What
You're Missing in Our Subscriber-only CounterPunch Newsletter
The Texas Wars of
Robert Gates:
On Affirmative
Action and Mexican Migrants
What's Robert
Gates's not-so-distant dirty past? Greg Moses turns over the
dirt in College Station, how Gates fought affirmative action
there and how Reagan and Bush's's slippery spook will run the
new Border War.The End of the Libération
Myth! Meet Libération, turncoat tool of neoliberalism.Pierre
Rimbert traces the decline and fall of one of radical journalism's
great hopes --the paper founded by Jean-Paul Sartre. Daniel Wolff describes how Bob Dylan
plays the music of the Apocalypse. Remember, we are funded solely
by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this
website by buying a
subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you
won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation towards the
cost of this online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible.Click
here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please:Subscribe
Now
Palestinian
"Civil War" and the Israeli Chocolate Ration
By ELIZA ERNSHIRE
Ramallah.
This phrase is not in the dictionary
of the Palestinian language, the Prime minister of this occupied
country told us. There is no such thing as civil war. No such
thing as factional hatred, no such thing as hatred no such thing.
There is no such thing as bombing
family homes, the Prime minister of Israel has told us and the
President of the U.S.A. has told us there is no such thing as
misguided precision bombs, no such thing as murdered civilians
and broken families and hatred and more hatred that grows from
these events. There is no such thing as fear in the Israeli society,
the Palestinians tell us, as the Jewish citizens wonder when
their security will be threatened again. The Israeli army tells
us that there is no such thing as injustice at checkpoints, no
such thing as giving freedom to 18 year old boys in Hummers who
terrorize Palestinian villages. There is no such thing as a history
for the Jewish people or their past of suffering ... No such
thing as the Holocaust ... No such thing.
Words that are torn to shreds
in the reality of conflict. In the reality of the hatred that
is being born out of every misguided precision bomb, out of every
crude rocket launched, out of every hour spent at a checkpoint
waiting for that 18-year old boy to finish his cigarette.
There is hatred born also from
the failure of the leading people who say "no such thing"
to recognize that there is such a thing and that this thing is
the death knell of their country.
Was it not the absolute warning
for everyone when three young children in Gaza were gunned to
death in a car on their way to school, that things have gone
far too far already? Here in Ramallah the President of Palestine
sits and watches in horror the daily bloodbath of Iraq and says
we are not in danger from that reality. The Prime minister in
Gaza watches children murdered and his own party member executed
and says we are not in danger of civil war.
"Our country is not in
threat of civil war", Haniya said.
"Iraq is not in the middle
of a civil war." Malakiya has said. It is still suffering
the "birth pangs of democracy".
In every human's feelings there
looms the reality of the bloodshed in Iraq civil war, although
the phrase "civil war" seems to continue to stick on
the cuffs of academics who have helped by their inaction to orchestrate
this country's sorrow.
Let these people kill themselves in civil conflict that is
not yet civil war
Menawhile the people are dying,
the children, the fighters, the civilians who dare the market
places to buy food for their families
On the day when the three sons
were murdered in Gaza, the city of Ramallah, a Fatah stronghold,
erupted. People took to the streets and there was incessant gunfire.
Men roamed the main areas of
the city with their faces uncovered and their guns on show. A
shrine was set up at Al Minara in the center of the city to the
three boys. Gruesome photos of their little tortured bodies were
enlarged and on display every where and in fury I locked myself
inside my house.
How dare this tragedy be used for political ends? How dare Fatah
use this event to further its own attempts to overthrow the government
they have never wanted to accept?..
There was incessant talk of
war. All the PA security men were shining their guns ready to
use them against an enemy that cannot annihilate them with one
air strike.
And then I was also angry with
myself for blaming them for this show of frustration and for
their shooting in the air and for their chanting.
Is it a wonder at all that
they respond like this?
Is it a wonder that a people who have been totally repressed
and humiliated for decades start to seethe with the wish to fight
in such provoking circumstances?
Israel and in the past nine
months the rest of the Western World, have created this powder
keg of anger and hatred and yet continue to represent the situation
in terms that are both unfair and untruthful.
In fact there are so many untruths
in this conflict that it is hard to find even a half truth any
more.
Not only is there "no
threat of civil war", but there is actually supposed to
be a "cease-fire" in this region at the moment.
If you lived here you would
understand the exact opposite. There is no cease-fire and a very
real threat of civil war born from decades of this terribly unjust
occupation and nine months of economic strangulation.
While some of the root causes
of civil unrest are the same here as in Iraq there are also some
major differences that could as soon save this country as lead
to its destruction. The difference here to Iraq is that the line
between the opposing factions is purely political. There is no
blood involved. It is not family or tribe or religious affiliation.
It is political choice. But the problem in this, as the majority
of people here tell me, is that if a conflict were to escalate
it would not be contained to political factions but could end
up involving brother against brother because political support
is often diverse within the family itself.
And this type of infighting
is not possible even in Iraq.
"In my family alone"
a police officer told me "you have all three parties. I
am Fatah, my sister is Hamas and my father is DFLP. Of course
there will be many people who will withdraw their political support
if it comes to a war. But not all."
When I asked him if he would
fight he said "Of course."
And as for the cease-fire,
when I first heard news of it I wanted to write then to say to
the international community not to accept Israel's "chocolate
ration". Not to accept sentimentality in place of morality.
Not to accept.
The people of Gaza and the
West Bank beg you not to accept.
I didn't write, hoping that
the world would not accept. Why should they be grateful that
Israel withdrew to a border inside which they should never have
entered? Why should they be grateful that Israel is not killing
a family every single day instead of absolutely irreconciled
to the fact that they killed so many in their Beit Hanoun massacring?
But the trend continued in
this case as it has in the past.
Israel invaded and slaughtered
and the spectators gasped a little. Israel withdrew and "made
concessions toward a cease-fire" (concessions that were
"all on their side") and the international community
was pleased and relieved.
Big Brother reduced the
chocolate ration by 30 per cent and then gave an increase of
15 per cent and the people were grateful.
There has never been a cease-fire.
Not in Gaza and definitely not in the West Bank. For a full list
of casualties, of injuries of arrests and killings since the
cease-fire was proclaimed look at the Maannews agency which has
listed some 87 violations on the side of Israel since the cease-fire
was internationally applauded. I can not bear to rewrite them
all again.
But let me add just one point.
As I write news is coming through that the High Court of Israel
has overturned the case against targeted killings.
So assassinations are legal
again.
Every one knows how many victims targeted killings can leave
in their wake. If you live in Ramallah or have lived in Nablus
or Jenin you well know the degree of horror that a targeted killing
generates. You will never forget the sight of undercover Special
Forces walking down main streets and opening fire seemingly indiscriminately.
And the aftermath of these actions. The anger and sorrow. The
funeral and rallies. The poster added to the covered walls. These
are things you will never forget.
And these killings are now legalized.
And do not violate the cease-fire.
It is not easy here at present.
People you love, the city you love, the brothers you love, the
resisters and the students you love are all facing an absolute
abyss. An abyss created by a world that is learning to live in
fear instead of in hope. An abyss that no amount of hopeful imagination
seems to be able to find the bottom of, although this is a game
we sometimes indulge in. "Who can think of a solution"
"But please Eliza!"
a friend from Nablus confided one evening about two weeks ago.
"My problem is as deep and bottomless. The girl I love"
I smiled. No my dear friend! That abyss is not bottomless! And
I can help you find any amount of solutions as imaginative or
as realistic as you like! He was incredulous at my smiling. Listened
to my advice like a child and rang me just over an hour ago to
tell me that it worked! He hopes to be married within the year,"situation
permitting".
Love always finds a way! I am glad for him. His life has been
made tragic enough by this occupation; he has lost a brother
and an uncle in the armed resistance and has spent some years
in an Israeli prison himself, although he is only 23. I am glad
to know that he can still love. And that love creates hope in
the ruins of this country.
Hatred, swollen here by years of gorging on the atmosphere of
fear and lies, in the end only destroys.
But does it destroy itself as well along the way?
Or just everything that is in its path?
And must this include truth?
There is no such thing as
No such thing as no such thing.
There is no such thing as
bombing family homesno such thing as murdered civilians and broken
families and hatred and more hatred.
CounterPunch
Speakers Bureau Sick of sit-on-the-Fence speakers, tongue-tied and timid?
CounterPunch Editors Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair
are available to speak forcefully on ALL the burning issues,
as are other CounterPunchers seasoned in stump oratory. Call
CounterPunch Speakers Bureau, 1-800-840-3683. Or email beckyg@counterpunch.org.
