home / subscribe / about us / books / archives / search / links / feedback

Read Cockburn and St. Clair's Whiteout: the CIA, Drugs and the Press and discover how the CIA gave a helping hand to the opium lords who took over Afghanistan, thus ushering the Taliban into power.

New Print Edition of CounterPunch Available Exclusively to Subscribers: Colonel Martha McSally: Inspired by Rosa Parks, She Battles Washington's Grovelling to Saudi Wahabbites; How to Talk to FoxNews: the Abboud Way; Coup de Farce: Neolibs Gnash Teeth at Chavez Rebound; Cockburn's Road: Alabama to Texas; Pappy Bush's Favorite Joke; Southern Injustice. Remember, the CounterPunch website is supported exclusively by subscribers to our newsletter. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now!

May 3, 2002

Yigal Bronner
A Journey to Beit Jalla

CounterPunch Wire
Otto Reich Named to Board of School of the Americas

John Troyer
Hatemongers Try to Cleanse History: Gays and 9/11

John Stauber
Big Food/Tobacco/Booze
Attacks "Mad Cow" Authors

Kathleen Christison
Before There Was Terrorism

May 2, 2002

CounterPunch Wire
Rep. Dick Armey Calls for Ethnic Cleansing of Palestinians

Rami Kaplan
Israeli Soldiers Resisting
the Occupation:
Why We Refuse to Fight

Carol Norris
Subterranean Mini-Nuke Blues

Bernard Weiner
A Peek Inside Colin Powell's Personal Diary

May 1, 2002

Badiou, Michel, Lazarus
French Elections:
What is to be Done?

Baruch Kimmerling
The Battle of Jenin as
an Inter-Ethnic War

Edward Hammond
Hiding History:
NAS Suppresses Chem/Bio War Documents

Kristen Schurr
Inside Gaza

Sam Bahour
Corporate America and
the Israeli Occupation

Jacques Ranciere
Prisoners of the Infinite

April 30, 2002

Mike Leon
Chomsky, Letters to the Writer and the Peace Movement

Dave Marsh
The FBI and the Music
Industry: Paying the Cost to Feed the Boss

Steen Sohn
Something Rotten in Denmark:
New Danish Government's Alliance with Far Right

Desmond Tutu
Apartheid in the Holy Land

Christopher Reilly
Kissinger: the Wanted Man

April 29, 2002

Larry Hales
At the Church of the Nativity

Michael Colby
The Times Does Brockovich:
Ralph Nader with Cleavage?

CounterPunch Wire
Bank Robs Publisher,
Vows to Repeat

Gavin Keeney
So Long, Frank O. Gehry?

April 28, 2002

Michael Neumann
The Jewish Left and Palestine

April 27, 2002

Dr. Susan Block
Adelphia Going Down:
Cover Ups, Censorship
and Naughty Accounting

Jordy Cummings
Stuck Inside the Journalism School Pyramid

Jeffrey St. Clair
Set This Flag on Fire!

April 26, 2002

Tom Turnipseed
Act Now to Stop the Killing
of an Innocent Man

Mokhiber / Weissman
Anti-Bribery Law Takes a Hit

Tariq Ali
Letter to a Young Muslim

April 25, 2002

Francis A. Boyle
Home Brew? Biowarfare,
Terror Weapons and the US

Adam Federman
"And the Earth Wept"
Bush at Saranac Lake

Stanton and Madsen
US Media Interests:
Champions of Profit, Propaganda and Puffery

Aaron Hawley
Cop a Buzz Day in Vermont:
Education v. Incarceration

David Vest
Code Red: Politics and Wordplay at the Vatican

Bernard Weiner
Time Out! A Pause for Longer-Range Thinking

Rep. Dennis Kucinich
Standing with the Peace Movement

April 24, 2002

David Vest
State of Politics in France:
Code Bleu

Jean Fallow
A20 in Seattle:
Cops Get Rough, Again

Kevin Alexander Gray
Help Save the Life of an Innocent Man: Ask for Clemency for Ricky Johnson

Tanya Reinhart
Jenin, the Propaganda Battle

Todd May
Drowning Children, Palestinians and American Responsibility

Alexander Cockburn
The Loneliest Road

Nir Rosen
The Broken Home:
Revisiting Israel

Mokhiber / Weissman
A Big Blow to Big Tobacco

April 23, 2002

Brian Wood
Where Is the Aid for the Victims in Jenin?

John Chuckman
I, George:
Gomer as Claudius

Norman Madarasz
French Presidential Elections
Absenteeism and Le Pen

Dr. Susan Block
Bernard Parks, Goodbye:
A Farewell to My Chief

Joan Smith
Who Will Rid Us of
These Pedophile Priests?

April 22, 2002

CounterPunch Wire
EPA Ombudsman Resigns
in Protest

Dave Marsh
DeskScan: What's Playing
at My House This Week

Ron Jacobs
A20 in DC: Taking the
Message to the Beast's Belly

Kathy Kelly
An Open Letter to
Israeli Soldiers

Irit Katriel
Word Games and Body Bags

Rep. Cynthia McKinney
We Come for Peace

Daniel Bar-Tal
Is There a Way Out?
Occupation, Terror
and Understanding

David Wilson
A Week of Coups, But Now
The Freedom Train Hits Town

Shaik Ubaid
Today I Was a Palestinian

April 21, 2002

Michelle Campos
Suckered Again in Israel

Mike Leon
200,000 in DC Protest Say:
"We Are All Palestinians Today"

C.G. Estabrook
Sex and Power in Catholicism

Kathy Kelly
Gimme Some Truth Now
A Walk Through Jenin

Resources:
100s of Links About 9/11


CounterPunch:
Complete Coverage of 9/11 and Its Aftermath


Five Days That
Shook The World:
Seattle and Beyond

By Alexander Cockburn
and Jeffrey St. Clair
Photos by Allan Sekula

(Click Here to Order from CounterPunch Online at 20% Off Amazon.com's price!)

INSIDE

Subscribe Online!

EXCLUSIVE TO
COUNTERPUNCH
SUBSCRIBERS


Published March 15, 2002

  • Facing Down Rehnquist and Scalia:
  • Jennifer Harbury at the Supreme Court;
  • ADL Throws in Towel, Pays Up:
  • How They Worked for Apartheid Regime and Spied on NAACP:
  • Cockburn on America the Bully:
  • From Teddy Roosevelt to George W.
  • St. Clair on Musicians Against the Death Penalty & The Legacy of the Mekons.


    Search CounterPunch

Read Whiteout and Find Out How the CIA's Backing of the Mujahideen Created the World's Most Robust Heroin Market and Helped to Finance the Rise of the Taliban and Osama bin Laden

Whiteout:
CIA, Drugs & the Press

by Alexander Cockburn
and Jeffrey St. Clair

The New Crusade:
America's War on Terrorism

By Rahul Mahajan

The Memphis Blues Again:
Six Decades of Memphis Music Photographs
Photos by Ernest Withers
Text by Daniel Wolff

The New Intifada:
Resisting Israel's Apartheid

Edited by Roane Carey

 

A Pocket Guide to
Environmental Bad Guys
by James Ridgeway
and Jeffrey St. Clair

The Phoenix Program
by Douglas Valentine

Al Gore:
A User's Manual
by Cockburn
and St. Clair

Buy This Explosive
New Book at an
Amazing Discount!
 

Reviews of Gore:
a User's Manual


Private Warriors
by Ken Silverstein

CounterPunch's Booktalk

May 3, 2002

American Journal

Priests and Palestinians:
Extreme Solutions

by Alexander Cockburn

Extreme Solution 1: Priests

The old movies used to feature a priest walking alongside the condemned man towards the scaffold, offering last seconds of comfort, plea-bargaining strategies with St Peter, a bolstering hand under the elbow. Some time in the next decade the tableau may be reversed, with a lay counselor assisting the condemned priest as he totters towards that final rendez-vous with the executioner.

The death penalty is being vigorously touted as the best way to deal with child molesters. And as the world knows, the Roman Catholic Church has sheltered many a child molester. On the cutting edge here are three states noted for the moral refinement of their legislators: to wit, Montana, Louisiana and Alabama. The first two states have already put Death for Molesters into their statute books and when the legislators of Alabama convene again next year they will press forward into legislation from an overwhelming vote last year in favor molester executions from its House of Representatives.

The Montana law allows a person previously convicted of "sexual intercourse without consent" with a person younger than 16 in any state to be sentenced to death if convicted of that crime in Montana. The law was passed in 1997 but no one has yet been charged under that provision. Louisiana has had a law on the books since 1995 that allows people convicted of raping a child under the age of 12 to be sentenced to death. A handful of people in the state have been charged under the law this year alone, but no one has yet been convicted and sentenced to death

Alabama's bill, would authorize the death penalty for people convicted a second time of having sex with a child younger than 12. No other states have the death penalty for a sex crime. ABC News quoted Marcel Black, the chairman of the Alabama House Judiciary Committee as saying "The very serious meaning of this is to send a message to child molesters that it is a bad thing to do".

Molesters can take comfort in the fact that these laws would probably not survive challenges from higher courts. The US Supreme Court ruled in 1977 that the death penalty is excessive punishment for rape. But who knows, in the current atmosphere anything is possible. Maybe that's why Pope John Paul II, a far-seeing man, shifted the Church towards opposition to the death penalty.

Extreme Solution 2: Palestinians

Two years ago less than eight per cent of those who took part in a Gallup poll among Jewish Israelis said they were in favor of what is politely called "transfer" - that is, the expulsion of perhaps two million Palestinians across the River Jordan. This month that figure reached 44 per cent. This week the US Congress sent an explicit message: Make our day.

Professor Martin van Creveld is Israel's best known military historian. On April 28 Britain's conservative newspaper The Telegraph, published an article outlining what Van Creveld believes Sharon's near-term goal: "transfer", otherwise known as expulsion of the Palestinians.

According to Van Creveld, Sharon's plan is to drive two million Palestinians across the Jordan using the pretext of a US attack on Iraq or a terrorist strike in Israel. This could trigger a vast mobilization to clear the occupied territories of their two million Arabs. Van Creveld notes that In September 1970, Van Creveld recalls, King Hussein of Jordan attacked the Palestinians in his kingdom, killing perhaps 5,000 to 10,000. Sharon, serving as Commanding Officer, Southern Front, argued that Israel's assistance to the king was a mistake; instead it should have tried to topple the Hashemite regime. Sharon has often said since that Jordan, which, according to him, has a Palestinian majority even now, is the Palestinian state, and thus a suitable destination for Palestinians to be kicvked out of his Greater Israel.

Van Creveld writes that Sharon has always nourished the idea of driving all Palestinians out.A US attack on Iraq sometime this summer would over appropriate cover. Sharon himself told Secretary of State Colin Powell that nothing happening in Israel should delay a US attack on Iraq. Other pretexts could include an uprising in Jordan, followed by the collapse of King Abdullah's regime or a major terrorist outrage inside Israel.

Should such circumstances arise, according to Van Creveld, then Israel would mobilize within hours. "First, the country's three ultra-modern submarines would take up firing positions out at sea. Borders would be closed, a news blackout imposed, and all foreign journalists rounded up and confined to a hotel as guests of the Government. A force of 12 divisions, 11 of them armored, plus various territorial units suitable for occupation duties, would be deployed: five against Egypt, three against Syria, and one opposite Lebanon. This would leave three to face east as well as enough forces to put a tank inside every Arab-Israeli village just in case their populations get any funny ideas."

In Van Creveld's view (he does say flatly that he is utterly opposed to any form of "transfer"), "The expulsion of the Palestinians would require only a few brigades. They would not drag people out of their houses but use heavy artillery to drive them out; the damage caused to Jenin would look like a pinprick in comparison. He discounts any effective response from Egypt, Syrpia, Lebanon or Iraq. "Saddam Hussein may launch some of the 30 to 40 missiles he probably has. The damage they can do, however, is limited. Should Saddam be mad enough to resort to weapons of mass destruction, then Israel's response would be so 'awesome and terrible' (as Yitzhak Shamir, the former prime minister, once said) as to defy the imagination."

But what about international reaction? Van Creveld thinks it would not be an effective deterrent. "If Mr Sharon decides to go ahead, the only country that can stop him is the United States. The US, however, regards itself as being at war with parts of the Muslim world that have supported Osama bin Laden. America will not necessarily object to that world being taught a lesson - particularly if it could be as swift and brutal as the 1967 campaign; and also particularly if it does not disrupt the flow of oil for too long."

Israeli military experts estimate that such a war could be over in just eight days," Van Creveld writes."Ifthe Arab states do not intervene, it will end with the Palestinians expelled and Jordan in ruins. If they do intervene, the result will be the same, with the main Arab armies destroyed. Israel would, of course, take some casualties, especially in the north, where its population would come under fire from Hizbollah. However, their number would be limited and Israel would stand triumphant, as it did in 1948, 1956, 1967 and 1973."

And just as Sharon prepares this mostrous act of ethnic cleansing, the US Congress votes unqualified support for anything Israel might do. Here are the lonely dissenters.

Only 2 No votes in the US Senate:

Hollings
Byrd

21 No Votes in the House:

Abercrombie
Hilliard
Obey
Bonior
Inslee
Paul
Boucher
Jackson (IL)
Petri
Condit (We guess the outgoing congressman from Modesto now feels free to disclose his true feelings about the Levy family.)
Kleczka
Rahall
Conyers
Lee
Rohrabacher
DeFazio
McKinney
Smith (MI)
Dingell
Miller, George
Stark.

29 Wimpy "Present" Votes, meaning that persons of conscience like Dennis Kucinich (recently consecrated by Studs Terkel) or Marci Kaptur, also from Ohio, could not quite muster the moral fortitude to do the right thing. We guess there's no place for Palestinians in Kucinich's latest prayer.

Baldwin
Kaptur
Peterson (MN)
Barr
Kilpatrick
Rivers
Becerra
Kind (WI)
Sabo
Bishop
Kucinich
Sanders
Brown (OH)
McDermott
Solis
Capuano
Mink
Thompson (CA)
Clayton
Mollohan
Thurman
Farr
Moran (VA)
Watt (NC)
Hostettler
Oberstar
Woolsey
Jones (OH)
Payne.