Larry Portis
The Songs of Basilio Martin Patino: Father of the New Spanish Cinema

Frida Berrigan
The Weapons Bonanza: a Perfect Storm of Profit

Wes Enzinna
Ghosts of Dictatorships Past: the School of the America's and Memory in Latin America

Elizabeth Schulte
The Fall of Donald Rumsfeld: Architect of a Disaster

Peter Rost, MD
The Credit Card Trap

Martha Rosenberg
We're Drinking What? Milk, rBST and Monsanto's Rats

Seth Sandronsky
University Unity: California's Professors and Students Unite

Missy Beattie
Explore This!

Adam Engel
Data Days

Jeffrey St. Clair
Playlist: What I'm Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Newberry and Curtis

Website of the Weekend
A Modest Proposal for the Art World

 

November 17, 2006

Greg Grandin
The Road from Serfdom: Milton Friedman and the Economics of Empire

Joseph Massad
Pinochet in Palestine: Fateh's Unholy Alliance

Kevin Zeese
George McGovern's Return to Capitol Hill: "A Down-to-Earth Disengagement Plan"

Gideon Levy
After the Rain of Death

Bill Quigley
WMDs Protected!: Blood-Pouring Anti-Nuke Clowns Sent to Prison

David Swanson
Last Chance for the Democrats?: a Tale of Two Conyers

Sherry Wolf
Gay Rights: When Will the US Catch Up with Africa?

Jerry Beisler
What James Webb Knows

Website of the Day
Thanks for the False Memories!

 

November 16, 2006

Kathy Kelly
Sources of Violence

Col. Douglas MacGregor
Was It Only Rumsfeld?

Norman Solomon
Operation Last Resort: the Media Offensive to Prolong the Iraq War

Nikki Thanos
From Oaxaca to Portland

Cindy Sheehan
Impeachment Proceedings

Lena Khalaf Tuffaha
Jimmy Carter and the "A" Word: Will the Democrats Listen to Carter on Palestine?

Gloria La Riva
Where is the Justice? Anti-Castro Terrorist Gets Only 4 Years

Pat Williams
How the Democrats Won the West

Kerry Joyce
From Rummy to Rahmmy: Bob Novak's New Source

CP News Service
Wal-Mart Charged with Selling Non-Organic Food as "Organic"

David Letterman
Top 10 Slogans for Wal-Mart Wine

James Ridgeway
Did Robert Gates' Planning Help Bring Black Hawk Down?

Website of the Day
A Conversation with West Point Grads Against the War

 

November 15, 2006

Jennifer Loewenstein
Alice in Erez: the Gaza Crossing

David Rosen
Rev. Ted Haggard and the Eclipse of Evangelical Fury

Ashley Smith
A Socialist in the Senate?

Landau / Hassen
Talking Tough on Iraq Isn't Courageous

Walden Bello
Iraq After November 7: New Challenges for the AntiWar Movement

Sibel Edmonds
The Highjacking of a Nation

Austin / Bernstein
Why Bill Cosby is Wrong to Link Black Culture to Economic Decline

Yitzhak Laor
This Merchandise, Security

James Rothenberg
Unimpeachable: a Brief Argument Why

Gail Dines
"Borat": It's a Guy Thing

Website of the Day
Kakistocracy


November 14, 2006

Werther
Beltway Bromo-Seltzer: a Sneak Peak at the Baker Report

Ray McGovern
Benching Scowcroft

John Walsh
Korea, Vietnam and Iraq Syndrome: Alive, Well and Gaining Strength

David MacMichael
Gates to the Pentagon

William S. Lind
Lose a War, Lose an Election

Sharon Smith
Democrats, Born to Compromise

Laura Carlsen
Oaxaca Fights Back

Ron Jacobs
The Perishing Republic

Peter Rost, MD
Whistleblowers: Who Are They?

Carol Norris
Post-Campaign Ad Stress Disorder?

Website of the Day
A Map of the US Nuclear Arsenal

 

 

November 13, 2006

Kathleen and Bill Christison
Screw the Palestinians, Full Steam Ahead

Bill Quigley
Robin Hood in Reverse: the Corporate Looting of the Gulf Coast

Paul Craig Roberts
The Democrats and Civil Liberties: Will They Turn a Blind Eye?

Uri Avnery
Call It What It Is: a Massacre!

Joe DeRaymond
The Strange Return of Daniel Ortega

Norman Finkelstein
Jimmy Carter's Roadmap

Col. Dan Smith
The Pentagon's Revolving Gates: Out with the Old, In with the Old

Shepherd Bliss
After the Party

Dave Lindorff
What Vote-Theft Conspiracy?

Missy Beattie
For Better / For Worse: Will Laura Stay the Course?

Trenticosta / Fleming
Vindication for the Angola 3

 

Weekend Edition
November 11 / 12, 2006

John Walsh
Rahm's Losers

Barucha Calamity Peller
Oaxaca at Any Cost

Al Krebs
Be Careful What You Wish For

Niall Meehan
Ireland's Freedom Struggle and the Foster School of Historical Falsification

Conn Hallinan
The Ills of War: Shafting the Vets

Patrick Cockburn
"We Worry About Staying Alive, Not the U.S. Elections"

Gary Leupp
Democrats Can Be NeoCons, Too

P. Sainath
India High and Low: the Anatomy of a Tiger

Nikolas Kozloff
The Return of Tom Lantos: Beware Venezuela, Here Come the Democratic Hawks

Lawrence R. Velvel
Throwing Rumsfeld Under the Bus

Fred Gardner
Marijuana, the Anti-Drug

Ralph Nader
Taking on the Boss: Claybrook vs. the Chamber

Ben Terrall / John Miller
East Timor: 15 Years After the Massacre

Mike Whitney
Cheney in a Box

Joshua Frank
Post-Electoral Deliriums

Mukul Dube
The Death Penalty Case of Mohd. Afzal

Jason Hribal
Jesse: Eulogy for a Working Dog

Daniel Wolff
The Unseen Springsteen

Michael Donnelly
Red Rock Blues: the Moab Folk Festival

Lord Montague
A Dissenting Note on the Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917

Poets' Basement
Davies, Louise, Buknatski and Orloski

 

November 10, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
Lame Duck

Marjorie Cohn
The War Crimes Case Against Rumsfeld

Jorge Mariscal
What Veterans See

Gregory Elich
The Trial of Saddam: Who Will Pass Judgment on the Judges?

Joshua Frank
Blue Dog Group: Bye-Bye Coke, Hello Pepsi

Megan Boler
The Joke is On Us: How "Borat" Lowers the Bar of Political Satire

Ramzy Baroud
The Treacherous Road to Oslo Begins Here

Farzana Versey
An Iraqi in India

Roberto Rodriguez
A Thumpin' or a Whippin'?

Cartoon of the Day
Splat!

 

November 9, 2006

Jennifer Loewenstein
How Gaza Offends Us All

Patrick Cockburn
War of the Snipers

Paul Craig Roberts
Will Democrats Become Part of the Problem?

Manuel Garcia, Jr.
The Roots of Corruption

Mike Whitney
Bush's Chernobyl Economy

Alan Maass
The Repudiation of One-Party Rule

Robert Jensen
Blood on the Tracks: the Elections and the Coming Train Wreck

Nicola Nasser
Saddam's Trial in Context

John Chuckman
As I Lay Dying: Watching the US Elections from Canada

Jamal Juma
Between Resistance and Deception in Palestine

Felice Pace
Can the Klamath be Restored?

Website of the Day
The Robert Gates Files

 

November 8, 2006

Alexander Cockburn / Jeffrey St. Clair
Count Your Blessings: NeoCons and NeoLibs Take Big Hit as Voters Say No to Bush, War and Free Trade

Lawrence E. Walsh
Robert Gates and Iran/Contra: Lies, Cover Ups and Slanted Intelligence

Bruce K. Gagnon
What's Next for the Peace Movement?: Confront the Democrats, Now!

Neve Gordon
Anti-Semitism? Mr. Dershowitz, You Just Don't Like What I Say

Dave Lindorff
Election Post-Mortem: What's Next?

Arthur Neslen
Another Tragic Day in Palestine

Joshua Frank
An Election Hangover: Thank God It's Over

James Goodman
The Corporate Food System is Broken

Charles Sullivan
Voting in the Absence of Choice

David Swanson
Subpoena Envy: The Dems Have the Power, But Will They Use It?

Missy Beattie
The Electorate Speaks and Barney Barks!

Dr. Susan Block
American Voters Say, "Bush Sucks!"

Website of the Day
Stealing Olive Groves from Palestinians

 

November 7, 2006

Michael Neumann
Cut and Run from Iraq: Sooner Rather Than Later

Paul Wolf
Saddam Must Die: A Pre-Ordained Verdict

Nikolas Kozloff
In Nicaragua, a Chavez Wave?

Eliza Ernshire
The Women of Beit Hanoun

William S. Lind
The Smile on Saddam's Face: He's Tan, Rested and Ready

Mike Ferner
Pick a Number: Greater Than 47,615

Felice Pace
Pumping the Klamath Dry

Chris Genovali
The Problem with PBDEs: Why Canada's Proposed Ban Won't Protect People or Wildlife

Gilad Atzmon
Watching Borat

Dick J. Reavis
Going to Class War with the Proletariat We Got ...

Elizabeth Weill-Greenberg
Lives (and Votes) Lost: the Ordeal of Larry Peterson

Website of the Day
Magic Sam: a Sure Cure for the Election Day Blues

Question of the Day
Is Bush Gay?

 

November 6, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
The Message of Campaign 2006

Norman Solomon
Saddam's Unindicted Co-Conspirator: Donald Rumsfeld

Robert Fisk
A Guilty Verdict on America, as Well

Marjorie Cohn
The Banana Election: From Hanging Chads to Hanging Saddam

Paul Craig Roberts
The Goose and the Gander: Is Bush Next?

Nikolas Kozloff
Election Eve Jitters: the Chavez Factor

Newton Garver
The Progress in Bolivia: Morales' Stunning Victory Over Big Oil

Mike Whitney
Bush's Carnival of Blood

Jesse Hagopian
From the Black Panthers to the Green Party: an Interview with Aaron Dixon

Dr. Peter Rost, MD
The Genocide Election: When a Life Saving Industry Cheats, People Die

Website of the Day
Robert Pollin vs. Rick Wolff: Is Pomo Marxism Marxism?

 

November 4 / 5, 2006

Dave Zirin
Political Players: Where Athletes Give Their Money

Patrick Cockburn
When Does Incompetence Become a Crime?

Sanho Tree
War Timing and Opportunism

Ralph Nader
Failure Across All Fronts

Lee Sustar
The Obama Myth

Dr. Shepherd Bliss
Torture Memories

Adam Elkus
Babies and Banks: Celebrity Colonialism in Africa

Seth Sandronsky
Is Another Recession Looming?

Fred Gardner
10 Years of Medical Pot in California: Dr. Mikuriya's Observations

Joshua Sperber
How the US Lost Latin America

Evelyn Pringle
Ohio Redux: Mr. Blackwell and the Henhouse

Mitchel Cohen
The Left and the Environment: Notes on the Ecological Dimension

Missy Beattie
The Medium is the Massage

Michael Dickinson
Watching the Guards: a Prison Diary

John Holt
The Silk Road to Ruin

Dr. Susan Block
The Beastly Bombing

Poets' Basement
LaMorticella, Engel, Orloski and Davies


November 3, 2006

Laura Carlsen
Day of the Dead in Oaxaca

Stephan Said
Honoring Bradley Will

John Stauber
"Victory in Iraq:" The PR Machine Behind Bush's Favorite Slogan

Mike Whitney
Baghdad is Surrounded

Joshua Frank
DNC Deja Vu

Victoria Furio
More Than Timetables

Tammara~85,441
They Say He is Coming Home

Stuart Croswaithe
Beatings and Sugar Plums: New Labor's War on the Kurds

Missy Beattie
Bush Shock

Website of the Day
Howlin' Wolf


November 2, 2006

Winslow T. Wheeler
The US Body Count in Iraq: an Analysis of Who is Dying and How

Paul Craig Roberts
Evil is as Evil Does

Dave Lindorff
Kerry Out: the Joke's Still on Us

Uri Avnery
The Lovable Man? Lieberman and the Decline of Israeli Democracy

Jeff Birkenstein
Smearing Harold Ford in Black Face

John Ross
Slave Labor in Private Prisons

Zoltan Grossman
Recharging the Anti-War Movement

Eveyln Pringle
The SEC's Probe of Halliburton: Is Cheney Being Fitted for a Striped Jumpsuit?

Christopher Brauchli
Drug Profits and PACs: Why Big Pharma Pushes the GOP

 

November 1, 2006

Alan Dershowitz v. Bruce Jackson
On Torture

Brian Tokar
Running on Hype: the Real Scoop on Biofuels

Fred Leonhardt
Democrats, Sex Crimes and the Press: the Goldschmidt Affair

Richard W. Behan
Triumph of the Petropublicans: Bush's Other Civil War

Brenda Norrell
Indigenous Opposition to the Border Wall

Charles Sullivan
Spoils of Corruption: Who Will Stand Up When America Goes Wrong?

Ron Jacobs
Hell is Rising in Oaxaca: interview with a Oaxacan Rebel

Mike Knapp
Green Stench in Minnesota: the Commissioner and the Hog Lot

Moshe Adler
The Temptations of a Union Boss: the Case of Brian McLaughlin

Walden Bello
Chain Gang Economics

Lee Ballinger
The Collapse of Hip Capitalism: How Tower Records Committed Suicide

Joshua Frank
Party in a Cage: Snake Oil and the Midterm Elections

Carl Gelderloos
Cheerleading the Massacre in Oaxaca: an Open Letter to the Washington Post

Peter Rost, MD
Panic in Big Pharma

Saul Landau
Bush's Anti-Terrorism Record: Don't Look Too Close

Website of the Day
The Meatrix


October 31, 2006

William S. Lind
The Third and Final Act: Iran

Stephen S. Pearcy
Dem Candidate's Wife Urges Cindy Sheehan Not to Protest Iraq War

Uri Avnery
Who's Afraid of an Iranian Bomb?

Michael Colby
Corporations Win Again!: Bush Opens National Parks to Bio-Prospecting

Sunsara Taylor
A No-Win Election for Women

Ben Beachy
Targeting Nicaraguans' Stomachs: 11th Hour Election Meddling by the US

Edward Humes
Nine Words: America's Disservice to Veterans

Roger Burbach
The Meaning of Lula's Victory in Brazil

Subcomandante Marcos
A Communique from the EZLN on Oaxaca

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
Funny Business in the Booth: Vote for James H. 'Jim'

Sharon Smith
Those Damned Democrats

Website of the Day
Parks Not for Sale

 

October 30, 2006

Robert Fisk
Dirty Bombs Over Lebanon: Did Israel Use Uranium Weapons?

Bruce Jackson
Normalizing Torture

Norman Solomon
I Was Wrong About Thomas Friedman, the World's Wealthiest Pundit

Lance Selfa
Liberal Doormats: Tread on Us

Ali Khan
The Veil and the British Male Elite

Lee Sustar
European Islamophobia: Fanning the Flames of Hate

Robert Jensen
The Death of Empathy

Akiva Eldar
Lieberman: Making Haider Look Good

Tim Montague
The Natural Step to Eco-Villages

Brian M. Downing
Evil in the Valley: Civilian Massacres, From Vietnam to Iraq

Website of the Day
Alien Impeachment


October 27 / 29, 2006
Weekend Edition

Jeffrey St. Clair
Hogwash: Fecal Factories in the Heartland

Maher Arar
The Horrors of Extraordinary Rendition: a Personal Account

David Rosen
Perversions of Power: Mark Foley and the Bush Administration

Gregory Elich
"A Bursting Boiler at Russia's Doorstep:" Why Bush is Seeking Confrontation with N. Korea

Tom Barry
Fear and Loathing in the North: an Apartheid Fence in America?

Jeff Taylor
Democrats By Default?

Dave Lindorff
Why Nancy Pelosi is Wrong

Ron Jacobs
The General Who Called Out the Devil: the Politics of Hugo Chavez

Maurus Chino
Hauba Hanu: Oppression Affects All People

Christopher Brauchli
Veiled Threats: the Global War on Fashion

Sherwood Ross
The Wages of Whistleblowing: Why Bunny Greenhouse Sits in a Corner

Rev. William Alberts
In Search of a Real Inter-Religious Dialogue on War and Justice

Aseem Shrivastava
Pushing India Toward a "Dollar Democracy"

Saul Landau / Farrah Hassen
Bush's Mea Culpa Speech, First Draft

Russ Fine / Dee Fine
Of Peters and Principles: Learning About Sex and Hypocrisy from the GOP

Seth Sandronsky
Social Security: the Distortions of Sebastian Mallaby

Michael Carmichael
Rogue President: Midterm Meltdown

Joe Allen
The Legacy of Gillo Pontecorvo: a Maker of Revolutionary Films

David Vest
Playlist: What I'm Listening to This Week

Poets' Basement
Landau, Engel and Buknatski

Website of the Weekend
Safely Home

 

October 26, 2006

Ismael Hossein-zadeh
Islamic Fascism?: Inflammatory Ironies

Carlos Zorrilla
The Police Raid on My House: Trumped Up Charges and Collusion Between a Mining Company and the Government of Ecuador

Paul Craig Roberts
The Crimes of Greed vs. the Crimes of Government: If Enron's Skilling Gets 24 Years in Prison, How Many Should Bush and Cheney Get?

Mike Whitney
The Charnel House of Baghdad

Lily Hughes
A Cruel and Unusual Reality: Inside the Texas Death House

Jennifer Matsui
Madonna's African Safari: The Great White Baby Hunter

Tim Matson
How to Save Vermont

Stephen Fleischman
Like a Soldier: Benchmarks, Timelines and Lies

Missy Beattie
The Blood of October: Are We Sure Barney Still Supports This War?

Patrick Cockburn
From "Mission Accomplished" to "Mission Impossible" in Iraq

Website of the Day
Open Letter to The Nation

 

October 25, 2006

Michael Donnelly
Ethnicity and Baseball

John Stanton
The Vindication of Sibel Edmonds

John Ross
Upheaval from the Bottom

Conn Hallinan
Hunting Hugo: When It's About Oil Nothing is Off the Table--Not Even Assassination

Robert Jensen
Academic Freedom on the Rocks

Johnny Barber
Drinking Tea with Hizbullah

Bruce K. Gagnon
Space Cowboy: Bush's War on Heaven

Daniel McGowan
Elie Wiesel for Israeli President?

James J. Brittain
Uribe's Failure to Learn from Colombia's Past

Peter Harley
Afghanistan in 3-D

Jonathan Cook
Israel's Minister of Strategic Threats

Shepherd Bliss
The Bioneers and the New York Times

Website of the Day
The Price of Staying the Course

 

October 24, 2006

John Walsh
The Book of Rahm: Emanuel's War Plan for Democrats

M. Shahid Alam
Not All Terrorists Are Muslim: the Latest Falsehood from the Advocates of Civilizational War

Dr. Trudy Bond
The Silence at Home, as America Eats Her Young

Michael Phillips
The Story of My Kidnapping in Nablus: "I Never Feared for My Life"

Dave Lindorff
Truth and Consequences on Iraq: Bush's Latest Cut-and-Paste War Plan

David Phinney
A US Fortress Rises in Baghdad: Asian Labor Trafficking Used to Build World's Largest Embassy

Laura Carlsen
Food Insecurity: the World Needs Its Small Farmers

Pierre Tristam
The American Way of Gore

Marguerite Rose Jimenez
"About That Trip to Cuba:" When the FBI Came Calling

Website of the Day
Tampon Terrorists

 

October 23, 2006

Saree Makdisi
Israel's Cluster Bomb War: "What We Did Was Insane and Monstrous"

Joshua Frank
The Antiwar Movement and Independent Politics: an Interview with Cindy Sheehan

Fred Gardner
What Have California Doctors Learned About Cannabis?

Ralph Nader
The End of Habeas Corpus and the Belligerent Despot-in-Chief

Ron Jacobs
Bush's Clark Clifford: James Baker Wants a Kinder, Gentler War

Norman Solomon
Punditry Without Consequences: Channeling Thomas Friedman

Richard Manning
Outside the Market: We Need and Owe Rural People

Neil Kitson
Canadians in Afghanistan: Bloody, Unbowed, Stoned?

William MacDougall
The Socialist, the Columnist, His Wife and the Prostitute

Gilad Atzmon
Surviving the Board of Deputies

Werther
The Evening of Empire

Website of the Day
Different Drummer: Internet Coffeehouse Movement

 

October 20 / 22, 2006

Alexander Cockburn
The Myth of Microloans

Gary Leupp
How the US Declared War on North Korea

Brian Cloughley
What Are They Dying For?

Dave Zirin
Pat Tillman's Brother Breaks His Silence

William Blum
Don't Look Back: Who Said Clinton Didn't Kill Anybody?

Christopher Brauchli
The Cronies' War

Winslow Wheeler
The Mad Logic of Pentagon Spending: As Costs Rise, Readiness Declines

Michael Donnelly
GOP Death Slide: Is the Party Really Over?

Fred Gardner
Corporate Drugs Useless Against Alzheimer's

Susie Day
How to Stay Out of Gitmo

Lucinda Marshall
Behind Closed Doors: the Invisibility of Domestic Violence

Fred Wilcox
The Second Palestinian Intifada: History of a Struggle for Survival

Alan Maass
Standing Up Against Racism at Columbia: a Wake Up Call to the Passive Left

Lee Sustar
A Bipartisan Border Wall: New Phases in the Crackdown on Immigrants

Ariadna Theokopoulos
Shame on You, Dr. Warf: Hail the Epidemiologist in Chief

Missy Beattie
Surges: the Dow and the Death Count

CP News Wire
Bush's Paraguay Land Grab: Hideout or Water Raid?

CP News Services
Sexually Repressed Republicans: Robert Bork, Riveted

Poets' Basement
Davies, Engel, Buknatski and Orloski

Website of the Weekend
Scenes from Oaxaca

 

October 19, 2006

Elaine Cassel
The Bush Administration's Assault on Defense Lawyers

Col. Dan Smith
Breaking Up That Old Gang of Mine: Cracks in the Bush / Blair Axis

Manuel Garcia, Jr.
North Korea's Nuclear Test: a Q & A

Josh Gryniewicz
Wal-Mart Tightens the Squeeze on Workers

Amira Hass
What is 20 Tons of Explosives?

Eric Holt-Gimenez
Poison and Famine in the Fields: How the Agri-Food Industry's Deadly Cycle Feeds Immigration

Jesse Hagopian
Arrested Democracy: On Trying to Ignore Aaron Dixon

Sam Husseini
How Third Parties Can Solve the "Spoiler" Problem and Win Elections

John Weisheit
A Gathering of Water Buffaloes: Feds Celebrate Death of the Colorado River

CP News Service
A Plea to U2 From Africa's Children: Stop Bono Before He Kills Again

Website of the Day
George W. Bush: Hollywood Producer

Art Gallery of the Day
Botero's Abu Ghraib Paintings in Manhattan

 

October 18, 2006

Joshua Frank
Cindy Sheehan's Lesser Evilism: Democrats or Bust?

Dr. Curran Warf, MD
Slandering Sound Science: Bush's Attack on the Lancet Iraq War Death Study

Saul Landau
Bush's Foley: Will the Dems Blow It?

Tom Barry
The Politics of Fear

Bruce Jackson
Thundersnow: a Report from Buffalo

Dave Lindorff
Loveless Among the Ruins: Even Repubs Flee Bush's Failed Middle East Policy

Frederico Fuentes
When Cochabamba Said "Enough": Bolivia's Blow to Neoliberalism

Michael Simmons
Greetings from Echo Park: an Open Letter to Rolling Stone's Jann Wenner

Daryll E. Ray
The Root Problems in American Agriculture

Kate Doyle
The Dead of Tlatelolco

Website of the Day
The Lynne Stewart Defense Committee

 


October 17, 2006

Michael Neumann
Hit and Run: Guerrilla Reviewing

Manuel Garcia, Jr.
Nuclear Test, Political Flare: Interpreting the Physics and Politics of N. Korea's Nuclear Test

Stephen S. Pearcy
The Interrogation of Julia Wilson: Secret Service Grills 14 Year-Old Artist

Sharon Smith
Afghanistan Reconsidered: The Taliban Aren't Gone, Women Haven't Been Liberated

Al Krebs
The Corporate Assault on Zoning

David Underhill
Politicus Interruptus: Come Back, Jo Bonner

Daniel Wolff
NY's Iraq Veterans Against the War Needs Your Help ... Now

James Brooks
Desirable Duds: Israeli / US Cluster Bombs Litter Lebanon

Website of the Day
Stop Torture Now

 

October 16, 2006

Gary Leupp
North Korea as a Religious State

Patrick Cockburn
General Mutinies Against Blair

David Wilson
Where Have All the Doctors Gone?: the Collapse of Iraq's Health Care Services

Robert Fisk
Confronting Turkey's Armenian Genocide

Robert Jensen
Racism and Cheap Thrills at U. of Texas Law School

Ingmar Lee / Krista Roessingh
An Appeal for S. India's Wild Elephants

Mike Whitney
America's Other War Party

Jake Whitney
The Courageous Dr. Rost

Sanho Tree
Sugar Daddy Politics: Was Foley Blackmailed to Secure His Vote on CAFTA?

Website of the Day
Best War Ever

 


October 14/15, 2006
Weekend Edition

Uri Avnery
Gaza as Laboratory: the Great Experiment

John Walsh
How Rahm Emmanuel Has Rigged a Pro-War Congress

Jean Bricmont
A Fable About Palestine

Jennifer Van Bergen
Bush's Military Commissions Act and the Future of America

Ralph Nader
Wilted Yankees: the Fruits of Checkbook Baseball

Floyd Rudmin
The Logic of Proliferation: How Bush's Belligerence Prompted N. Korea to Pursue Nuclear Weapons

Mark Weisbrot
Correcting the Facts on US/Venezuela Relations

Laura Carlsen
Building a Future in the Mixteca

Hani Shukrallah
A Stroll Through the Cairo Mall: Shopping as Cultural Pursuit

Dr. Susan Block
The Spent Milk of Human Foley

John Chuckman
North Korea's Bomb: Still 1,126 Nuke Tests Behind the US

Lucinda Marshall
Is Betty Ugly?: the Profits of Denigration

Don Monkerud
The Case Against Depleted Uranium

Missy Comley Beattie
What Bush Means By Tolerable Violence in Iraq

Ron Jacobs
Shouting "No One is Illegal" in a Crowded Theater

Website of the Weekend
Ratfink Raunchfest

 

October 13, 2006

Jorge Mariscal
PowerPoint Racism: How Military Recruiters Pitch to Latinos

Stephen Philion
The Myth of the Spat Upon Vets: an Interview with Jerry Lembcke

John Blair
Strip Mining Wildlife Preserves: Black Beauty's Filthy Lucre

Col. Dan Smith
Oil, Atoms and War

Alastair Crooke / Mark Perry
How Hezbollah Defeated Israel: Part Two, Winning the Ground War

Stephen Fleischman
Journalism Then and Now

Charles Perroud
The Death Penalty's Invisible Victims

Anne E. Brodsky
Return to Afghanistan: Where the Rhetoric Doesn't Match the Reality

Website of the Day
Underwater Nuke Test

 

October 12, 2006

Jonathan Cook
Israel's Plan for a Military Strike on Iran

Norman Solomon
The Pundit Path to Death in Iraq

M. Shahid Alam
On Colonialism and Colleagues

Paul Craig Roberts
Can We Call It Genocide Now?

Meredith Schafer / Chris Kutalik
Is a General Transportation Strike Looming for 2008? Can Labor Seize the Moment?

Carl Gelderloos
Images of Occupation: Teaching in Nablus

Alastair Crooke / Mark Perry
How Hezbollah Defeated Israel: Part One, Winning the Intelligence War

Charles Sullivan
Assassins of Truth

William S. Lind
Why Do We Still Fight a Lost War?

CP News Service
The South Turns Against the War

Website of the Day
There's a Riot Goin' On

 

October 11, 2006

John Feffer
Pyongyang 1, Bush 0

Dave Lindorff
A Killing Occupation

Jackson Katz
Gunning Down Women: Coverage of "School Shootings" Misses Central Issue

April Howard / Ben Dangl
The Tin War in Bolivia

Michael Carmichael
World War W

Ken Couesbouc
The New Witchcraft: Marvin Harris on the War on Terror

Gregory Afghani
Sleepless on Skid Row: Guilty of Being Homeless in America

Alexander Cockburn
600,000 Dead in Iraq: Chortles in the New Yorker for Slaughter's Cheerleader, C. Hitchens

Website of the Day
Petition: Defend Columbia Students Who Confronted the Minutemen

 

October 10, 2006

Paul Craig Roberts
Lost Wars and a Lost Economy

Robert Robideau
The Myth Keepers of Columbus

Joshua Frank
The Democrats and the War on Civil Liberties

Dave Lindorff
Free the Press Free Linda Greenhouse

Dave Zirin
Brother of the Fist

Heather Gray
Where Votes Matter: My Experience in South Africa

James Knotwell
Big Ag in the Heartland: the Future of Nebraska's Family Farms

Missy Beattie
The Return of James Baker, III

Mike Whitney
Bush and North Korea: Bumbling Toward Disaster

David Rosen
Sex Panic on Capitol Hill: Mark Foley and the Politics of Sex in America

Website of the Day
Eno / Byrne: Music to Enjoy the Foley Scandal By

 


October 9. 2006

Robert Fisk
The Age of Terror

Norman Solomon
Welcome to the Nuclear Club

Ron Jacobs
The Boom Heard Around the World

Gideon Levy
The Mystery of America

Walter Brasch
Their Back Pages: Sex, Lies and Family Values

Mickey Z.
Who Killed Michael Moore?

John Holt
Grizzlies in Our Midst: Can Humans and Bears Coexist?

Lucinda Marshall
Not So Pretty in Pink: Profits and Breast Cancer

Saul Landau
Post-Castro Cuba

Website of the Day
War, Inc.

 

 

October 7 / 8, 2006
Weekend Edition

Alexander Cockburn
Wargasms and Orgasms

Peter Kwong
The Chinese Face of Neoliberalism

Ralph Nader
Revolt of the Generals

Mark Donham
What Cynthia McKinney Means to Me

Dave Lindorff
Philly's Police Snoops

Peter Bosshard
World Bank Shuts Out Dissident Voices: Big Dams, Huge Profits & Political Corruption

Ron Jacobs
Evil Hour in Colombia

Lawrence R. Velvel
Governmental Derelicts: Moral Meltdown in America

Fred Gardner
Arnold Vetoes Hemp Bill

David Green
The US, Israel and the Invasion of Lebanon

Jim B.
Activism, Incorporated: Outsourcing Grassroots Politics?

Missy Beattie
Prayers for Peace at the Edge of the Abyss

Michael Donnelly
Blame the Page: Grand Old Perverts Go on Offensive

Jackson Thoreau
Enter Newt

Jon Hung
Revisiting Korematsu: Denying Civil Rights Based on National Origin

CounterPunch News Service
Why We Confronted the Minutemen at Columbia

Tom D'Antoni
Playlist

Poets' Basement
Orloski, Davies, Tirado, Gaffney and Ford

Website of the Weekend
Reagan Gone Wild

 


October 6, 2006

Alison Weir
Just Another Mother Murdered

Tiffany Ten Eyck / Mark Brenner
Made in (DeUnionized) America

Corporate Crime Reporter
Look Who's Behind "37 Reasons" to Vote for Big Business: Former Clinton PR Flak Mike McCurry

Juan Antonio Montecino
Cleaving a False Divide in Latin America

Walden Bello
A Siamese Tragedy

Christopher Brauchli
Rank Invitations: Dining with Bush

Brynne Keith-Jennings
Dan Burton in Nicaragua: the Congressman, His Stick and the Elections

Jonathan Cook
The Struggle for Palestine's Soul

Website of the Day
Fighting Hog Farms and Clearcuts in the Heartland

 


October 5, 2006

John Walsh
Turn the Page

Carol Norris
The Radical Right, the Myth of the Gay Child Abuser and You: a Psychotherapist on the Hysteria Over Foley

Paul Craig Roberts
Will November Bring Hope or Another Stolen Election?

Ricardo Alarcón
The Truth About the Embargo of Cuba

James Abourezk
Waterboarding the Constitution: After Torture, What's Next?

Nicola Nasser
Removing Hamas: Brinksmanship or Coup d'Etat?

Kirkpatrick Sale
Breaking Away: the First North American Secessionist Conference

Uri Avnery
Peace with Syria: Lunch in Damascus

Website of the Day
More Naughty GOP Messages


October 4, 2006

Elizabeth Terzakis
The Walls That Racism Built: Blood Revenge, the Death Penalty and Kevin Cooper

Paul Wolf
The Mushy Rebellion: Pakistan Under Musharraf

Sean Penn
The Arrogant, the Misguided and the Cowards

Dave Lindorff
Outrage as Misdirection: The Real Scandal isn't Foley

Diane Farsetta
For Sale: Iraqi Kurdistan

Sharon Smith
Democrats: Yes to War, No to Pedophilia

Felice Pace
Revoking 1776

Sara Roy
The Economy of Gaza

Website of the Day
Alexander Cockburn: the Video Interview (Part Two)


October 3, 2006

Jennifer Van Bergen
Compassionate Conservative Pedophiles

Greg Moses
The Infallible Empire: Junking Habeas Corpus

Stan Cox
Real Bad ID: a National Driver's License and the Fading Right of Anonymity

Niranjan Ramakrishnan
How Empires Die

Evelyn Pringle
Big Pharma Takes a Hit: Alaska's Supreme Court Outlaws Forced Drugging

Fred Wilhelms
SoundExchange and Unpaid Music Artists: Help Us Find These Musicians and Get Them Paid

Michael Abelman
Know Your Farmer, Know Your Food: the Risks of Convenience and Consolidation

Gary Leupp
The Foley Follies

Website of the Day
Bush and Blair: Endless Love

 

October 2, 2006

Eric Hazan
Roadmap to Nowhere: an Interview with Tanya Reinhart on Israel/Palestine Since 2003

Mike Whitney
Bloodbath on 60 Minutes: Court Stenographer Finally Comes Clean

Norman Solomon
American Narcissism and Iraq

Assaf Kfoury
Meeting Nasrallah

Missy Beattie
The Meaning of "ummmm": Speaker Hasert and the Over-Friendly Congressman

Arthur Neslen
Lie Less in Gaza

Paula J. Caplan
How the Supreme Court Mangled My Research

Website of the Day
Predator Drones Target Bechtel

 

 

 

 

 

Subscribe Online

Weekend Edition
November 25 / 26, 2006

Plans B, C and D

Contingency and Counter-Contingency in Venezuela

By GEORGE CICCARIELLO-MAHER

Anyone paying attention to the Venezuelan press in recent weeks will not be able to ignore a shift in the tenor of the electoral campaign. Weeks and months of straightforward campaign rhetoric and poll results has given way to a more sinister tone, as the discussion has shifted away from the voting process on December 3rd and toward what will be done on December 4th. This shift originates in the rhetoric of an increasingly-desperate opposition which hopes to have its cake and eat it too, that is, to simultaneously contest elections and discredit the process. But this rhetoric has found its echo of resistance in similar plans for "the day after" by different sectors of the Bolivarian Revolution: efforts to organize themselves on the local level to defend against attacks on Venezuelan sovereignty.


Plan B

After much uncertainty, it now seems that-despite running consistently 20-30% behind Chávez in the polls-opposition candidate Manuel Rosales will not be pulling out of the election. And this despite the fact that sectors of the opposition like the Acción Democrática Party (AD) and Antonio Ledezma's Alianza Bravo Pueblo have still refused to support the process and are calling for abstention. While the Rosales campaign has not denied the claims of such groups, and while he can be heard to echo the claims of abstentionists that the "electoral conditions are insufficient," and that the fingerprint machines used in the voting process have "no function except to frighten the electorate," Rosales has not been sufficiently consistent with this theme to justify withdrawing from the elections. Given his rhetoric, quite simply, withdrawing would be not be a credible decision: it's too late for that.

But unfortunately, this doesn't mean that the opposition will be passively accepting their electoral defeat on December 3rd. Instead, rather than complaining of electoral conditions beforehand and talking the abstentionist talk, the opposition is rallying around the slogan of "defend the vote." This vague slogan has some clear consequences, as became clear when opposition ideologue Rafael Poleo appeared recently on Globovisión. Poleo, who has links to the Bush clan and the CIA, who was thoroughly implicated in the April 2002 coup, and whose daughter has been directly implicated in the assassination of Danilo Anderson, the judge whose job it was to collect evidence against the coup-plotters, laid out the strategy of the radical opposition in the clearest of terms on November 6th: "On the 3rd, it is up to the citizens to align themselves with the opposition, they need to go and vote. On the 4th, it's up to Manuel Rosales to lead the protests against the fraud that has been set up. And on the 5th, it's up to the Armed Forces to decide if it will continue forcing those in the Venezuelan opposition to put up with a shameful regime."

According to Poleo, Rosales could be the most important Venezuelan of the 21st century "if he does what he needs to do." The Electoral Committee (CNE) "will announce the victory of Hugo Chávez, regardless of what the numbers say," and "at 6am on the 4th, the streets will fill with people decrying fraud, and then we will see the true size of Rosales." Revealingly, Poleo declares that "that day after, the 4th, will be even more important than December 3rdOn the 4th, it's up to the people to do what the Ukranians did, to carry out an 'Orange Revolution,' to hurl themselves onto the streets, because the fraud has already been arranged, they already have the numbers ready." The Chavistas will not abandon power for the simple reason that "they are Nazis." A coup attempt is in the works, and it has been publicly announced beforehand (all claims of a lack of press freedom in Venezuela thereby proven false).

While Poleo seems uncertain about which path Rosales will choose, the ground is already being laid for his participation in this coup attempt. Hence, Rosales has been clearly evasive when faced with questions about his recognition of the election results: when Chávez publicly agreed to respect the results of the election and challenged his opponent to do the same, the response from Rosales echoing the "democratic" doublespeak of the Northern superpower. Rosales made the very question sound silly: Venezuela is, according to Rosales, the "only country on earth" in which there would even exist a doubt regarding the recognition of elections, but despite this the opposition candidate would not agree to accept these results without the significant caveat that said results must be fair. In terms of the second step of the plan-appeals to the military-Rosales even beat Poleo to the punch, openly calling on November 5th for a meeting with the military high command, a request which was flatly denied by Minster of Defense General Raúl Baduel on the basis that such a meeting would constitute an unconstitutional intervention of the military into the electoral process.

In addition, Nestor González González, the baldheaded military leader of the April 2002 coup, has crawled out of his hole to release an audiotape calling for the same sequence of events. While the opposition press wouldn't touch this tape with a ten-foot pole, the rhetoric is the same as that of Poleo: defending the vote, and thereby defending "civil society." As Mario Silva, the fiery host of Chavista evening program La Hojilla makes clear, talk of civil society operates here as a subsititute for talk of the pueblo, the people, for the simple reason that "they don't have a people." Silva's response: "They shall not pass," and if the opposition attempts to spread destabilization and violent blockades known as guarimbas outward from their wealthy refuge, "they won't get out of the Eastern part of the capital."

This entire strategy, moreover, has been developing slowly through the political interventions of certain polling agencies whose fidelity to the opposition is clear, and whose polls range from the bad to the worse to the patently made-up. The now-infamous American firm Penn, Schoen, and Berland-most famous for its coup-mongering through polling in Venezuela and Serbia-has stepped into the fray as expected. Perhaps wary of repeating their exaggerated performance in the 2004 recall election, Penn and Schoen have released polls showing Chávez with a slender 6-point lead, but here's the kicker: due to some dubious claims about how the undecideds (the "ni-ni," or "neither-nor" as they are called here) will eventually vote, the results have been deemed "a technical tie."

Moreover, the "Hannah Arendt Center" has nominally interrogated but subtly reinforced another alibi of the opposition by relasing a poll under the patently politicized slogan of the "Survey Without Fear." Respondents were allegedly given different colored pencils bearing either Chavista or opposition slogans, or no slogan at all, and the fact that their responses shifted according to the pencil used allegedly "proves" that fear is present.

The pollsters don't see fit to explain how this fear operates, why it is that the "Chavista" pencil doesn't merely operate as a reminder of the accomplishments of the revolutionary government, or most importantly why it is that the fact that the opposition pencil yields more support for Rosales isn't also a result of "fear" of the opposition. But to ask such questions of these polls is to take them too seriously: as Mario Silva reveals, again on La Hojilla, the so-called "Hannah Arendt Center" is directly linked to the head of the Rosales campaign team. Such polls constitute little more than direct interventions in support of this three-step plan laid out by Poleo.


Plan C

In response to this chatter from the opposition press, Chávez has made very clear how he would respond to an attack on the constitutional order after the elections are held. In a speech on November 4th, Chávez preempted the opposition by announcing that any "Plan B" would represent yet another attempt by the United States to topple his regime and replace it with something friendlier (to foreign capital). Since resistance to Chavismo is fundamentally international, according to Chávez, so too should be the response, and he therefore announced plans to unilaterally terminate petroleum shipments to the United States if "actions similar to those of 2002 were to occur." This is, in his words, the "Plan CH" to the opposition's "Plan B" (unfortunately, translation loses the fact that, when pronounced, "ch" sounds strikingly like the name of an Argentine revolutionary that some might have heard of): "We will give them a knockout at the polls, but if they activate their Plan B of violence, electoral guarimbas, and the rejection of the results, if they attempt to sabotage oil installations or attempt a coup d'etat, we will give them a double knockout with Plan CH."

In terms of a specific response to the predictable tactics of the opposition, Vice President José Vicente Rangel made clear on November 13th that the goal of the opposition is to provoke a violent response through guarimbas. According to Rangel, such plans won't work, since "we aren't going to give them the pleasure because we can control problems of public order with the word, with the voice, with the example." Order, however, will be maintained: "aside from the soldiers who will go out to defend the Chávez government, it will be the people who immediately hit the streets without any need for us to call upon them, as happened on April 13th 2002." As has often been said by the President, "if they come at us like the 11th (of April), we'll give them the 13th."

Chávez himself has echoed this sentiment more recently in a speech on November 17th, in which he asks of the opposition: "don't force me to take drastic measures to safeguard the sovereignty and the stability of the country." Attempts at destabilization would be met with firmness, since "that permissive Chávez was left behind that night in 2002." Chávez concludes: "We won't allow Venezuela to be filled with bloodshed again."


Plan D

As suggested by the Vice President, Plan C (or "CH") isn't as important as Plan D: the autonomous organization of Chavistas to defend their revolution. So we shouldn't be surprised to find that the most radical sectors of Chavismo are also making plans. Specifically, several armed self-defense organizations rooted in the Tupamaro movement and largely-defunct Bolivarian Circles, which claim a particularly powerful following in the barrios of western Caracas, are preparing plans for the defense of Chavista neighborhoods.

Such plans are centered in the historically revolutionary neighborhood of 23 de Enero (January 23rd), in the climbing foothills in western Caracas. 23 de Enero has long represented the organizational "brain" of radical Caracas, as opposed to the "heart" of revolt represented by the slums of Petare, that powderkeg standing far to the east of the city which gave rise to the epic 1989 Caracazo riots. The spirit of revolt has often been sparked in the utter destitution of Petare, the largest and most dangerous of Caracas' slums, but the organizational structure which fans the flames can generally be found in 23. In the short lived April 2002 coup against Chávez, several ministers were spirited away for safe keeping in the "bunker" of 23 de Enero, only to reemerge and participate in the efforts to recover the president.

Given this role as radical safe haven, the many radical armed groups populating the neighborhood-from the Carapaica, who made their plans public in local newspapers, to Cepa Cartolini, to the Colectivo Alexis Vive (most of these groups descended from the earlier Coordinador Simón Bolívar and later Tupamaros)-think first of protecting the "bunker": a source close to sectors of the Tupamaros tells me that "the general line is that, in the event of trouble, if it's a confrontation with lead, they'll guard 23 de Enero, keep in contact with other organizations, and mobilize resistance." Specifically, I am told, most organizations have adopted a bifurcated approach to resisting the "Plan B" of the opposition: half of their forces will be devoted to rearguard defense of the bunkers, while half will form "mobilization groups" traveling throughout the city.

It should be pointed out that, while the Metropolitan Mayor's office has "fulfilled a necessary support role" by providing logistical support to radical neighborhoods (cellphones, motorcycles), this role is precisely that: support. That is to say, these neighborhood organizations are best considered as "base movements" engaged in a revolutionary process of local administration. In the words of one participant, the resistance to threats from the opposition has led these groups to "create new forms for organizing the local self-defense of sovereignty." These new forms are not