home / subscribe / donate / tower / books / archives / search / links / feedback / events / faq

What You're Missing in Our Subscriber-only CounterPunch Newsletter Special Investigation: Why Did the World Trade Towers Fall? A scientific explanation at last, from a physicist and mechanical engineer. P. Sainath recalls Gandhi's 9/11, one hundred years ago; Chris Sands reports from Afghanistan on the rise of the Taliban. What you just missed, but can still get, in our last newsletter: Paul Craig Roberts on the Collapse of America. CounterPunch Online is read by millions of viewers each month! But remember, we are funded solely by the subscribers to the print edition of CounterPunch. Please support this website by buying a subscription to our newsletter, which contains fresh material you won't find anywhere else, or by making a donation towards the cost of this online edition. Remember contributions are tax-deductible. Click here to make a donation. If you find our site useful please: Subscribe Now! Get CounterPunch By Email for Only $35 a Year Josh Frank and Howie Hawkins in Rochester

Today's Stories October 5, 2006 Uri Avnery Peace with Syria: Lunch in Damascus October 4, 2006 Elizabeth Terzakis The Walls That Racism Built: Blood Revenge, the Death Penalty and Kevin Cooper Paul Wolf The Mushy Rebellion: Pakistan Under Musharraf Sean Penn The Arrogant, the Misguided and the Cowards Dave Lindorff Outrage as Misdirection: The Real Scandal isn't Foley Diane Farsetta For Sale: Iraqi Kurdistan Sharon Smith Democrats: Yes to War, No to Pedophilia Felice Pace Revoking 1776 Sara Roy The Economy of Gaza Website of the Day Alexander Cockburn: the Video Interview (Part Two) October 3, 2006 Jennifer Van Bergen Compassionate Conservative Pedophiles Greg Moses The Infallible Empire: Junking Habeas Corpus Stan Cox Real Bad ID: a National Driver's License and the Fading Right of Anonymity Niranjan Ramakrishnan How Empires Die Evelyn Pringle Big Pharma Takes a Hit: Alaska's Supreme Court Outlaws Forced Drugging Fred Wilhelms SoundExchange and Unpaid Music Artists: Help Us Find These Musicians and Get Them Paid! Michael Abelman Know Your Farmer, Know Your Food: the Risks of Convenience and Consolidation Gary Leupp The Foley Follies Website of the Day Bush and Blair: Endless Love   October 2, 2006 Eric Hazan Roadmap to Nowhere: an Interview with Tanya Reinhart on Israel/Palestine Since 2003 Mike Whitney Bloodbath on 60 Minutes: Court Stenographer Finally Comes Clean Norman Solomon American Narcissism and Iraq Assaf Kfoury Meeting Nasrallah Missy Beattie The Meaning of "ummmm": Speaker Hasert and the Over-Friendly Congressman Arthur Neslen Lie Less in Gaza Paula J. Caplan How the Supreme Court Mangled My Research Website of the Day Predator Drones Target Bechtel   Sept. 30 / 0ct. 1, 2006 Weekend Edition Paul Craig Roberts The New Face of Class War Marjorie Cohn Rounding Up US Citizens: a Consitutional Shredding Ben Tripp Deviant Conservative Males: an Analysis Ron Jacobs A Dismal and Chaotic Place: Iraq According to Patrick Cockburn Ralph Nader Torturer-in-Chief Mike Whitney Iraq: The Breaking Point Christopher Reed It Pays to Raise a Ruckus Seth Sandronsky The Housing Bust: Excess Investment and Its Discontents Fred Gardner The Chancellor's Wife Mokhiber / Weissman Hewlett Packard and the Erosion of Privacy Michael Dickinson My Escape Attempt from Prison Transfer: Extract from a Diary in Turkish Police Custody Alan Gregory Fake Green: Top 10 Ways Politicians Pretend to be Environmentalists Poets' Basement Gardner, Landau, Lindorff, Davies,& Buknatski     September 29, 2006 Bruce Jackson Chavez's Reading, Bush's Reading Michael J. Smith The Lobby Debate Does Manhattan Emira Woods Oil Trip: Record Profits for Exxon, Deprivation for Africa William S. Lind The Sanctuary Illusion: Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iraq as Theme Parks for 4GW David Swanson Mommy, What's Waterboarding? Jonathan Cook Bad Faith and the Destruction of Palestine Website of the Day Jesus: the Recruitment Tapes September 28, 2006 Sen. Russ Feingold The Flaws in the Military Commissions Act Ron Jacobs The Generals, the Democrats and Iraq: One Policy, Two Parties Mokhiber / Weissman Scenes from Laura's Book Festival: Elmo Will Not Save You Lee Sustar A Left Challenge to Lula Robert Jensen Finding My Way Back to Church--and Getting Kicked Out John Chuckman America Has Just Lost Two More Wars Evelyn Pringle Inside America's Nursing Homes: a Hidden Tragedy of Neglect and Abuse Nicola Nasser Bush and Islam: Words vs. Deeds Uri Avnery Political Corruption in Israel Website of the Day Art Against the Empire September 27, 2006 Patrick Cockburn A Final Explosion Looms in Mosul Camilo Mejia Blowback From Iraq: Giving Terrorism a Reason to Exist Pat Williams Tax Burdens and Cheaters in the Rockies: Send Those IRS Mercenaries in Search of Montana's Land Barons and Oil Drillers Ben Terrall Failing Haiti: Another Bungled UN Mission Ridgeway / Ng Paul Weyrich Explaines His Opposition to the Patriot Act: a Short Film Joe Allen Where are the Mass Protests? Andrew Wimmer Don't Disappear Into a Black Hole Franklin C. Spinney Rumsfeld's AutoCarterization: Skullduggery in the Pentagon's Budget Website of the Day Model Nukes: the Photo Contest September 26, 2006 Hani Shukrallah The American Mind: When Historical Analysis is Reduced to Whim William Blum If It's Election Season, It Must Be Time for a Terror Alert Niranjan Ramakrishnan Torturing the Obvious Barbara Becnel Witness to an Execution: a Slow and Very Painful Death Paul Rockwell Judicial Complicity in US War Crimes: the Watada Case Dave Lindorff Bush and Iran: Going to War to Save His Own Ass? Rich Gibson Lessons from the Detroit Teachers' Strike Anthony Papa The Danger of Meth Registries: "Have a Cold? Prove It, Then Sign Here" Nate Mezmer New Orleans is Back ... Without Blacks: Monday Night Football at the Superdome Uri Avnery Mohammed's Sword Website of the Day Only YOU Can Stop the Sale of Public Lands to Mining, Timber and Real Estate Corporations September 25, 2006 Patrick Cockburn The Most Dangerous Place in the World: a Journey to Iraq's "Taliban Republic" Jonathan Cook Human Rights Watch: Still Missing the Point on Lebanon Joshua Frank Did Maria Cantwell's Campaign Try to Buy Off Aaron Dixon? Paul Craig Roberts Is the Bush Administration Itching to Nuke Iran? Robert Jensen Defending Chavez on FoxNews Dave Lindorff Horowitz on Campus: This Mouth for Hire Norman Solomon Media Tall Tales for Next War Dr. Charles Jonkel Save a Grizzly, Visit a Library: "People like the Croc Hunter are Worse Than the Most Bloodthirsty Slob Hunter Michael Dickinson "The King's New Clothes:" a Play Written in a Turkish Jail Alexander Cockburn Flying Saucers and the Decline of the Left Website of the Day Great Bear Foundation   September 23 / 24, 2006 Weekend Edition Jonathan Cook How Israel is Engineering the "Clash of Civilizations" Jeffrey St. Clair Star Wars Goes Online ... Crashes Dr. Anon A Doctor's Life in Baghdad Tom Barry Oil and Political Opportunism Carl G. Estabrook The Darfur Smokescreen Laura Carlsen Mexico's Two Presidents Todd Chretien The Axis of Lesser Evilism Dr. Charles Jonkel From Grizzly Man to the Croc Hunter: the Global Media and the Death of Bears Debbie Nathan I Was Disappeared By Salon Fred Gardner Dustin Costa Struggles Against Invisibility Fred Wilhelms The Money Belongs to the Artists Who Created the Music Seth Sandronsky The Cruel Economics of Health Care in America Ralph Nader Mavericks at Work Rev. William Alberts "Specks" and "Logs" and 9/11 Jon Van Camp Who is Hezbollah? Heather Gray Conservatives and Technology David Vest Jerry Lightfoot, RIP Jeffrey St. Clair Playlist: What I'm Listenting to This Week Poets' Basement Landau / Davies Website of the Weekend Meet Me In The Morning: C. Wonderland & J. Lightfoot Video of the Weekend Is It a Bird? A Missile? Or, Just Perhaps, a Friggin' Plane?   September 22, 2006 Patrick Cockburn Republic of Fear: Torture in Bush's Iraq, Worse Than Under Saddam Michael Donnelly It's the Manipulated Economy, Stupid! Ramzy Baroud The Next Palestinian Struggle Evo Morales "We Need Partners, Not Bosses": Address to the United Nations Stanley Howard Torture and Justice in Chicago Sarah Leah Whitson Hezbollah's Rockets and Civilian Casualties: a Reply to Jonathan Cook JoAnn Wypijewski Conservations at Ground Zero Website of the Day Cockburn in Atlanta: the Video Interview September 21, 2006 Mahmoud Ahmadi-Nejad "No Nation Should Have Superiority Over Others:" UN Address Justin E. H. Smith Ending the Death Penalty: Outline of an Abolitionist Program Rick Kuhn Australian Government Steps Up Attacks on Muslims: "I Certainly Don't Want That Type of People in Australia" Mike Roselle Ed Wiley's Long March: the Elementary School vs. the Strip Mine Amira Hass In the Name of Security: What Israeli Police Files Reveal About the Occupation of Palestine Deborah Rich From the Kitchen of Dr. Frankenstein: the Consumption of Gene-Engineeered Foods Mickey Z. 10 Reasons Cars Suck Saul Landau Terrorism at Sheridan Circle Website of the Day Stop the Decapitation of Mountains! September 20, 2006 Sharon Smith Elections, Detentions and Deportations Christopher Reed Goodbye Koizumi, Hello Abe John Ross Mexico: Does AMLO Have a Future? Joshua Frank A Wasted Campaign: How Jonathan Tasini Helped Hillary Clinton and Distracted the Antiwar Movement Arthur Neslen The Clenched Fist of the Phoenix: What Made Israel Burn Lebanon, Again? Norman Solomon The Hollow Promise of Digital Technology Michael Carmichael The Vatican's Tyrant Evelyn Pringle The Merck Vioxx Litigation: a Scorecard Hugo Chavez Rise Up Against the Empire: Address to the United Nations Website of the Day Before You Enlist: Watch This Video! September 19, 2006 Patrick Cockburn Deadly Harvest: Lebanese Fields Sown with Israeli Cluster Bombs Jeff Leys Economic Warfare: Iraq and the IMF Brian M. Downing War, Taxes and Democracy Col. Dan Smith Dispelling Brutality Liaquat Ali Khan Presidential Incitements: Did Bush's Speech Violate Geneva Conventions on Genocide? Ron Jacobs Just Sign on the Dotted Line: Iraqi Oil and Production Sharing Agreements Nik Barry-Shaw / Yves Engler Canada in Haiti: Torture, Murder and Complicity Lucinda Marshall Air Paranoia: the Great Toothpaste and Hair Gel Scare Saul Landau The Pinochet Syndicate Photo of the Day Hold That Bridge! Website of the Day Scenarios for an Iranian War September 18, 2006 Carl Boggs Crimes of Empire Uri Avnery Peace Panic Mike Stark / Jim Bullington Ann Richards, the Original Texacutioner Joshua Frank Corporate E. Coli John Murphy The Price of Free Speech Ramzy Baroud Murdoch Almighty Dave Lindorff On Constitution Day Bill Quigley Showing Conviction at Echo 9 Website of the Day Tutorial: How to Hack a Diebold Voting Machine   September 16 / 17, 2006 Weekend Edition Tariq Ali A Bavarian Provocation Eliza Ernshire Death and Tears in Nablus Jeffrey St. Clair The Remaking of Cataract Canyon (Part 7): To Tilted Park Mairead Corrigan Maguire A Nobel Laureate Visits with Israeli Nuclear Whistleblower Mordechai Vanunu Brian Cloughley "Let Them Drink Coke!": Losing Hearts and Minds in Afghanistan Ben Tripp November Prognostication: Republicans Sweep! Laura Carlsen Bush and Latin America: War on Terrorism or Fight for Social Justice Ralph Nader Terror on the Road Ron Jacobs Shooting Sgrena John Chuckman Imperial Entropy Robert Fisk The American Military's Cult of Cruelty Gary Leupp The Pope's New Crusade: Defender of the West, Scourge of Islam Lawrence R. Velvel The Pretexter in Chief: Learning About Bush from Hewlett-Packard Missy Comley Beattie The Insecurity of Immorality Adrienne Johnstone Deporting Widows: the Nightmare of a Kenyan Immigrant Mickey Z. Why I Hate America Jeffrey St. Clair Playlist: What I'm Listening to This Week Poets' Basement Kearney, Orloski, Engel, Louise and Davies Website of the Weekend Still Life with Killpecker September 15, 2006 Diana Johnstone In Defense of Conspiracy: 9/11, in Theory and in Fact Diane Christian On Retaliation William S. Lind General Puffery: When the Military Brass Deceives Lee Sustar Bosses Take Aim at Undocument Workers Dave Lindorff Retroactive Immunity for Bush? Ramzy Baroud Presidential PR: Lost in the Bush Spin Cycle Mokhiber / Weissman The Cesspool Jeffrey St. Clair Glow, River, Glow: Radioactive Leaks and Plumbers at Hanford Website of the Day F-22: The Most Expensive Piece of Junk Ever Built? September 14, 2006 Franklin Lamb Israel's Use of American Cluster Bombs: a Walk Through the Rubble Tim Wilkinson Alan Dershowitz's Sinister Scheme Dick J. Reavis Mexico's Time of Troubles: Who Benefits? Sam Husseini 9/11 Five Years Later: a Conspiracy to Silence Doug Giebel Democracies of Death: Why John Adams Wouldn't Recognize His Own Country Bill Berkowitz The Messaging Strategy of the Iraq War Diane Farsetta What Media Democracy Looks Like Mary Turck Targeting Refugees and Human Rights Workers in Colombia Patrick Cockburn Amnesty Intl Accuses Hizbollah of War Crimes, But Katyusha Damage "Much Less" Than Israel Claimed J.L. Chestnut, Jr. Ah, Do You Know What It Means to Miss New Orleans? Website of the Day The Shocking Truth About Inequality September 13, 2006 Jack Bratich Eyes Put a Spell on You: Signs of Surveillance in the Public Secret Sphere John Ross Welcome to the Nightmare: Al Qaeda de Mexico? Christopher Brauchli "You Had to Have Been There": Teaching Iraq and Iran Dave Lindorff Mourning in America: Bush Weeps? Who are They Kidding? Antony Loewenstein My Israel Question Al Krebs The Gates Foundation and African Agriculture Leonard Peltier Crazy Horse in Chains Jim Bensman My Adventures with the FBI: How I Was Targeted as a Terrorist Website of the Day FreedomWalk: Take a Moment for Leonard Peltier September 12, 2006 Norman Finkelstein Kill Arabs, Cry Anti-Semitism Seth Sandronsky The War on Nurses John Walsh Khatami Comes to Harvard Alan Maass "Islamic Fascism": the New Hysteria David Krieger Troubling Questions About Missile Defense Nate Mezmer September 12th, America Kathleen Christison The Coming Collapse of Zionism September 11, 2006 Uri Avnery State of Chutzpah Patrick Cockburn Palestinians Forced to Scavenge Rubbish Dumps for Food Col Dan Smith The Centrality of War in the Presidency of George W. Bush Dr. Susan Block Beyond Terror Anthony Alessandrini Forgetting 9/11 Dave Lindorff Bush After 9/11: Five Years of High Crimes and Misdemeanors Niranjan Ramakrishnan What Happened? Joshua Frank Proving Nothing: How the 9/11 "Truth" Movement Helps Bush & Cheney Jean Bricmont The End of the "End of History" Sprague / Emesberger "You Are a Dog. You Should Die": Death Threats Against Lancet's Haiti Investigator Website of the Day Web Piracy   September 9/10, 2006 Weekend Edition Alexander Cockburn The 9/11 Conspiracy Nuts: How They Let the Guilty Parties of 9/11 Off the Hook Jeffrey St. Clair The Remaking of Cataract Canyon: In the Footsteps of Vladimir Putin (Part Six) Greg Grandin Good Christ, Bad Christ: Testament of the Death Squads Peter Stone Brown Bob Dylan's Swing Time Waltz in the Face of the Apocalypse Ralph Nader X-Raying Greed Brian Cloughley Rumsfeld at the American Legion: Dead Babies and Nazi Propaganda Col. Chet Richards Crossroads at the Litani David Model Tailoring the Case Against Iran: Cut from the Same Old Pattern Dave Himmelstein From Bil'in to Birmingham Ron Jacobs War and the Power of Words Fred Gardner Is Medical Pot Image a Turn-Off to Teens? Mike Whitney America's Economic Meltdown Josh Gryniewicz In the Belly of the Bentonville Beast: Working for Wal-Mart Daniel Gross / Joe Tessone An IWW Story at Starbucks Joe Bageant Inside the Iron Theater Nicole Colson The Colbert Factor: Some Truthiness, At Last Alexander Billet Thirty Years of "White Riot": Long Live The Clash! Poets' Basement Engel, Louise, Buknatski, Davies, & Orloski   September 8, 2006 Uri Avnery "I'm a Leftist, But ...": the Liberals' War on Lebanon Paul Craig Roberts Books Are Our Salvation Bill Quigley Judge Says: "No Clowning Around Our WMDs!" Robert Jensen Parallel Purges: Academic Freedom in Iran and the US Norman Solomon Perception Gap: The War on Terror as Others See It Keith Bolin   September 8, 2006 Uri Avnery "I'm a Leftist, But ...": the Liberals' War on Lebanon Paul Craig Roberts Books Are Our Salvation Bill Quigley Judge Says: "No Clowning Around Our WMDs!" Robert Jensen Parallel Purges: Academic Freedom in Iran and the US Norman Solomon Perception Gap: The War on Terror as Others See It Keith Bolin The Future of the Family Farm Kristin S. Schafer The Global Trade in Deadly Pesticides Jeffrey St. Clair The Remaking of Cataract Canyon (Part Five) Patrick Cockburn Gaza is Dying Website of the Day Help the Bismark 3! September 7, 206 Marjorie Cohn Why Bush Really Came Clean About the CIA's Secret Torture Prisons Sharon Smith Downward Mobility: No Recovery for Workers René Drucker Colín The Fraud in Mexico Michael Donnelly Bush Family Values: About Those Nazi Appeasers John Borowski Scholastic Peddles a Fictitious Path to 9/11 to Kids Lucinda Marshall Bombing Indiana Charles Sullivan Katrina and the New Jim Crow: Ethnic Cleansing in New Orleans Jeffrey St. Clair The Remaking of Cataract Canyon: Part Four Jonathan Cook How Human Rights Watch Lost Its Way in Lebanon Website of the Day Rasta! Reggae's Joe Hill   September 6, 2006 Stephen Soldz Protecting the Torturers: Bad Faith and Distortions frm the American Psychological Assocation Dave Zirin Cops vs. Jocks: the Shooting of Steve Foley Ramzy Baroud The Gaza Maze: Who Gained Most from the Fox Reporters' Kidnapping Noel Ignatiev Democrats, Pwogs and the Lesser Evil Folly Dave Lindorff Bombing Without Regrets: The US and Cluster Bombs Norman Solomon Spinning Troop Levels in Iraq Binoy Kampmark The Death of Steve Irwin and the Politics of the Zoo Jeffrey St. Clair A Premature Burial: the Remaking of Cataract Canyon (Part Three) John Ross The Death of Mexican Presidency Website of the Day Flaming Arrows   September 5, 2006 Jonathan Cook Will Robert Fisk tell us the whole story? Time For A Champion of Truth to Speak Up Patrick Cockburn Better Not Meet at the Casbah Mike Whitney The Worst Secretary of Defense in U.S. History? You Be the Judge Roland Sheppard The Civil Rights Movement is Dead and So is the Democratic Party James Petras As Bush Regime Faces Twilight Slide, How Much Havoc Can Paulson Wreak? Alexander Cockburn Will Bush Bomb Teheran?   September 4, 2006 Clancy Sigal The Women Who Gave Us Labor Day Jeffrey St. Clair The Remaking of Cataract Canyon: Part 2 Anthony Alessandrini The Great Debate about Aroma Coffee: Why I Boycott Dennis Perrin The Great Debate in Tarrytown: Straight Zion, No Chaser Daniel Cassidy 'S lom to Slum Paul Craig Roberts The War Is Lost   September 2 / 3, 2006 Uri Avnery When Napoleon Won at Waterloo Jeffrey St. Clair A Premature Burial: the Remaking of Cataract Canyon Ralph Nader The No-Fault White House Noam Chomsky Viewing the World from a Bombsight Allan Lichtman Arrested Democracy: Letter from the Baltimore County Jail Stanley Heller When Criticism of Cluster Bombs is "Anti-Semitic" Rana el-Khatib Invasion's Child: the Making of Issa Peter Montague Taking on the Pentagon: Chemical Weapons to Burn Laura Carlsen Mexico on a Collision Course Dr. Susan Block Bush Hate Rising Joe Bageant Roy's People: Why Progressives Need to Listen to Orbison, Not Policy Wonks Scott Stedjan / Matt Schaaf A New Generation of Landmines? Gary Leupp The Emperor Has Been Exposed Stephen Fleischman The Great American Oligarchy Paul Balles Has Ahmadinejad Already Checkmated Bush? Ingmar Lee Canada's $450 Million Gift to Bush: the Softwood Lumber Slush Fund Jane Stillwater Burning Man: the Good, the Bad and the Evil Twin Ron Jacobs Dylan Faces the Apocalypse, Again St. Clair / Bossert Playlist: What We're Listening to This Week Poets' Basement Grima, Engel, Orloski and Davies Website of the Weekend To New Orleans: a Photo Journal   September 1, 2006 Uri Avnery Olmert Agonistes Paul Craig Roberts Of Wolves and Men (and Impotent Democrats) Bill Ayers Exclusionary Signs of the Times Kevin Zeese The Best War Ever Xochitl Bervera The Forgotten Children of New Orleans Norman Solomon Bush vs. Ahmadinejad: a TV Debate We'll Never See Alexander Cockburn Hezbollah Denounces Nasrallah Interview as a Fake Richard Neville Rupert Murdoch's Victims Website of the Day The Uranium Flood             Subscribe Online

October 5, 2006 Waterboarding the Constitution After Torture, What's Next? By JAMES ABOUREZK So, waterboarding is now OK. So is the suspension of one of our basic rights of freedom-the Writ of Habeas Corpus. Habeas Corpus, according to the U.S. Constitution, can only be suspended in cases of invasion or rebellion. Our Supreme Court has held, "habeas corpus is the fundamental instrument for safeguarding individual freedom against arbitrary and lawless state action." Abe Lincoln suspended the Writ during the Civil War, and even then it was a questionable act. And even more hopeless is that part of the law that permits President George W. Bush to interpret Common Article Three of the 1949 Geneva Conventions. Although Mr. Bush claims that the article is vague, no one before him has had any trouble understanding that torture is wrong, and in violation of international law. But the suspension of the Writ in 2006 is not only unconstitutional because there is neither a rebellion nor have we been invaded. It is flat out wrong. The only rebellion we were faced with was the one begun by three Republican Senators-McCain, Graham and Warner. All three had served in the military, but McCain had actually spent time as a prisoner of war in North Viet Nam . Many of us cheered when he stood up to the President to say that if we permitted torture, which is what Bush and Cheney were trying to legalize, our own soldiers, sailors and airmen would be subject to the same brutalization as Mr. Bush was hoping to inflict on his "terror suspects." But the rebellion was quickly quelled when McCain, Graham and Warner caved in and said that the compromise they worked out with the President would both preserve our morals and get valuable information from enemy combatants. First, people who are experts in interrogation of the enemy pretty much agree that torture doesn't work. Those being tortured will say anything they think their interrogators want to hear, just so the torture will stop. Secondly, the information, even if true, which is rare, in virtually every case is outdated by the time the torture is finished. Certainly no enemy would continue with plans known to someone who was captured. But even more importantly, as Former Secretary of State and famous Army general, Colin Powell, said, we lose our moral high ground if we torture prisoners. To me, that is a hundred times more powerful a statement than the repetitious rantings of George W. Bush who continually cites the mantra, "we are protecting Americans." That phrase, of course, is born of polling that says Americans want to be protected, and delivered by the likes of Karl Rove, who, if nothing else, knows how to demagogue. But the hottest place in political hell should be reserved for members of Congress, including the weak-kneed Democrats, who essentially went along with Mr. Bush's "compromise." It did not seem to bother Senators and Representatives that the Writ of Habeas Corpus is being suspended for enemy combatants. There is now no way to learn whether or not the prisoner is indeed an enemy, or just someone who was gathered up in a sweep of foreigners in Afghanistan, because, without habeas corpus, their detention cannot be tested in a court. Senate Democrats, who in recent years have dug in to filibuster at the slightest provocation, this time merely stood up to record their opposition, knowing full well they would lose a straight up or down vote on the Bush compromise. But instead of really trying to stop the legislation, those who opposed it were content to make a speech and vote against it so they could later brag about their principled stand. Everyone knew that was the Bush/Rove strategy-bring it up just before the elections so you can accuse the opposition of being soft on terrorism. It worked with the Iraqi War resolution in 2002, so why not now? My wife, who is from the Middle East, in fact from a country that tortures its prisoners, was nearly in tears when, after hearing about the legislation, told me that everyone in her home country always looked up to America as a beacon of freedom. But those who loved America as an idea would now feel completely alone. President Bush continually says that, "they" hate us because of our freedoms. That may explain why, in this legislation and in the Patriot Act, he is, piece by piece, trying to remove our freedoms. If this is his idea of protecting Americans, we really can't stand much more protection. The public's opposition to this draconian law is the only thing that will give Congress the backbone to preserve our freedoms. James Abourezk served as the U.S. Congressman and Senator from South Dakota from 1973-1979. His memoir, Advise & Dissent: Memoirs of South Dakota and the U.S. Senate, was published in 1989. Abourezk founded the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee, and he is a signer of the Call from World Can't Wait-Drive Out the Bush Regime which is holding protests in over 150 cities on October 5, 2006.

Now Available from CounterPunch Books! The Case Against Israel By Michael Neumann Click Here to Order Michael Neumann's Devastating Rebuttal of Alan Dershowitz WHAT'S INSIDE Grand Theft Pentagon: Tales of Greed and Profiteering in the War on Terror by Jeffrey St. Clair   CounterPunch Speakers Bureau Sick of sit-on-the-Fence speakers, tongue-tied and timid? CounterPunch Editors Alexander Cockburn and Jeffrey St Clair are available to speak forcefully on ALL the burning issues, as are other CounterPunchers seasoned in stump oratory. Call CounterPunch Speakers Bureau, 1-800-840-3683. Or email beckyg@counterpunch.org. The Book on 9/11 the White House Denounced as "ABSOLUTE GARBAGE"