FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail

Straw Dogs

by JAMES McENTEER

The controversy over Sonia Sotomayor’s Supreme Court nomination illustrates a fundamental problem with how mass media supposedly “inform” the American public about salient events.  To stir up interest (in themselves, mostly), media invite predictable opponents of any nominee to high office to attack that nominee.

Deep thinker Ann Coulter went on TV to call Sotomayor a racist. Revered statesman Newt Gingrich texted that same sentiment to various folk.  Media seemed less interested in his (typically mean and shallow) message than the fact that the old bozo had figured out how to text.  Resident network intellectual Pat Buchanan declared Sotomayor – Princeton summa cum laude and Yale law review – “not that smart.”

University of Utah dropout Karl Rove opined that there are lots of “stupid” Ivy League graduates.  Most people presume his long association with the Yale and Harvard alum George W. Bush taught him that.  Michael Goldfarb and other National Review types offered their carefully reasoned opposition.  Goldfarb objected to the way the Supreme Court nominee pronounces her own name, saying that “It Sticks In My Craw.”

Failed Republican presidential nominee Mike Huckabee called Sotomayor a nominee of the “far left.” Of course he also referred to her as “Maria,” throwing his own judgment into question.  And how about Democratic Senator Ben Nelson, who did not rule out a filibuster of the nomination, even before he learned who the nominee was?

The problem is not simply that media offer conduits to amplify the uninformed opinions of mindless political hacks, attention junkies so thoroughly unqualified to discuss Sotomayor’s legal history and philosophy that they must resort to racist, sexist name-calling.  There is seldom any effort to engage the blatant inaccuracy and stupidity of these unwelcome, all-too-familiar “critics.”

Coulter asked why liberals did not show the same empathy for the black Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas as they seem to demonstrate for the Latina Sonia Sotomayor.  No talking head pointed out that Sotomayor has decades of judicial experience while Thomas had none.  His was a cynical nomination by George H.W. Bush, as a less-than-mediocre right-wing replacement for the great jurist, Thurgood Marshall, simply because he was black.  Thomas also stood accused of sexual harassment, a charge he never refuted.  Instead he blamed the victim and shifted the debate to be about what he called a “high-tech lynching,” then wormed his way into lifetime office, past red-faced wishy-washy liberals including Kennedy and Biden.

Part of the problem is that most media-ready conservative spokespersons possess no substantive knowledge or moral credibility.  They are merely dependable attack dogs, foaming at the mouth.  Coulter routinely calls people fags and racists; Gingrich is a political thug who resigned in disgrace and profaned his marriages; Rove made a dishonorable career as an unprincipled scumbag.  We should demand accountability from the networks and print media who enable these vermin to spew their poison.

Rupert Murdoch deserves particular opprobrium.  He provides Rove’s venomous bile outlets in The Wall Street Journal and on Fox News, where Rove joins Hannity, O’Reilly, Beck and other numbskulls, whose vitriol and histrionics substitute for reasoned discourse. Murdoch’s media empire has done more to distort, degrade and dumb down the American democratic process than Tom DeLay, Lee Harvey Oswald and Rush Limbaugh put together.  Any sense of civic responsibility mass media ever displayed toward the national political conversation has long since been superceded by a meretricious urge to peddle outrage for profit, no matter how tasteless or untrue.

The dimunition of the Republican Party – which staked all on its radical right wing – and the impoverishment of political discourse in our country have fed each other’s decline.  The spectacle of politicians sacrificing political ideals for personal ambition is neither new nor surprising.  But Rove and Cheney have taken that to new levels, trashing not only all Republican ideals, but Constitutional principles and human decency as well, routinely debasing language and governance with lies and character assassination to maintain their power.  They now have the chutzpah to use the complaisant whorish media to condemn the petty sins of the Obama administration.  They should answer for their transgressions in a court of law, not on Fox News Sunday.

TV has long been trapped in an oppositional format.  Conflict makes for drama.  Actual intelligent discussion is too boring.  If somebody is not shot or defamed every thirty seconds the audience may turn the channel.  It’s amazing that millions of human beings still tune into this trash.  But Murdoch and his ilk are not merely polluters. They are perverts, deforming issues and reputations for money.  Already a billionaire, Murdoch, 78, clearly cares nothing about the cultural and political damage he wreaks, or the devastation he will leave behind.  His straw dogs, on and off his payroll – all trashy bark and no substance – will continue to provide the lowest common denominator for political discussion in our country until we have the will to turn them off.

JAMES McENTEER is the author of Shooting the Truth: the Rise of American Political Documentaries (Praeger 2006). He lives in Cochabamba, Bolivia.

James McEnteer’s most recent book is Acting Like It Matters: John Malpede and the Los Angeles Poverty DepartmentHe lives in Quito, Ecuador.

Weekend Edition
April 29-31, 2016
Jeffrey St. Clair
Groove on the Tracks: the Magic Left Hand of Red Garland
Ben Debney
Kush Zombies: QELD’s Hat Tip to Old School Hip Hop
Charles R. Larson
Moby Dick on Steroids?
April 28, 2016
Miguel A. Cruz Díaz
Puerto Rico: a Junta By Any Other Name
Alfredo Lopez
Where the Bern is Fizzling: Why Sanders Can’t Win the Support of People of Color
Peter Linebaugh
The Commons and the Centennial of the Easter Rising
Dan Arel
What Next? Can the #Movement4Bernie Accomplish Anything?
John Wight
An Indictment of Thatcher’s Legacy: Justice for Hillsborough Families, at Last
Bob Lord
Inequality Will Increase Until There’s a Revolution
Cathy Breen
Kurdistan: Can We Feel the Heat?
Nicolai Petro
Odessa: Averting Another Massacre
Doug Johnson Hatlem
On Open Marriages and Closed Elections
Polly Hughes
Rev. Pinkney was Right: It’s Comin’ to Your City Next!
Manuel E. Yepe
The People of the USA will Have the Final Word
Rebecca Green
How Big Money in Politics Fuels Inequality and War
Sam Husseini
Could Voters Opposed to Both Clinton and Trump Team up Using VotePact?
Franklin Lamb
Can Responsibility to Protect Preserve our Cultural Heritage in Syria?
Carl Finamore
SF College Faculty Strike for Justice Stop Class Reductions & Pay Cuts
Binoy Kampmark
The Failed Cruz-Kasich Pact: Donald Trump and GOP Desperation
Terry Simons
Hillary Clinton is DINO-mite to the Billionaires
April 27, 2016
John Stauber
#FeelTheBern Goes #UpInSmoke
Pepe Escobar
Hillary: Wall Street’s Golden Girl
Lawrence Ware – Lauren Whiteman
Tell the Negroes to Wait: Obama, Black Lives Matter, and Compromising with White Supremacy
James McEnteer
Ecuador: the Geopolitics of Generosity
Gareth Porter
The Classified ’28 Pages’: a Diversion From Real US-Saudi Issues
Katie Fite
Toxic Range: the BLM’s Growing Chemical Addiction
Kevin Grandia - Brendan DeMelle
Exxon Knew CO2 Pollution Was A Global Threat By Late 1970s
Maidhc Ó Cathail
Likud Becomes a Regional Member of the European Parliament
Peter Lee
US Pivot to Asia Poised to Enter Nuclear Phase
Franklin Spinney
Pentagon Gong Show
Jesse Jackson
Rahm AWOL on Chicago Police Reform
Sam Jojola
Grizzly Bear Reintroduction vs. Multiple Conflicts and Political Land Grab
Binoy Kampmark
Anzac Day Memories: The Sullen Child of History
Jonathan Latham
God’s Red Pencil? CRISPR and The Three Myths of Precise Genome Editing
April 26, 2016
Mary Anne Henderson – Brian Platt
More Than a Few Rogue Cops: the Disturbing History of Police in Schools
Manuel E. Yepe
The Return of the Coup in Latin America
Maria Dyveke Styve
An Ode to the Death of Europe and a Concerned Love Letter to Žižek
Doug Johnson Hatlem
To Clear the Air, Sanders Should Challenge New York Vote
Paul Craig Roberts
Washington Launches Its Attack Against BRICS
Patrick Cockburn
Saudi Arabia and 9/11: the Kingdom May be in For a Nasty Shock
Sam Gordon
In / Out: Which Way for the European Union?
Jack Smith
The Future of US / Cuban Relations
James Rothenberg
Sanders’ Choice
Binoy Kampmark
Meddlesome Empire: Obama and Client Britain’s EU Referendum
Halyna Mokrushyna
Left-wing, Antiwar Voice in Ukraine Assaulted by Rightist Extremists
FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmail