home / subscribe / donate / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq

The New Print Edition of CounterPunch, Only for Our Newsletter Subscribers!

How Neoliberalism Crashed

The economic crash has changed the world map and destroyed the neoliberal consensus that has blighted the planet for the last thirty years. Read Hudson and Sommers on the great opportunity. Also: Learn where Bill Ayers hid out when he was on the run. Cockburn and St. Clair disclose that his host in those fugitive days was a top McCain backer. Also in our new issue: Also: portrait of a police informer -- David Bonner’s marvelous portrait of the late George Demmerle. Find the answers in CounterPunch newsletter. Get your copy today by subscribing online or calling 1-800-840-3683 Contributions to CounterPunch are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now! CounterPunch books and gear make great presents.

Order CounterPunch By Email For Only $35 a Year !

 

Today's Stories

October 24 / 26, 2008

Mike Whitney
Down for the Count

October 23, 2008

Allan J. Lichtman
What Voter Fraud?

Todd Chretien
Why I'm Not Voting for Obama

John Ross
No Child Left Behind, Mexican-Style

Peter Morici
Strategies to End the Crisis

Mats Svensson
Short Film Clips at a Checkpoint

Marlene Martin
Don't Let Them Execute an Innocent Man

Robert Jensen /
Pat Youngblood
Looking Beyond the Election and Beyond Elections

Margaret Kimberley
Rightwing Obama Love

Deepak Tripathi
Post-Bush Scenarios

David Morris
Why Joe the Plumber is a Socialist (And You Are, Too)

Website of the Day
Voting While Black in North Carolina

October 22, 2008

Brian Cloughley
Kid Killers are Barbarians

Heather Gray
Raising Hell in the South: the Legacy of J. L. Chestnut, Jr.

Jeff Birkenstein
McCain's Disdain for Spain

Ralph Nader
The Song Remains the Same: Convergence and Avoidance in the Presidential Election

DC Larson
The Growing of a Heartland Nader Raider

David Swanson
Colin Powell, Not Qualified for Government Service

Keeanga-Yamatta Taylor Race and the Election: When the "Real" America Enters the Voting Booth

Larry Everest
9/11 and the Imperial Adventure in Afghanistan

Robert Fantina
Anything to Win

Martha Rosenberg
The Financier's Playbook

Stephen Martin
Giving It Up to the Combine

Website of the Day
Brokers with Hands on Their Faces

October 21, 2008

Vijay Prashad
Wealth's Apostles

Paul Craig Roberts
How Inflation Works: Why I Can't Buy an Old Ferrari

Corey D. B. Walker
Empire and White Supremacy

Steve Breyman
How to "Win" in Afghanistan

Eric Toussaint
The Economic Crisis and Latin America: Time to Delink

Wajahat Ali
Boo Radley Comes Out to Play: the Emerging Muslim-American Electorate

Robert Weitzel
Wasting a Vote for Lincoln's Radical Ideal (Or Why I'm Voting for Nader)

Brendan Cooney
Palinoscopy: an Exploration of Why Liberals are So Obsessed with Sarah Palin

Dave Lindorff
Cuba's Oil Reserves: a Game-Changer?

Marqueece Harris-Dawson / Bob Wing
When You're a Black Candidate There's No Such Thing as a Safe Lead

Patrick B. Barr
Socialist, Socialist, SOCIALIST!

Omar Barghouti
The Boycott and Palestinian Groups: Countering the Critics

Website of the Day
How to Dismantle a US War Plane (and Get Away With It)

October 20, 2008

Michael Hudson
The ABCs of Paulson's Bailout

Anthony DiMaggio
The Scandal That Never Was: ACORN, Rightwing Media and Election "Fraud"

Tariq Ali
Zardari Bans My Books

Uri Avnery
Is Akko Burning?

Bill Quigley
Hammered by the Swedes

Ben Rosenfeld
The Politics of St. Joe, Martyr to a Lie

David Michael Green
Payback's a Bitch: McCain on the Ash Heap

William S. Lind
The Afghanistan Advantage

Chris Genovali
Drill, Baby, Drill (Wink, Wink)

Stephen Martin
The Last Man in America

Howard Lisnoff
Bad News for War Resisters

David Yearsley
Organ Meat

Website of the Day
Our Brother is Sick: the Steve Ferguson Cancer Fund

October 17 / 19, 2008

Alexander Cockburn
Blow Ups and Bomber
s

Jeffrey St. Clair
Inside Hanford: a Trip to America's Most Toxic Place

Pam Martens
How the Banksters are Making a Killing Off the Bailout

Paul Craig Roberts
Government of Thieves

Mike Whtney
No More Investment Banks

Michael D. Yates
Bowling Alley Blues: Racism Dies Hard in Johnstown, PA

Suzanne Smith
The Energy-War Connection: McCain Said It, Why Don't We?

Carl Boggs
Prosecuting Bush

Ralph Nader
Closing the Courthouse Doors

Fidel Castro
The Global Crash

Dave Marsh
The Great Levi Stubbs

Saul Landau
Denial, the Election Musical Comedy

Jo Guldi
The Floods of Heaven

Kevin Zeese
Now the Cost of War Really Matters

Larry Everest
Afghanistan, Not a Good War Gone Bad

Steve Early
Stop, in the Name of Joe!

David Macaray
Hey, Joe

Ben Terrall
When Ike Hit Haiti

Missy Beattie
Palin and God's Children

Don Monkerud
American Exceptionalism

Helen Redmond
Health Care Now's Big Con

Dan Bacher
Schwarzenegger's Delta Vision: Canals and Dams to Bail Out Big Ag

Wajahat Ali
Bush Gets Stoned

Farzana Versey
The White Tiger's Stripes and Gripes

Vladimir Frolov
Medvedev to Obama: We Come Not to Bury America, But to Buy It

Kim Nicolini
Frozen River: At Last, a Great Movie That's Neither Hip Nor Cool

Poets Basement
Gibbons, Corsale, Davis and Fleming

Website of the Day
The Real Sarah Palin?

October 16, 2008

Mike Whitney
The End of Friedmanite Economics: an Interview with Robert Pollin

Jonathan Cook
The Acre Riots

Ayesha Ijaz Khan
Is Obama Playing to the Gallery? Or Has He Lost the Plot in South Asia?

Alan Maass
A Supreme Injustice: the Death Penalty Case of Troy Davis

Chuck O'Connell
Our Needs Do Not Fit on Their Ballots

Mary Lynn Cramer
Krugman's Prize: Iconoclast, Apologist or Propagandist?

P. Sainath
The Race May be Over, But Race Isn't

Andy Worthington
The Shrinking Case Against Binyam Mohamed: Justice Department Drops "Dirty Bomb Plot" Allegation

Peter Gelderloos
Enric Duran, the Good Thief?

Stephen Martin
The Nourishment of Idleness: Where Has All the Money Gone?

Douglas Valentine
Why I'm Voting for Obama

Website of the Day
The Mormon Worker

 

October 15, 2008

Steve Conn
The Real Story of Troopergate

William P. O'Connor
The Legend of John McCain

Robert Weissman
The Partial Nationalization of US Banks: Public Ownership, But No Public Control

Jonathan M. Feldman
Before the Second Wave of Crisis: an Alternative to the Triple Failure

Ron Jacobs
The Politics of Race in America: Is a Vote For Obama a Vote Against Racism?

Conn Hallinan
Targeting Unions in Colombia

Justin Podur
The Financial Economy and Real Economy

Karl Grossman
The New Nuclear Navy

Dave Lindorff
Is the Government Really Turning Socialist?

Eric Walberg
The Quiet Russian

Martha Rosenberg
Of Blood and Eggs

Uri Avnery
A Fairy Tale

Monica Benderman
No More

Website of the Day
Contractor Misconduct Database

 

 

Weekend Edition
October 24 / 26, 2008

Faith-Based Surge

Whining About Winning in Iraq

By SAUL LANDAU

On infrequent news reports from Iraq I occasionally recognize a place I filmed. In late September 2002, I saw Baghdad, Kerbalah, Najaf, Hamidayah and other Iraqi cities through the camera lens. Saddam Hussein had just announced he would allow UN weapons inspectors to return to Iraq. US politicians and pundits ignored the implications of his action. But in Baghdad, visiting foreigners breathed sighs of relief. If Saddam had weapons, they concluded, the best forensic experts in the world with sophisticated technology would find them. Saddam knew this, so it meant he didn’t have WMD. As soon as the inspectors concluded their search and failed to find the alleged stash, Bush would have lost his reason to go to war.

Under Saddam, the ruling Baath Party made sure that fellow Sunnis held key government positions. But they retained space for Shiites, Kurds, Turkomen and even Christians like Deputy Foreign Minister Tariq Aziz. Saddam enforced this uneasy arrangement with brutal repression, but even after starting foolish and costly wars (Iran and Kuwait), he still had oil revenues trickling in, enough to give many Iraqis access to water, sewage, schools and hospitals. Iraqis suffered hardships of 12 years of crippling sanctions imposed by the US and UK as punishment for Saddam’s Kuwait invasion.

During that week of filming, no Iraqi introduced him or herself as Shia or Sunni, despite antipathy to Saddam – which they expressed off camera. Several pleaded: “Please don’t come here. Saddam is old and will die soon. His sons are too stupid to govern.”

Meanwhile, Hans Blix and his UN inspectors began their search. After several months of finding nothing, Bush grew impatient and told them to leave, invaded Iraq in March and in May 2003 declared victory: “Mission Accomplished.”

Five years later, Republican candidates shout triumphantly: “We’re winning the war in Iraq,” a war Bush had declared won. Do they mean fewer US troops now get killed and wounded? That’s it! McCain walked the Baghdad streets (one block with massive military protection) and got a gestalt experience: “Thanks to Gen. David Petraeus and these brave young Americans, we are winning in Iraq and we will come home with honor,” said John McCain.

Such campaign rhetoric – reported on Fox Noise as News -- collides painfully with reality. No one questions the relevance of honor in the context of killing, torturing and humiliating a people. What does “honor” mean after subjecting Iraq to five plus years of occupation? No one invited us, by the way! The media and the leading Democrats do not confront McCain when he twists facts and history. They also aided and abetted Bush in his lies and war-making by continuing to fund it; then, they regretted their past behavior and continued to fund the war. Well, no one’s perfect!

“It’s just campaign rhetoric,” retort the cynics who supposedly belong to the Fourth Estate. “No one really pays attention.” If not, then why say it? Obama at least chastised McCain in the debates for supporting the push to go to war in the first place. But Biden also … well, lot’s not bring up unpleasant memories (votes).

Sarah Palin, who can’t make two coherent sentences on key issues, whined her “winning” lines and then shamelessly displayed her son, Track, about to deploy to Iraq. “John McCain refused to break faith with the troops who have now brought victory within sight,” she squealed. “as mother of one of those troops.”

Obama refuses “to acknowledge we are winning in Iraq” Palin bleats. “He called it spin. Is General Petraeus spinning the American people? I don’t think so. I don’t think so.” McCain pied in: “We’re not gonna let them get defeated. We’re not gonna have them surrender. And they’re gonna win. And by golly, they are winning, my friends. They are winning. They are winning.” (MSNBC, 6/13/08)

Winning! I hope Obama uses a few minutes of his remaining campaign time to expose the absurd use of language his opponents have chosen to describe what war has inflicted on Iraq and its people! Iraqis bleed. US troops occupy their country for no legal or moral reason. Hundreds of thousands of Iraqis have died or gotten wounded in vain. They have watched their infrastructure get destroyed and their professionals flee the country – or get murdered. Millions had homes destroyed; hundreds of thousands were subjected to arbitrary imprisonment; 4 plus million have fled, some to internal refugee camps, 2.2 million to other countries.

McCain and Palin have elevated the word “surge” to the level of religious faith. No need to explain! In fact, the reduction of violence in Iraq against US troops has resulted from paying former enemies to stop fighting US forces and from encouraging – by not stopping -- ethnic cleansing in the country.

Violence remains a daily occurrence, but US troops are less the victims of it. Iraqis now bear nearly the full brunt of tactics like kidnappings, a very common occurrence.
           
On October 12, Pamela Hess (AP) reported “a startling statistic” from US intelligence: “a 500 percent increase in foreigners taken hostage around the world as militants adopt the methods of the most violent figures in the Iraq insurgency.” In 2004, “342 foreign and U.S. hostages were taken by terrorist and insurgent organizations. By 2006, that number had grown to 501. By 2007, it had jumped to more than 1,500, and it is on track to rise even higher this year, according to Thomas Brown, director of the office that analyzes information about prisoners of war and those missing in action.” This figure does not include the total kidnappings of a country’s own residents by terrorist or insurgent groups — a much more frequent and long-standing practice. U.S. military hostages – not included in the magical shield of “surge” -- are almost guaranteed execution.

Ask the residents of Mosul about the magical surge. Over the last weeks, thousands of Christians have fled this predominantly Sunni city, 225 miles north of Baghdad. These “almost winners” ran from Islamic extremists who declared holy war on this ancient Christian community.

Iraqi police rushed to Mosul to try to stop the murders. Some 5,000 Christians fled over the past weeks, according to Iraqi officials. Mosul’s provincial governor Duraid Kashmula, called the violence “the fiercest campaign against the Christians since 2003.” (Patrick Cockburn, The Independent, October 13)

How will the Iraqis who fled respond to Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki’s claim that they can now safely return to their homes? So far, only 20,000 families (120,000 individuals) have returned, according to Abdul-Khaliq Zanqana, a member of the Iraqi parliament’s displacement and migration committee. 2 million refugees still live in Iraq; most of the others reside in Syria and Jordan.

In 2006-7, some 3,000 Iraqis died each month from sectarian violence. This figure has dropped, but not because more US troops arrived. Rather, ethnic cleansing has meant that either Sunni or Shia dominate neighborhoods or whole cities. A Sunni trying to reclaim his house in a Shia neighborhood or vice versa can hardly expect a warm welcome – except for arson. Baghdad has become lined with concrete blast walls and checkpoints. This means greater security, but not better life style.

US troops did train Iraqis army and police forces so that Iraqis could develop their politics, which they did. But senior members of Iraq’s government tend to live in the Green Zone, protected by US troops and with regular electricity and potable water. Other parts of Iraq suffer from cholera due to bad water.

Iraqi leaders still travel in armored convoys and rely on huge concrete barriers. Murder has replaced political killing. Thanks to the five years of war, Iraq has become a training ground for professional assassins.

In this atmosphere, who is winning? And who is whining about winning? Prime Minister Maliki, whom the White House selected as Iraq’s leader, leans toward Iran in his allegiances. He has tacitly supported Obama’s position of withdrawal within sixteen months. He also embraced Iranian President Ahmadinejad when he visited Iraq in March, without the vast display of body guards and military protection John McCain received.

No gratitude! For four years, Bush policies backed the pro-Iranian Shiites and helped them consolidate political power. Once the US military force has gone, Maliki can order Iraq’s US-trained army to target the Sunnis – and they can count on Iranian help in doing so. Maliki’s sectarian Shiites and their allies in Tehran have emerged from a formerly Sunni-run state to govern, thanks to US help. McCain and Palin refer to this dreary scenario when they whine about Obama not accepting “winning.”

How would they define “losing?” Obama could retort: “Stop whining about winning and explain how you’ll rebuild Babylon!” I filmed in that biblical spot in 2002. Six months later, winning US army members watched looters steal and destroy Iraq’s treasures while protecting the oil assets -- the behavior of “winners”!

Saul Landau’s film, IRAQ: VOICES FROM THE STREET, is on dvd on English and Spanish (roundworldproductions@gmail.com) See his Counterpunch Press book A BUSH AND BOTOX WORLD


 

 

Shop at Amazon.com

 

 


Now Available from CounterPunch Books!

The Inside Story of the Shannon Five's Smashing Victory Over the
Bush War Machine

By Harry Browne

Born Under a Bad Sky:
Notes from the Dark Side

of the Earth
By Jeffrey St. Clair

RED STATE REBELS:
Tales of Grassroots Resistance from the Heartland

Edited by
Jeffrey St. Clair
and Joshua Frank


How the Press Led
the US into War


Buy End Times Now!

New From
CounterPunch Books

The Secret Language
of the Crossroads:
HOW THE IRISH
INVENTED SLANG
By Daniel Cassidy

WINNER OF THE
AMERICAN BOOK AWARD!


Click Here to Buy!

Cassidy on Tour
Click Here for Dates & Venues

"The Case Against Israel"
Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz


Click Here to Buy!


Saul Landau's Bush and Botox World with a Foreword by Gore Vidal


Click Here to Order!

 

Grand Theft Pentagon
How They Made a Killing on the War on Terrorism

 

 

 

 

 


The Occupation
by Patrick Cockburn

 

 

 


Humanitarian Imperialism
By Jean Bricmont

 


 

 


CITY BEAUTIFUL
By Tennessee Reed