FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail

Criticism of Israel

by MICHAEL NEUMANN

Israel’s defenders, increasingly besieged, increasingly proclaim that antisemites hide behind criticism of Zionism or Israel.   This is quite true, but what sort of ‘hiding’ is involved?  Antisemites do not literally hide out of sight,  like a murderer in a dark alley.   They’re more like a robbers casing bank and posing as a ordinary customers, or pedophiles posing as child care workers.  They disguise themselves, striving to look like respectable critics when in fact they are nothing of the sort.  Their racism shrouds itself in criticism.

What does this say about critics of Israel?  Why is this such a good disguise?   Why have antisemites increasingly flocked to this strategy?

The answer lies partly in how disguise affects us.  Bank robbers hiding as customers don’t make us think there’s anything creepy about being a customer.   That’s why the pose remains a good disguise.  And if pedophiles do, perhaps, cast some suspicion on the role of child care worker, that’s almost tragic.   Real child care is a very necessary, honorable and laudable calling.   We need such people and they deserve our respect.

Even if every single bank robber masqueraded as a paying customer, and every single pedophile masqueraded as a child care worker, we’d have to keep one vital fact in mind.   The more-than-overwhelming majority of bank customers are not robbers and the more-than-overwhelming majority of child care workers are not pedophiles.  It is not merely out of fairness, but for the good of everyone that we never forget this.

These obvious truths help explain why criticism of Israel has become such a popular disguise among antisemites.

It didn’t used to be.  After all, for a long time there was no Israel.   Before its existence, many antisemites didn’t bother to disguise themselves.   When they did, it was usually as ethnic nationalists:  “I’m not antisemitic, I’m pro-German”.  Today, white racists often say something similar:  “I’m not anti-black, I’m pro-white”.   This is no longer respectable, though, oddly, “I’m not anti-Arab, I’m pro-Jewish” would probably still pass muster.   Certainly “I’m not anti-Arab, I’m pro-Israel” would do the trick.

Why the change?  It’s partly because, when ethnic nationalisms (except maybe Zionism) lost their respectability, they could no longer protect antisemites.  But, for decades, neither would criticism of Israel. “I’m not antisemitic, I’m anti-Israel” (or ‘anti-Zionist’) wouldn’t have got you very far in, say, 1948 or 1967.  Back then, being anti-Israel might sound good to many Middle Eastern people, but not to Americans or Europeans.   Israel was plucky, Israel was sacred, Israel was good.   Back then, Jewish UN officials like Richard Goldstone didn’t find Israel guilty of war crimes.  International heroes like Desmond Tutu didn’t tell us that Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians was worse than apartheid.

These admirable, unimpeachable testimonials were a turning point.  Antisemites have flocked to criticism of Israel precisely because criticism of Israel is so amply justified.   Criticism of Israel isn’t a great disguise because the critics are sleazebags.   Quite the contrary:  it’s  a great disguise because criticizing Israel is not only correct, it’s the right thing to do.   The more-than-overwhelming majority of those who criticize Israel are genuine humanitarians, genuine enemies of oppression and ethnic nationalism, genuine fighters for justice.  The more obvious this has become, the more antisemites get on board.

How then, can we unmask these posers?   Not, clearly, by attacking the genuine critics.   We don’t unmask pedophiles, one dearly hopes, by vilifying child care workers.   That would be crazy, a great loss to our society and indeed to the world.

Those who unmask the antisemitism of the white supremacist site Stormfront show us a saner, better approach.  It is to provide evidence that for antisemites, concern for the agonies of the Palestinians is not, as it is for the likes of Goldstone or Tutu, a priority.   It is an afterthought.   Stormfront was  founded by a former Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan and a member of the American Nazi Party.  It espoused antisemitism long before it became pro-Palestinian.   For Stormfront, championing the Palestinians is like Big Oil wanting to save the whales.  It’s the cynical exploitation of what more and more people see as a noble cause.

And so it is with other antisemites.   Ernst Zundel, David Irving and their ilk have no track record of horror at Israeli crimes, or of sympathy with the Palestinians.   They were blatant antisemites before they criticized Israel.   And if we suspect a critic of Israel might be antisemitic, we should ask:  did they seem antisemitic before they were critics?   Did they rail against Jews in some other context, perhaps with dark references to Jewish ascendancy ‘in Hollywood’, or ‘in the banks’?   Yes, antisemites very frequently masquerade as critics of Israel.   We should take great care to unmask them, so that the genuine critics can continue their valuable work.

MICHAEL NEUMANN is a professor of philosophy at a Canadian university.  He is the author of What’s Left: Radical Politics and the Radical Psyche and The Case Against Israel.  He also contributed the essay, “What is Anti-Semitism”, to CounterPunch’s book, The Politics of Anti-Semitism.  He can be reached at mneumann@live.com

 

Michael Neumann is a professor of philosophy at a Canadian university.  He is the author of What’s Left: Radical Politics and the Radical Psyche and The Case Against Israel.  He also contributed the essay, “What is Anti-Semitism”, to CounterPunch’s book, The Politics of Anti-Semitism.  He can be reached at mneumann@live.com

Weekend Edition
April 29, 2016
Friday - Sunday
Andrew Levine
What is the Democratic Party Good For? Absolutely Nothing
Roberto J. González – David Price
Anthropologists Marshalling History: the American Anthropological Association’s Vote on the Academic Boycott of Israeli Institutions
Robert Jacobs
Hanford, Not Fukushima, is the Big Radiological Threat to the West Coast
Ismael Hossein-Zadeh
US Presidential Election: Beyond Lesser Evilism
Dave Lindorff
The Push to Make Sanders the Green Party’s Candidate
Peter Linebaugh
Marymount, Haymarket, Marikana: a Brief Note Towards ‘Completing’ May Day
Ian Fairlie
Chernobyl’s Ongoing Toll: 40,000 More Cancer Deaths?
Pete Dolack
Verizon Sticks it to its Workers Because $45 Billion isn’t Enough
Moshe Adler
May Day: a Trade Agreement to Unite Third World and American Workers
Margaret Kimberley
Dishonoring Harriet Tubman
Deepak Tripathi
The United States, Britain and the European Union
Eva Golinger
My Country, My Love: a Conversation with Gerardo and Adriana of the Cuban Five
Richard Falk
If Obama Visits Hiroshima
Vijay Prashad
Political Violence in Honduras
Paul Krane
Where Gun Control Ought to Start: Disarming the Police
David Anderson
Al Jazeera America: Goodbye to All That Jazz
Rob Hager
Platform Perversity: More From the Campaign That Can’t Strategize
Pat Williams
FDR in Montana
Dave Marsh
Every Day I Read the Book (the Best Music Books of the Last Year)
David Rosen
Job Satisfaction Under Perpetual Stagnation
John Feffer
Big Oil isn’t Going Down Without a Fight
Murray Dobbin
The Canadian / Saudi Arms Deal: More Than Meets the Eye?
Gary Engler
The Devil Capitalism
Brian Cloughley
Is Washington Preparing for War Against Russia?
Manuel E. Yepe
The Big Lies and the Small Lies
Robert Fantina
Vice Presidents, Candidates and History
Mel Gurtov
Sanctions and Defiance in North Korea
Howard Lisnoff
Still the Litmus Test of Worth
Dean Baker
Big Business and the Overtime Rule: Irrational Complaints
Ulrich Heyden
Crimea as a Paradise for High-Class Tourism?
Ramzy Baroud
Did the Arabs Betray Palestine? – A Schism between the Ruling Classes and the Wider Society
Halyna Mokrushyna
The War on Ukrainian Scientists
Joseph Natoli
Who’s the Better Neoliberal?
Ron Jacobs
The Battle at Big Brown: Joe Allen’s The Package King
Wahid Azal
Class Struggle and Westoxication in Pahlavi Iran: a Review of the Iranian Series ‘Shahrzad’
David Crisp
After All These Years, Newspapers Still Needed
Graham Peebles
Hungry and Frightened: Famine in Ethiopia 2016
Robert Koehler
Opening the Closed Political Culture
Missy Comley Beattie
Waves of Nostalgia
Thomas Knapp
The Problem with Donald Trump’s Version of “America First”
Georgina Downs
Hillsborough and Beyond: Establishment Cover Ups, Lies & Corruption
Jeffrey St. Clair
Groove on the Tracks: the Magic Left Hand of Red Garland
Ben Debney
Kush Zombies: QELD’s Hat Tip to Old School Hip Hop
Charles R. Larson
Moby Dick on Steroids?
David Yearsley
Miles Davis: Ace of Baseness
FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail