home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events
![]() |
|
Get the Answer Only in CounterPunch's Print Edition US's top radical economist, Prof.Robert Pollin, gives CounterPunch newsletter subscribers exclusive briefing on the global casino and the dollar's future. Is neoliberalism still calling the shots? Is US now under Chinese rule? Move over, Kansas! Maybe Tom Frank got it wrong. Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz asks, What's the matter with Oklahoma? How did one state go from pro-worker to proto-fascist in a generation? It'll take a mutiny: Alexander Cockburn on how Cindy Sheehan and a radical movement can end the war. Get the answers you're looking for in the latest subscriber-only edition of CounterPunch ... CounterPunch Online is read by millions of viewers each month! But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation for the online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now! or write CounterPunch, PO BOX 228, Petrolia, CA 95558 |
|
September 19, 2005 Kathleen
and Bill Christison September 17 / 18, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Ralph
Nader Diane
Christian Ned
Sublette William
Cook Barbara
Ehrenreich Nikolas
Kozloff Dave
Lindorff Heather
Gray C.A.N. James
Petras Bill
Pahneles Jeff
Chapman Dave
Zirin Ron
Jacobs Fred
Gardner Peter
Harley Matthew
Koehler Ben
Tripp Poets'
Basement Website
of the Weekend
September 16, 2005 Ishmael
Reed J.L.
Chestnut, Jr. James
Petras Louis
Proyect Christopher
Brauchli Naomi
Archer Edward
Gibbon Francis
Boyle Paul
Craig Roberts
September 15, 2005 Jeffrey
St. Clair Brian
J. Foley Justin
E.H. Smith Dave
Lindorff Kevin
Zeese Jason
Leopold Todd
May Niranjan
Ramakrishnan Pat
Williams William
S. Lind Saul
Landau
September 14, 2005 Gary
Leupp Evelyn
Pringle Jordan
Flaherty Jeff
Chapman Ramzy
Baroud Manuel
Garcia, Jr. Mickey
Z. Sam
Husseini Ralph
Nader
September 13, 2005 Uri
Avnery Werther JG Marlene
Martin Joshua
Frank Ron
Jacobs Dave
Lindorff Ben
Tripp Dave
Zirin Billy
Sothern Website
of the Day
September 12, 2005 Bill
Glahn Jason
Leopold Bill
Simpich Mike
Whitney Justin
Felux Rep.
Cynthia McKinney Carol
Norris Robert
Jensen Gideon
Levy Paul
Craig Roberts Website
of the Day
September 9 / 11, 2005 William
A. Cook Saul
Landau Lance
Selfa Col.
Dan Smith Elaine
Cassel Ron
Jacobs Elisa
Salasin Christopher
Brauchli Evelyn
Pringle Tom
Crumpacker Dave
Lindorff Robert
Jensen Gary
Bass Dr.
Susan Block Steven
Sherman Col.
Douglas A. Macgregor Barghouti
/ Grima Jeff
Berg Fred
Gardner Charles
Sullivan Dan
Vojir Website
of the Weekend
John
Chuckman Dan
La Botz Carol
Norris David
Krieger Irma
Thomas Roger
Morris September 7, 2005 Roxanne
Dunbar-Ortiz Werther Chris
Floyd Jason
Leopold Michael
Donnelly Niranjan
Ramakrishnan Linda
Milazzo / John Stern Gary
Leupp Pierre
Tristam Kevin
Zeese Charmaine
Neville
September 6, 2005 Keeanga-Yamahtta
Taylor Dan
La Botz Larry
Bradshaw / Lorrie Beth Slonsky Chuck
D. Debbie
Dupre / Bill Quigley Omar
Wariach Mike
Whitney Carol
Norris Norman
Solomon Michael
Neumann
Paul
Craig Roberts David
Vest John
Blair Fidel
Castro Mike
Whitney Alan
Farago Doug
Giebel Mark
Chmiel Carol
Wolman, MD Norman
Solomon Eli
Stephens Peter
Linebaugh
September 3 / 4, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Paul
Craig Roberts Gary
Leupp Dave
Lindorff Dan
La Botz Jonathan
M. Feldman Landau
/ Hassen Tim
Wise Mitchel
Cohen Dave
Zirin Mike
Ferner Rep.
Cynthia McKinney Jason
Leopold Justin
Felux Monica
Benderman Ben
Tripp Jordan
Flaherty Bill
Pahnelas Seth
Sandronsky Mark
Donham Fred
Gardner Joshua
Frank Jackie
Corr Poets'
Basement
September 2, 2005 Evan
Jones David
Stocker Dave
Lindorff Norman
Solomon Mike
Whitney Eli
Stephens Ron
Jacobs Christopher
Brauchli Harvey
Wasserman CounterPunch
Wire Glen
Ford
September 1, 2005 Dr.
Greg Henderson, MD Paul
Craig Roberts Mike
Whitney Lee
Sustar Dave
Lindorff Lynn
Gonzalez Chris
Floyd
Cockburn
/ St. Clair John Walsh Bernstein /
Mishel Alan Farago Norman
Solomon Bryan
Newbury Jason
Leopold Website
of the Day
August 30, 2005 Gary
Leupp Joshua
Frank Evelyn
Pringle Urariano
Mota Ron
Jacobs CP
News Service Roger
Morris
August 29, 2005 Seth
Sandronsky Norman
Solomon Charles
Sullivan Paul
Craig Roberts Website
of the Day
Alexander
Cockburn Ricardo
Alarcon Diane
Christian M.
Shahid Alam Laith
al-Saud Diane
Farsetta Saul
Landau Tom
Barry Nicholas
Rowe George
E. Bisharat Dave
Lindorff Fred
Gardner John
Francis Lee Evan
Jones Ali
Khan Poets'
Basement August 26, 2005 Lee
Sustar Ramzy
Baroud Christopher
Brauchli Peter
Harley John
Snider Kathleen
Christison
August 25, 2005 Paul
Craig Roberts Cockburn
/ St. Clair J.L.
Chestnut, Jr. Chhandasi
Pandya Richard
Ward Norman
Solomon Joshua
Frank Seth
Sandronsky Lucinda
Marshall VIPS Ralph
Nader
August 24, 2005 Stan
Goff Rachard
Itani Elisa
Salasin Ron
Jacobs John
Chuckman Leibowitz
/ Heller Douglas
Valentine Thomas
Nagy Alexander
Cockburn Website
of the Day
August 23, 2005 Rev.
Graylan Scott Hagler Karen
Kilroy Stew
Albert Joshua
Frank Dave
Zirin Julia
Olmstead CounterPunch
Wire Jason
Leopold Diane
Christian
August 22, 2005 Sonia
Nettnin Mike
Whitney Kevin
Zeese Norman
Solomon Christopher
Brauchli Jeff
Bale Greg
Moses
August 20 / 21, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Saul
Landau Kevin
Zeese Greg
Moses Ray
McGovern Fred
Gardner Martin
Smith Benjamin
Granby Frankie
Lake Joshua
Frank Ron
Jacobs Tom
Crumpacker Mike
Ferner James
Petras Col.
Dan Smith Dr.
Teresa Whitehurst Ben
Tripp Poets'
Basement
August 19, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Neve
Gordon Gary
Leupp William
S. Lind Vijay
Prashad Dave
Lindorff Pat
Williams John
Pilger Elaine
Cassel
August 18, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Greg
Moses Ramzy
Baroud Joshua
Frank Monica
Benderman Paul
Craig Roberts
August 17, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Robert
Jensen Carl
G. Estabrook Mike
Whitney Niranjan
Ramakrishnan Norman
Solomon Dave
Zirin Jennifer
Loewenstein CounterPunch
August 16, 2005 Greg
Moses Thomas
Larson Diana
Barahona Dave
Lindorff Rep.
Cynthia McKinney Elisa
Salasin David
Krieger Alexander
Cockburn Website
of the Day
August 15, 2005 Greg
Moses Paul
Craig Roberts Mike
Whitney Robert
Jensen CounterPunch
Wire Norman
Solomon Kathleen
Christison
August 13 / 14, 2005 Cockburn
/ St. Clair William
Blum Gary
Leupp Jack
Z. Bratich Brian
Cloughley Ron
Jacobs John
Farley Dave
Lindorff Tim
Wise J.L.
Chestnut, Jr. John
Gershman Felice
Pace Fred
Gardner David
Krieger Roxanne
Dunbar-Ortiz Ben
Tripp Poets'
Basement
August 12, 2005 Christopher
Brauchli Greg
Moses Ramzy
Baroud Norman
Solomon Chris
Genovali Chris
Floyd Tariq
Ali
August 11, 2005 Saul
Landau Dave
Lindorff Ralph
Nader Talli
Nauman Gary
Leupp Sharon
Smith Paul
Craig Roberts
August 10, 2005 Tim
Wise Ron
Jacobs Joshua
Frank Cynthia
McKinney Rick
Wilhelm Stan
Goff
August 9, 2005 Mike
Ferner Monica
Benderman Mike
Marqusee Rep.
Cynthia McKinney Paul
Craig Roberts
August 6-8, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Jason
Leopold Ray
McGovern David
Krieger Sharon
K. Weiner / Robert Jensen Fred
Gardner
August 5, 2005 Bill
Christison Paul
Craig Roberts Alexander
Cockburn
August 4, 2005 Tom
Barry Lila
Rajiva Greg
Moses Alexander
Cockburn August 3, 2005
August 3, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn Paul
Craig Roberts William
A. Cook Dave
Zirin Dave
Lindorff José
Pertierra
August 2, 2005 Ramzi
Kysia William
A. Cook Paul
Craig Roberts Mike
Whitney Ron
Jacobs Norman
Madarsz Tim
Wise
August 1, 2005 Virginia
Rodino Diana
Barahona Joshua
Frank Mike
Whitney Norm
Dixon Norman
Solomon James
Petras
July 30 / 31, 2005 Alexander
Cockburn JoAnn
Wypijewski Sheldon
Rampton Jack
Z. Bratich Greg
Moses Jordan
Green Patrick
Cockburn Brian
Cloughley Justin
Taylor Saul
Landau John
Walsh Joshua
Frank Ron
Jacobs Fred
Gardner John
Chuckman Liaquat
Ali Khan Remi
Kanazi Naveen
Jaganathan Richard
Heinberg Max
Watts Ben
Tripp Poets'
Basement
July 29, 2005 Cockburn
/ St. Clair P.
Sainath Niranjan
Ramakrishnan Dave
Lindorff J.L.
Chestnut, Jr. Pat
Williams Norman
Solomon Sen.
Russ Feingold
July 28, 2005 Paul
Craig Roberts William
S. Lind Gilad
Atzmon Joshua
Frank Lila
Rajiva Amina
Mire Website
of the Day
July 27, 2005 Roger
Morris Gary
Leupp Paul
Craig Roberts Jackie
Corr Mike
Whitney Dave
Zirin Christopher
Bradley Norman
Solomon Website
of the Day
Subscribe Online
|
September 19, 2005 Travels in Palestine, Part OneHorror StoryBy KATHLEEN and BILL
CHRISTISON It all quickly comes together traveling through the West Bank: the separation wall encircling Anata; the verdant natural spring in the Israeli settlement of Anatot -- the spring, along with the mountains and wadis surrounding it and even the settlement's very name, all stolen from Palestinians by Israel and its settlers; the wall encroaching on the small, heroic village of Bil'in; the Israeli trash and garbage heaps that loom over Wadi Fuqin and other Palestinian villages, wherever there is a settlement under construction or expanding; the Israeli construction everywhere, everywhere, cutting through the land, destroying the land, building for Israelis, destroying what is Palestinian; the ecological devastation throughout the West Bank. You cannot travel around the West Bank for more than a day or two without seeing all of this, without knowing what it means, without knowing how Israel is committing a kind of slow ethnocide -- perhaps, over the longer term, even genocide -- against Palestinians. You cannot see the extent of this without wondering how it can ever be turned around. The village of Anata is as good a place as any to start. Just outside the Jerusalem city limits (in fact, in one of the many weird anomalies of the occupation, part of the town is inside the municipal limits, most of it outside), Anata's land once encompassed several thousand dunams, including a natural spring where villagers once gathered clean fresh water, some farmland where a wheat crop was grown, and tens of square miles of spectacular desert wilderness. The land now "belongs" to four Israeli settlements that encircle the town, including the tiny settlement of Anatot. All taken without so much as a by-your-leave. We set out in search of the
spring, an out-of-the-way spot known only to locals. After standing
on a hilltop above Anata to get a perspective on the town and
its surroundings -- its neighboring Palestinian refugee camp
of Shu'afat, the very large Israeli settlement of Pisgat Ze'ev
that sits on some of Anata's land, and the huge concrete wall
rapidly snaking its way in and out of these areas -- we come
down off the hill, crossing an area of now-fallow wheat fields,
and approach the guard post at the entrance We are allowed to drive in. A few twists and turns, and we come upon a makeshift toll booth at the top of a winding road that drops down precipitously to the wadi and the spring below. The scene ahead of us is the startlingly beautiful mountainscape of the Judean desert, fading in the distant haze into soft shades of blue. This toll booth is manned by a young settler woman, also armed. The charge for visiting the spring is 17 shekels per person, about $3.75. Before the occupation, before the settlement, there was no charge, this was free land, the life-giving waters of the spring available to everyone. Ahmad works a deal with the young Israeli woman. Telling her he doesn't want to pay for this, he gives her a 50-shekel note and tells her he would like it back if we return within fifteen minutes. He is very soft-spoken and charming, and she agrees. As we inch down the hairpin turns of the very narrow road, we pass a pipeline used to move spring water up to the settlement. A little way down, we pass a small cluster of stone houses clinging to the mountainside, all obviously Palestinian by their style. They are abandoned, their inhabitants forced out, Ahmad says. At the bottom we come to an oasis in the desert, a very green place with several tall trees and a small waterfall feeding some natural pools and a brook. This is Ain Fara, which leads farther east to Wadi Qelt. It is a place where, before the Israelis came, the people of Anata and other nearby villages used to come for water and where Ahmad used to hike as a teenager. Now it is Israel's, where Israelis go to swim and picnic, and where a settlement pipes the water out. Ten minutes later, having retrieved his 50 shekels at the toll booth, Ahmad gives his perspective on what is happening. It is a microcosm of what is happening throughout the West Bank. First, he says, they take the land, appropriating it for the settlement; then they take the water; then they kick out the Palestinians who live there on the mountainside; then they begin to charge a fee to visit. Those from Anata who once farmed some of this land can no longer get to their fields; those who once came here for water can no longer do so. Everyone from Anata has been barred from this land for years. And now, Israel is not merely keeping them out of their land but, with the wall, is enclosing them within the municipal area of the town, walling them into a ghetto. "They push them out, push them out, push them out, push them out," Ahmad intones, echoing the steady monotony of precisely the process of ethnic cleansing represented by Israel's absorption of the West Bank. Another Microcosm Bil'in is a heroic little village, only 1,800 strong, a rural agricultural village that few would ever have heard of had it not been for Israel's wall. Situated in a mountainous area just inside the West Bank, nine miles west of Ramallah, a mere ten miles as the crow flies east of Israel's Ben-Gurion International Airport, and literally in the shadow of the massive Israeli settlement of Modi'in Illit, which now houses 35,000 people and is planned to expand to 150,000 by 2020, Bil'in is fighting an uphill battle against Israel's encroachment. Because it is inconveniently close to Modi'in Illit, Bil'in has lost three-quarters of its agricultural land to the wall. Israel claims the wall will provide security for the settlement, but it is clear that Bil'in is being hemmed in, its land taken, in order to give Modi'in Illit even more room for expansion. Of Bil'in's original 4,200 dunams (slightly more than 1,000 acres), 3,000 have been confiscated and, because it is forbidden to use any land within 500 meters of the wall, another half of what is left to the village will be unusable. We sit in the shade of a pomegranate and some other fruit trees in the front yard of the mayor's house, drinking tea and talking about Bil'in. This is his "office"; there is no finely appointed municipal office in this tiny village. He has just come up the hill, hot and sweating, from helping build a new village school. His youngest child and some of his grandchildren are arriving home from school, still dressed in their school uniforms. Right now, there is only one school, for both boys and girls; the girls will get the new building. The mayor talks about what Bil'in has lost: hundreds of olive trees bulldozed or cut down and taken to Israel; other hundreds now inaccessible on the Israeli side of the wall (the mayor used to own some olive trees himself and sold the olives and the, oil but now he owns nothing but his house and has no way to make a living); cattle and sheep now with no land on which to graze; and, perhaps most important, no space anymore for a growing village to expand. The mayor has nine children and many grandchildren, and he wonders what the future will be like for the next generation when the village begins to burst at the seams without any place to grow. "We want the future for the kids," he says, obviously not hopeful. "We are people who want a future to live in peace. We don't want war and blood and killing." He believes it's the Israelis who want to kill. "Everyone says Palestinians are terrorists, criminals, killing the Jewish. But," he protests, "we are just sitting in our houses, in our village, and they come and attack us." Since February, when Israel started construction of the wall, Bil'in and its supporters among Palestinian activists, Israeli peace groups, and the International Solidarity Movement have staged protests at least weekly and sometimes more often, always non-violent but encountering violence at increasing levels from Israeli military and police. Palestinian boys have begun with increasing frequency to throw stones at Israeli soldiers, but this is unusually only in response to Israeli shooting. Every Friday in September has seen a step-up in harsh measures by the Israelis -- rubber-coated bullets, bullets made of some compacted substance like salt or sand that adheres to the skin, teargas, arrests, beatings, a total curfew on the village, total closure of the road leading to the village -- and every Friday a step-up in anti-wall protests. When a massive show of Israeli military force on the first Friday stopped a small group of protesters, organizers gathered several hundred for the next week's demonstration. When the road was completely closed off on that second Friday, over 200 mostly Israeli protesters walked miles across rocky, mountainous terrain, bypassing the soldiers and sneaking into the village from another direction, joining some international activists and the Palestinians already there. When direct confrontation with soldiers seemed futile, the forces of peace turned to music. In the days preceding the third Friday's protest, organizers took a piano to Bil'in, placing it in the spot where bulldozers work on the wall, and a Dutch pianist, a Holocaust survivor who lived in Israel in his twenties but left because he felt Israel was becoming too nationalistic and militaristic, gave a concert on Friday at noon. Others also played the piano and guitars. Having ourselves failed to get in to the village on the second Friday, we try the next week. The Israelis are letting some people in this time, mostly Palestinians and anyone with a press pass. We go with a Japanese journalist, hoping to be allowed in on the basis of his pass. No such luck. Our friend Ahmad drops us off at the Israeli checkpoint outside town and takes the journalist into town. No amount of arguing with the young Israeli soldier who commands the eight soldiers and police at this checkpoint does any good. It's a "closed military zone," he says, and we cannot go in because there's a protest demonstration there. Ahmad, who comes back for a while to keep us company, tells him we simply want to watch, not to take part in the protest -- a slight lie -- but that does no good. Bill gets angry, telling the soldier that some day U.S. aid for this Israeli crap is going to stop and reminding him that we pay his salary, but this does no good either. The soldier is a child, but he has learned the power of helplessness: he just shrugs, tells us he is only following orders and doesn't even know the person who gave the orders. It's an old story. We stand around in the sun for two hours, watching as the Israelis stop every passing car, turning most back but allowing some to pass after a period of negotiation. We are kept company for a while by a group of five Israeli women from an organization called Machsom (Checkpoint) Watch who have no press passes but are allowed in after an hour's wait. For quite a long time, we are watched by a tiny lizard, no more than two inches long, who suns himself and keeps watch curiously on a nearby rock. After nearly two hours, it gets momentarily more exciting. The Israeli soldiers begin to shout and scurry around, and we look upward to see a group of about a dozen Palestinian boys on a ridge above us throwing stones at the Israelis. They are far enough away that few of their stones hit their mark, but a couple boink off the top of the small Israeli personnel carrier or land on the ground nearby. The Israelis, who have been casually lounging around, all don helmets and pick up their rifles. One aims at the kids above but doesn't fire. As many pile into the vehicle as can fit, and the others walk along on the protected side as the jeep slowly begins to drive down the mountain road to the next curve, out of range of the stone-throwers. It's fun to watch them retreat, although only momentarily satisfying. A minute later, Ahmad returns with the Japanese journalist, who has his story and has to return to Jerusalem to file it. We realize that, with the soldiers now downhill of us, there is no checkpoint between us and Bil'in and that we could probably drive right in, but we don't try. Enough is enough, which is exactly what the Israelis want. Earlier, at our meeting with the mayor, he has urged us to get the word out about what Bil'in is enduring. "You will help me if you write a good word about Bil'in and what we are suffering from the Jewish," he pleads. Bil'in is being squeezed, losing its livelihood, losing its future. "Where is the future for this child?" he wonders, pointing to his youngest son, a boy of about eleven. We have no answer for him. The protests are inspiring, a powerful symbol of Palestinians helping other Palestinians, of Israelis helping Palestinians, of internationals helping Palestinians. But the mainstream international media ignore the protests, ignore the plight of Bil'in and all the other Bil'ins throughout Palestine (the Japanese journalist tells us he has seen several American journalists throughout the protests but no one from large papers like the New York Times or the Washington Post, no one from CNN, and no one from other television networks). And the bulldozers keep on going. Israel's Shame And this is exactly the point. The bulldozers keep on going, for Israel is trying to destroy the future for the mayor's eleven-year-old son, to destroy the future for Palestine. Israel wants to squeeze Bil'in until it expires, without any agricultural capability anymore, without a place for its livestock to graze, without a place for its people to grow. All so that Israel can create room for Israeli Jews to spread across the land. Anywhere else in the world, this would be widely known for what it is -- racism, dispossession, ethnic cleansing. Ha'aretz correspondent Gideon Levy recently said it outright: this pogrom against the Palestinians is the shame of Israel. Levy was writing of Hebron, where 450 malicious Israeli settlers, backed up by hundreds of Israeli soldiers and the full power of the Israeli state, harass and intimidate, physically attack, throw slop on, and steal from 150,000 Palestinians, but what he says applies to Israel's actions throughout the West Bank. Hebron is the worst but by no means the only horror in Israel's long catalog of horrors. Each day that the pogrom in Hebron continues, Levy wrote, "is another day of shame for the State of Israel" -- a day in which "Israel cannot be considered a state ruled by law, or a democracy." But theft is theft, pogroms are pogroms, and if the pogroms in Anata and Bil'in are "better" than the atrocities taking place in Hebron, they are only marginally so. Kathleen Christison is a former CIA political analyst and has worked on Middle East issues for 30 years. She is the author of Perceptions of Palestine and The Wound of Dispossession. She can be reached at: christison@counterpunch.org Bill Christison was a senior official of the CIA.
He served as a National Intelligence Officer and as Director
of the CIA's Office of Regional and Political Analysis. He is
a contributor to Imperial
Crusades, CounterPunch's history of the wars on Iraq and
Afghanistan. They can be reached at christison@counterpunch.org.
ALEXANDER COCKBURN, JEFFREY ST CLAIR, BECKY GRANT AND THE INSTITUTE FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF JOURNALISTIC CLARITY, COUNTERPUNCH We published an article entitled "A Saudiless Arabia" by Wayne Madsen dated October 22, 2002 (the "Article"), on the website of the Institute for the Advancement of Journalistic Clarity, CounterPunch, www.counterpunch.org (the "Website"). Although it was not our intention, counsel for Mohammed Hussein Al Amoudi has advised us the Article suggests, or could be read as suggesting, that Mr Al Amoudi has funded, supported, or is in some way associated with, the terrorist activities of Osama bin Laden and the Al Qaeda terrorist network. We do not have any evidence connecting Mr Al Amoudi with terrorism. As a result of an exchange of communications with Mr Al Amoudi's lawyers, we have removed the Article from the Website. We are pleased to clarify the position. August 17, 2005
|
from CounterPunch Books! The Case Against Israel By Michael Neumann ![]() Grand Theft Pentagon: Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror by Jeffrey St. Clair ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
![]()
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |