home / subscribe / about us / books / archives / search / links / feedback

Read Cockburn and St. Clair's Whiteout: the CIA, Drugs and the Press and discover how the CIA gave a helping hand to the opium lords who took over Afghanistan, thus ushering the Taliban into power.


CounterPunch: Complete Coverage of 9/11 and the War on Afghanistan

New Print Edition of CounterPunch Available Exclusively to Subscribers: Occupied Ramallah Close Up: Large and Small Change in a State of Siege; Feed Your Goats, Maybe Get Shot; Snipers on Main Street; Hiding in Your Back Room for Three Days; Humor, Heroism and Bravado Amid Bullets; Occupied DC: Legislators' Daily Gauntlet of Searches; Only in America: His Dad Was CIA; He Hated Blacks; He Robbed Banks, and Liked to Dress Up Like a Woman; A Tribute to Billy Wilder. Remember, the CounterPunch website is supported exclusively by subscribers to our newsletter. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now!

April 19, 2002

Jeffrey St. Clair
From Sen. "Lunkhead" to Bush Energy Czar: A Year in the Life of Spencer Abraham

April 18, 2002

Tom Turnipseed
Latin America's Dilemma:
The Propaganda of Otto Reich

Sam Bahour
Bush is Playing Russian
Roulette with Palestinians

M. Shahid Alam
A Colonizing Project
Built on Lies

Alexander Cockburn
Austin Cultural Limits:
Willie Nelson, Film and BBQ

April 17, 2002

Norman Finkelstein
Behind the Carnage in Palestine

Kristen Schurr
With the Wounded
and the Homeless in Nablus

Norman Madarasz
Undoing Chavez:
The View from South America

Brian Wood
Combing The Ruins of Jenin

George Monbiot
Chemical Coup: The CIA's Attempt to Undermine the UN's Weapon Inspector for Iraq

Robert Fisk
Fear and Learning in America

April 16, 2002

Todd May
US Should End Aid to Israel

Gabriel Ash
The Oilman, the General
and the Coup that Failed

Ron Jacobs
Wake Up Some Mornin',
Find Your Own Self Dead:
The Chavez Coup

Brian Wood
Inside Jenin: Rubble and Decomposing Bodies

Jack McCarthy
Citizen Coup: The Times,
The Post and the Coup Plotters

Dave Marsh
Hymns: How I Got Through
Last Week

April 15, 2002

Susi Abeles
A Field Trip to Jenin

Breyten Breytenbach
A Letter to Ariel Sharon:
"You Won't Break Them"

Gregory Wilpert
CounterCoup in Venezuela

Kristen Schurr
Amid the Rubble of Nablus

Jordy Cummings
An Open Letter to Abe Foxman

Christopher Reilly
The Media, the CIA
and the Chavez Coup

James T. Phillips
"Homicide" Bombers

April 14, 2002

William Blum
The CIA and Venezuela

David Vest
A Good Old-Fashion "Incursion"

Ralph Nader
General Motors:
Stuck in Reverse

M. Junaid Alam
From the Ashes: Palestinian Struggle for Freedom

Sam Bahour
Palestinians and Americans

April 13, 2002

Beth Daoud
Life in the Ruins of Nablus

Patrick Cockburn
Bulldozing History:
The End Nears for Stalin's
Most Monstrous Hotel

Gregory Wilpert
The Coup in Venezuela:
an Eye-Witness Account

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
Thoughts on Our War
Against Terrorism

Anne Winkler-Morey
Why I Didn't Organize
a Passover Seder This Year

Resources:
100s of Links About 9/11


CounterPunch:
Complete Coverage of 9/11 and Its Aftermath


Five Days That
Shook The World:
Seattle and Beyond

By Alexander Cockburn
and Jeffrey St. Clair
Photos by Allan Sekula

(Click Here to Order from CounterPunch Online at 20% Off Amazon.com's price!)

INSIDE

Subscribe Online!

EXCLUSIVE TO
COUNTERPUNCH
SUBSCRIBERS


Published March 15, 2002

  • Facing Down Rehnquist and Scalia:
  • Jennifer Harbury at the Supreme Court;
  • ADL Throws in Towel, Pays Up:
  • How They Worked for Apartheid Regime and Spied on NAACP:
  • Cockburn on America the Bully:
  • From Teddy Roosevelt to George W.
  • St. Clair on Musicians Against the Death Penalty & The Legacy of the Mekons.


    Search CounterPunch

Read Whiteout and Find Out How the CIA's Backing of the Mujahideen Created the World's Most Robust Heroin Market and Helped to Finance the Rise of the Taliban and Osama bin Laden

Whiteout:
CIA, Drugs & the Press

by Alexander Cockburn
and Jeffrey St. Clair

The New Crusade:
America's War on Terrorism

By Rahul Mahajan

The Memphis Blues Again:
Six Decades of Memphis Music Photographs
Photos by Ernest Withers
Text by Daniel Wolff

The New Intifada:
Resisting Israel's Apartheid

Edited by Roane Carey

 

A Pocket Guide to
Environmental Bad Guys
by James Ridgeway
and Jeffrey St. Clair

The Phoenix Program
by Douglas Valentine

Al Gore:
A User's Manual
by Cockburn
and St. Clair

Buy This Explosive
New Book at an
Amazing Discount!
 

Reviews of Gore:
a User's Manual


Private Warriors
by Ken Silverstein

CounterPunch's Booktalk

April 18, 2002

Letter from the Frontier

By Chris Floyd

Gaius Aelius Messala
legatus, XVII Legion
to his brother, Quintus.

Germania Magnia. 19 October [8 A.D].

Brother! Warmest greetings from the River Elbe. Tonight you recline on soft couches with your friends, feasting and drinking--and talking rot--while we poor soldiers shiver in our tents, eating hard bread and sharpening our blades for tomorrow's battle. Even now your arm is encircling some tender waist--is it still Livilla, or has Agrippina mounted the throne once again? Such lusty campaigners!--while my only company is cold bronze, a flickering lamp, and the ugly mug of Brutus, the slave Father sent with his last dispatch. He smiles as he writes this for me--quite right, Brutus! We must take our misfortunes in good part, eh?

But in truth, Brother, I would not change places with you tonight. Our fight tomorrow is a noble one, an act of justice that will bring fresh glory to Rome. We strike at the barbarians who devastated Noviomagus this summer, a murderous raid across the Rhine, on our own territory, leaving thousands dead--an affront to Roman power that cannot go unanswered. We have pursued these beasts deep into their own lair, and now they are cornered. Tomorrow they will pay the price for their evil.

So much for them. Now, Quintus, Father sends disturbing news--your continuing acquaintance with those so-called 'republicans' who snipe and peep and whisper their calumnies against the great Augustus. I know the type well; indeed, in my own youth I was given to much the same tomfoolery, duped by tales of 'ancient liberties lost' and fearsome rants against 'tyranny'. But you are now reaching an age when you must put aside this kind of sentimentality, and recognise that the measures taken by our Imperator have in fact saved the Republic from its own worst excesses.

Where is this 'tyranny'? You are in Rome--look around, what do you see? The old forms and formalities are still observed--indeed, more strictly than ever. The Senate still meets, debates, makes policy. The assemblies still hold their elections, the praetors still exercise their constitutional powers. Political factions still jostle for primacy, poets and playwrights still revel in decadence, courts are still filled with wrangling advocates chewing over every jot and tittle--tyranny should present a more placid face, don't you think? The bumptious course of our public life should be smoothed and flattened by the iron hand of the autocrat. But as you see, it is not so.

Yes, Quintus, I know the whispers. I know that Augustus has taken on many of the burdens of state that once were dispersed among several hands. But note well: at each stage, these powers have been granted by the Senate, ratified by law, in the best Roman tradition. And note too, dear brother: this accumulation of powers is temporary. They were given to Augustus in a time of crisis, when through his wisdom and his auctoritas, his moral authority, he delivered the commonwealth from chaos and preserved our way of life from those who would destroy it. Once we are past these dangerous shoals, the concentration of powers will end, never fear.

So yes, to preserve those 'ancient liberties,' we must relinquish them, in part, for a time. Perhaps this paradox is hard to fathom there in the comfort of Rome; but for us on the frontier, its truth stands out in stark relief. We are here to carry on that work of preservation, to save our way of life and pass it down to our posterity. I want my son to grow strong and wise, secure in the bounty of our family lands. I want him to fish in the peaceful waters on our estate, as I did, listening to the learned slaves reciting Virgil, Seneca, Horace and Livy. He should never know want or fear or hunger: those ravening wolves which spring from the chaos that Augustus has mastered--and which these barbarians, in their envy and ignorance, would unleash upon us again.

How many generations have shed their blood to bring us to this pinnacle of civilisation! How much toil and treasure have been expended to maintain it! Yet your whispering friends speak of 'aggression,' of 'violent conquest' and 'oppression' of other peoples They would have us still in mud huts, trembling by the Tiber. Yes, we project our dominance--because we must. First and foremost, to preserve our patrimony, as is right and just--but also to bring enlightenment to the dark places of the earth. Why else has Fortune favoured us, above all nations in the history of the world, except to carry out this divine mission? I am proud to play my small part in such noble endeavours; and I hope that you too, dear Quintus, will come to know this pride as well.

The night grows thin; dawn is near. I must finish this tomorrow--if Jupiter and Minerva, deities of our house, see fit to bring me through.

20 October. Evening.

The battle was short, our losses light. The barbarians have been destroyed. The best of our men went about it quickly--the only mercy in this kind of thing--but some fell short, alas. I had to execute three of my soldiers--dispatched them with my own hand--for the bestial way they handled the women and children, making slow sport of the business.

By afternoon, the killing was done, and the village put to the torch. We marched up to the surrounding hills and made camp on the western slope, the far side, away from the smoking valley.

I am weary now and will write no more. Commend me to our father, and attend well what I have told you. Put away childish things and gird yourself: we have much hard work ahead.

Chris Floyd is is an American freelance journalist based in Europe. His political column, 'Global Eye,' appears weekly in The Moscow Times and the St. Petersburg Times. Different versions of this article originally ran in The Moscow Times and The Ecologist (UK). He can be reached at: cfloyd72@hotmail.com